Dance of Time and Illusion ( Episode Analysis)Part 30updated DTNTPg131 - Page 99

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

77.6k

Users

64

Likes

4.7k

Frequent Posters

Darciny thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Darciny I hate hypocrisy and I make no bones out of it. For me Saanjh and Vandana are hypocrites. Maya is bad, I accept that. She needs to be punished I also accept that. But whatever Maya did doesnt lighten the wrongs these two women are doing in the name of we know it all.

You have to feel life, you have to feel pain to understand why certain people do certain things. Atleast one chance needs to be given to the person to explain themselves before making judgement. Even our judiciary gives that to the worst criminal. But VM didnt give it to Maya. She showed zero empathy to a girl who fell on her feet. Saanjh told she is Maya's friend, but didnt have the courtesy to tell a thank you to her when she protected her from fire, instead hugged her husband.

These 2 women say one thing and do another thing. They didnt get what they wanted, so they can also go beyhadh to get what they want. That is Arjun for Saanjh.

Maya is a criminal, but I am unable to hate her. I am simply unable to. I want her to be punished and I want that to happen at the earliest because she is a risk, a serious threat to herself and others. But she is a woman of situations, a child who lost her innocence at 9.

Once again I tell what Maya did if we get proofs can be punished under IPC. Indian Penal Code has provisions to punish her. But Vandana and Saanjh are doing, IPC cannot see, IPC cannot punish because that crime can only be felt not seen.


Well Vandana had been an awful mother in law and there's no doubt about it. Even if she had reasons to believe that Maya is wrong for her son, her methods were extremely wrong and outright disgusting. But then haven't she been punished enough for her deeds? She lost both her sons. She has also been subjected to physical torture.

And Saanjh, yes she should have been grateful to Maya when Maya saved her from the fire. But for me, her actions portray a girl who is hopelessly in love with her childhood best friend and is now having a tough time to move ahead in life. She is no doubt, a very 'clingy' woman who has no other ambitions in life. But her intentions regarding Arjun seems genuine to me. She is not thinking of separating a happily married couple but she is trying to save her childhood best friend trapped in a toxic relationship


Anyways, differences of opinions will always arise especially in shows like this which test your moral values. Though we may not necessarily agree with each other's opinion, it's good to have a healthy discussion without it turning into a warzone.
😊
aekiel thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Darciny I hate hypocrisy and I make no bones out of it. For me Saanjh and Vandana are hypocrites. Maya is bad, I accept that. She needs to be punished I also accept that. But whatever Maya did doesnt lighten the wrongs these two women are doing in the name of we know it all.

You have to feel life, you have to feel pain to understand why certain people do certain things. Atleast one chance needs to be given to the person to explain themselves before making judgement. Even our judiciary gives that to the worst criminal. But VM didnt give it to Maya. She showed zero empathy to a girl who fell on her feet. Saanjh told she is Maya's friend, but didnt have the courtesy to tell a thank you to her when she protected her from fire, instead hugged her husband.

These 2 women say one thing and do another thing. They didnt get what they wanted, so they can also go beyhadh to get what they want. That is Arjun for Saanjh.

Maya is a criminal, but I am unable to hate her. I am simply unable to. I want her to be punished and I want that to happen at the earliest because she is a risk, a serious threat to herself and others. But she is a woman of situations, a child who lost her innocence at 9.

Once again I tell what Maya did if we get proofs can be punished under IPC. Indian Penal Code has provisions to punish her. But Vandana and Saanjh are doing, IPC cannot see, IPC cannot punish because that crime can only be felt not seen.



Shruti, I used to comment on your threads a long while back, and then somewhere your views went on a completely different track, one I couldn't quite bring myself to identify with.

Nevertheless, you're entitled to your opinions, and I believe in "live and let live", so simply stopped responding on your threads.

Just responding this once because Darciny's question was something that I had too, but never bothered to ask, because the analysis you did reflected your lines of thought (the same what you've replied above)

I simply believe, you're holding Maya to a lesser standard because you've accepted her for what she is, and that makes you to see her actions in a more justifiable light.

On the contrary, you hold Vandana and Saanjh to far, far higher standards, and do not allow them the benefit of normal human mistakes. To feel the temptation of a mistake is human, but to not act on it, requires strength and mental fortitude, and that's where Saanjh's been reasonably good.

You believe that Maya would've changed if Vandana had accepted her begging at her feet- I'm not so sure, given her previous dialogues of "How does it matter" and Arjun has to live at my house only" when asked by Jhanvi about whether Arjun loved her. Maya's brain is wired in a way that sooner or later, she would've found VM and Ayaan troublesome (remember her reaction when Arjun said Ayaan is his "jaan"?), and would've found a way to separate Arjun from his family.

You mention Saanjh not thanking her for saving her, but didn't think about what Maya did to get Saanjh out of the way for the wedding, and Saanjh's actions after that (including buying honeymoon tickets out of her own money, and decorating the house for their arrival).

And they say, a first impression is a last impression- Vandana's first impression of Maya was the girl who broke the glass on seeing Arjun and Saanjh together.


anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
There is no harm in empathising with that 9 year old little girl...but as @Darciny has pointed out why so much hate for Saanjh and Vandana..Although we all are allowed to have our own opinions.
I just feel that Saanjh doesn't want to separate Maya and Arjun and want Arjun for herself...she thinks that Maya is a threat and wants to help Arjun out and she is going to the house to get proof of Ayaan's innocence.
She herself admitted to Samay that she can never forget Arjun but is TRYING to move on.
She never once has said that Arjun doesn't matter anymore or she had forgotten him.

Vandana also wants to save Ayaan and she thinks and has seen that Maya is dangerous and thus wants to take Arjun away from her.

Vandana's behaviour with Maya was shameful and no one can defend that.
But she openly admitted that she disliked Maya and didn't want her as her daughter in law.

Both Vandana and Saanjh have been pretty direct when it comes to confronting Maya...in my opinion they are not hypocrites.

Now they are playing a game with Maya and trying to beat her in her own game which is not going to be easy.

Maya also plays games...she becomes a victim in front of Arjun while behind him she plays her games.

One can also say that Maya is also hypocrite then in that case.

One should think from their prespective as well

Both have already suffered and paid for their mistakes...Vandana has lost his sons and Saanjh is engaged to an obsessed guy whom Maya had sent to keep Saanjh away from Arjun.

The show hasn't shown that Saanjh wants to destroy a married couple's life...she wants to save Ayaan and what everything she has seen so far she knows that Maya is dangerous.

Also I read that u had compared Maa Kali with Maya...I just feel that Maa Kali was the destroyer of evil forced and not sure how can she be compared with Maya coz Maya herself is commiting crimes.
I didn't get ur comparison at all.

It is great that u deeply analyise the show.

In my opinion analysis are always better if they include all perspectives rather than a single character's perspective.

In my opinion Maya is going to get more dark and her obsession for Arjun will increase and she is going to cross all limits.
Saanjh and Vandana will try to bring out the truth that Maya is ill and needs help and was responsible for Ashwin's death and for framing Ayaan.
Arjun is going to go away from her.
Samay coz of his recklessness will prove to be a hurdle for Maya...he is an obsessed man and his recklessness will pose a threat for Maya as he might try to harm Arjun...he will die at some point of the story.
And in the end it will be proven that excess of everythign is harmful even LOVE.

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
@Darciny I dont keep Vandana and Saanjh at high standards, they themselves keep them at higher standard. So I judge them from the perspective of God. Saanjh goes and questions God. Why you did this to me, give orders to God, what is written for me give it to Maya. Now Vandana she tells Maya is bad and mad. On what basis, horoscope, what Ashwin told. What are the proofs she had when she made judgement and then did her actions. So when you behave I know all, you will be judged with the standard of judging God. Your actions has to be impeccable. You are not allowed human mistakes. To allow human mistakes you have to behave like humans. That's my take.
@aekiel I guess I have given the reply above

@anshvi I feel more than I see. I can only tell Samay will take Maya. Samay and Maya will go. I am more interested in the track that happens post Samay taking Maya. Need to see where everyone stands. What is the equation post that. Real fun is that track. For me Maya the girl and Maya the metaphor is the centre of Beyhadh script. So I prefer to analyze from the centre point. That is my way of doing it. It can be good, it can be bad, but then that's how I prefer to do it.
Edited by shruthiravi - 8 years ago
sumz_d thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: anshvi

There is no harm in empathising with that 9 year old little girl...but as @Darciny has pointed out why so much hate for Saanjh and Vandana..Although we all are allowed to have our own opinions.

I just feel that Saanjh doesn't want to separate Maya and Arjun and want Arjun for herself...she thinks that Maya is a threat and wants to help Arjun out and she is going to the house to get proof of Ayaan's innocence.
She herself admitted to Samay that she can never forget Arjun but is TRYING to move on.
She never once has said that Arjun doesn't matter anymore or she had forgotten him.

Vandana also wants to save Ayaan and she thinks and has seen that Maya is dangerous and thus wants to take Arjun away from her.

Vandana's behaviour with Maya was shameful and no one can defend that.
But she openly admitted that she disliked Maya and didn't want her as her daughter in law.

Both Vandana and Saanjh have been pretty direct when it comes to confronting Maya...in my opinion they are not hypocrites.

Now they are playing a game with Maya and trying to beat her in her own game which is not going to be easy.

Maya also plays games...she becomes a victim in front of Arjun while behind him she plays her games.

One can also say that Maya is also hypocrite then in that case.

One should think from their prespective as well

Both have already suffered and paid for their mistakes...Vandana has lost his sons and Saanjh is engaged to an obsessed guy whom Maya had sent to keep Saanjh away from Arjun.

The show hasn't shown that Saanjh wants to destroy a married couple's life...she wants to save Ayaan and what everything she has seen so far she knows that Maya is dangerous.

Also I read that u had compared Maa Kali with Maya...I just feel that Maa Kali was the destroyer of evil forced and not sure how can she be compared with Maya coz Maya herself is commiting crimes.
I didn't get ur comparison at all.

It is great that u deeply analyise the show.

In my opinion analysis are always better if they include all perspectives rather than a single character's perspective.

In my opinion Maya is going to get more dark and her obsession for Arjun will increase and she is going to cross all limits.
Saanjh and Vandana will try to bring out the truth that Maya is ill and needs help and was responsible for Ashwin's death and for framing Ayaan.
Arjun is going to go away from her.
Samay coz of his recklessness will prove to be a hurdle for Maya...he is an obsessed man and his recklessness will pose a threat for Maya as he might try to harm Arjun...he will die at some point of the story.
And in the end it will be proven that excess of everythign is harmful even LOVE.



Maya killed Ashwin who was an angel?
Maya framed Ayaan who was doing aarti of Maya?

The thing is Maya only harms those who are not innocent. However in the future episodes Maya might as well go darker.

After the holi incident Saanjh shamelessly and openly confronts Maya and asked what was wrong that she danced with her husband. Not once Saanjh saw her own fault or felt anything wrong by doing that tamasha with Arjun who is Married man for crying out loud!

Not only that she had also called Arjun in a hotel to meet and made Arjun lie to Maya. Wasn't this also wrong?

Vandana mata had no empathy for Maya since the beginning even after all that good things that Maya did for her family. Instead to chose to believe a person like Ashwin.

Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. This is karma's law.
What matters is who starts the action. Its both Saanjh and Vandana who had unnecessarily started doing "Wrong" actions out of which Maya reacted "Wrong"


shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
@sumz we only see the reactions, not the actions that leads to those reactions. That's why it is said act in any situation than react. When Arjun is touched Maya reacts and that is her Achilles heel. Act when he is touched. Just leave him and go. Which this woman cannot do as she is so insecure.
aekiel thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Darciny I dont keep Vandana and Saanjh at high standards, they themselves keep them at higher standard. So I judge them from the perspective of God. Saanjh goes and questions God. Why you did this to me, give orders to God, what is written for me give it to Maya. Now Vandana she tells Maya is bad and mad. On what basis, horoscope, what Ashwin told. What are the proofs she had when she made judgement and then did her actions. So when you behave I know all, you will be judged with the standard of judging God. Your actions has to be impeccable. You are not allowed human mistakes. To allow human mistakes you have to behave like humans. That's my take.



Sorry to say, but that's a very lame looking reason.

Vandana and Saanjh have never claimed that they are "godly/mahaan" or "don't do mistakes", so to judge them from that angle looks very unreasonable.

If you want to judge them with the standard of judging God, give them the powers that God has- certainly they're showing that they're human with the silly ways they're trying to dig out evidence at Maya's house. 😉 If anything, Maya seems to be the all-knowing, powerful one here.

Even you'll agree that if you keep an average, peace loving person as the base, Saanjh and Vandana are more likely to meet that criteria. Maya obviously does not, because her brain is wired in a different way. So they might be better than Maya, that certainly does not make them God- just that they are better, more reasonable humans.

Hold everyone to the same standards, that's all I'd say.



Edited by aekiel - 8 years ago
anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: sumz_d



Maya killed Ashwin who was an angel?
Maya framed Ayaan who was doing aarti of Maya?

The thing is Maya only harms those who are not innocent. However in the future episodes Maya might as well go darker.

After the holi incident Saanjh shamelessly and openly confronts Maya and asked what was wrong that she danced with her husband. Not once Saanjh saw her own fault or felt anything wrong by doing that tamasha with Arjun who is Married man for crying out loud!

Not only that she had also called Arjun in a hotel to meet and made Arjun lie to Maya. Wasn't this also wrong?

Vandana mata had no empathy for Maya since the beginning even after all that good things that Maya did for her family. Instead to chose to believe a person like Ashwin.

Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. This is karma's law.
What matters is who starts the action. Its both Saanjh and Vandana who had unnecessarily started doing "Wrong" actions out of which Maya reacted "Wrong"



Completely disagree wid ur post !

The thing that Maya harm's those who are not innocent is absolutely not true !
Again as I said all perspectives should be considered

Maya tied drugged Arjun that was right ? Ayaan saw his brother in that state and Maya manipulated his vice...instigated him..Ayaan was wrong to use abusive words...but so was Maya infact she was more wrong in this situation...she framed Ayaan for a crime he did not commit and used Samay in the process...so saying that Ayaan was not innocent doesn't justify Maya's actions at all!
What she did is a punishable crime!

Also killing someone is a crime and cannot be justified.
Ashwin was a monster and there is no doubt about it...but I do not justify Maya killing him.
If it was self defence it could have been understood.

If we all think this way and start talking about karma then in that case we can all go on a killing spree...but it is the not the case...no one has the right to take anyone's life in my opinion...there is court for that matter and above there is God.

Also no one is saying that Vandana and Saanjh are white characters or Goddesses...they are human and they have paid for their mistakes too . I do not justify their wrong actions and same goes for Maya
I in not any case can justify her wrong actions !

And if every action has an equal reaction then what should happen to Maya?
Should Ayaan now frame her in a false case
Or Vandana should torture her
Or Jhanvi should kill Arjun coz she killed Ashwin.




Edited by anshvi - 8 years ago
sumz_d thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@sumz we only see the reactions, not the actions that leads to those reactions. That's why it is said act in any situation than react. When Arjun is touched Maya reacts and that is her Achilles heel. Act when he is touched. Just leave him and go. Which this woman cannot do as she is so insecure.


Exactly Di..
If a good person has the Power to bring in change for humanity's sake, then that person should Use their power.
If a good person doesn't use the power then that is also considered wrong in God's eyes.

There was only one positive step that VM and Saanjh ought to do, but instead they pushed Maya more in the dark. And now both VM and Saanjh act like they are angels.

Edited by sumz_d - 8 years ago
sumz_d thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: anshvi


Completely disagree wid ur post !

The thing that Maya harm's those who are not innocent is absolutely not true !
Again as I said all perspectives should be considered

Maya tied drugged Arjun that was right ? Ayaan saw his brother in that state and Maya manipulated his vice...instigated him..Ayaan was wrong to use abusive words...but so was Maya infact she was more wrong in this situation...she framed Ayaan for a crime he did not commit and used Samay in the process...so saying that Ayaan was not innocent doesn't justify Maya's actions at all!
What she did is a punishable crime!

Also killing someone is a crime and cannot be justified.
Ashwin was a monster and there is no doubt about it...but I do not justify Maya killing him.
If it was self defence it could have been understood.

If we all think this way and start talking about karma then in that case we can all go on a killing spree...but it is the not the case...no one has the right to take anyone's life in my opinion...there is court for that matter and above there is God.

Also no one is saying that Vandana and Saanjh are white characters or Goddesses...they are human and they have paid for their mistakes too . I do not justify their wrong actions and same goes for Maya
I in not any case can justify her wrong actions !

And if every action has an equal reaction then what should happen to Maya?
Should Ayaan now frame her in a false case
Or Vandana should torture her
Or Jhanvi should kill Arjun coz she killed Ashwin.





Arjun pushing Maya and manhandling Maya was that also right?

So you mean to say that whatever those filthy words that Ayaan spoke was due to Maya's instigation? So if Ayaan tears and Manhandles Maya due to Maya's own instigation it is not bad because he was "INSTIGATED"

So in that case Maya is also not wrong. She was also "INSTIGATED" by VM, and Saanjh gang.

So you see it all boils down to Vandana and Saanjh being the root cause of all the wrong things.

Now try to see things from Maya's perspective. She had tried her level best to be accepted by VM. She had even begged to her but what did VM do to her? She didn't even give one chance to Maya. Saanjh did not ever see her own wrong doings instead she shamelessly confronted to Maya. Heck even Saanjh's own mum could see what Saanjh was trying to do in the past but not once Saanjh saw her mistake.

And yes Maya will be punished by the law of karma but not only Maya all will be punished

Only one positive step was all that demanded in the past.
One positive step would have changed the whole situation.

Edited by sumz_d - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".