Myopic vision led to Colors downfall - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

91

Views

9.1k

Users

25

Likes

370

Frequent Posters

shabla thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: Winnertakesital

I have visited this forum since March. Never made my account to write or discuss as all of you discussed everything in detail

I am on twitter. So tweet and let go. Half of twitter is sense and other half nonsense.

I have watched shows on Sony. For this channel Ekta and Gul had to go through a different route.

do u agree everything was perfect in Bepannaah ? So many posts where members hated tracks, episodes and left mid way.

I did watch DMG, humsafars and Bepannaah ( dmg was pretty young to analyse). All these came with a bang and fell in between.

Humsafars was flawed from the begining. Only Vibha Chibber and Harshad Chopda did their jobs.

Bepannaah also had its share of technical flaws. I could not understand why a pilot who pumped in 5 crs paid off all debtors to trouble the FL. The manner in which Zosh got contracts was also defective. Aditya Hooda trying to create a fake marriage was child's play. No parallels at all.

Who wrote these tracks ? Cinevistaa or colors

The way this show was promoted it is clear they wanted numbers and not story

i also read Harshad's iv. He too thinks like Anirudh. Both sound two sides of d same coin.

No doubt the creator created a great story but it wad not implemented properly since the begining or i can say after the 1st week

.It looked like it ought to be on Sony and the channel which aired Bepannaah was also a wrong choice.


finally...u r in this forum since march n now u made an account...achi baath hai...and ur from twitter...yeh toh sone pe suhaga hai..daire aayea lekin durusthe aaya...gud thing...at least ab tho mulaakat huwi aapse...waise at one look u sound lik an MID...kiski tht only u knws...leave it anyways...

now u wnt ekta n gul to take different route...kaun sa wala route...yeh tho aapne bola hi nahi...google map mein milega route shayad...bcz naagin its abt time to change skin n ujala lady is evn struggling to breathe...

And if u dnt knw abt why Adithya helped or troubled zoya or abt fake marriage thn sweety i doubt how much u have evn watched tis show...

And thn channel wanted numbers i agree tht...it was a costly shw tho numbers where sufficient...but purposefully ill treating a show which had great story...not acceptable at all...

ppl hated tracks n left mid way..again agreed...but as u r in twitter defo u might hav seen same ppl regreting their decision...as u say wht is done cannot be reversed...

And no idea abt DMG n HS but BP cam with a bang and went with a bang with a hand full of popular awards...no more proof needed fr tht...

And yaar woh one line wala reply na zyada convenient tha..ya thanks alot u decided to grace our forum finally...show end huwa phir bhi aap ka pyar barkarar hai..v missed u terribly...
Edited by shabla - 6 years ago
Winnertakesital thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#42

I wanna say one thing I don't know who are u from where u come whatever u say na here say same thing infroin of harshad n rahi Humsafar ki baat even u saw agar saw na see first 30-35 epi that was directed by Ani sir n u are saying about bepannah u know what we don't own u its better baksh do Hume n hamare dost ko...God bless u

😕

What happened ?


Harshad is great actor !! Deserves the best

Yes i saw humsafars. If they had shown Sahir and Arzoo's past accha rehta. He had a wife who was in coma. His struggle. A glimpse of the past. Lekin that is history now.

Coming to Bepannaah, appreciation ke sath critical reviews was also done on episdoes and tracks without any discrimination. If members did not like anything. All were vocal. Yes if they were good then lots of a pat on the cvs back was given on this forum

Bas itna hi.

PS : was giving Harshad a compliment, he does sound like his creator who won't compromise with his stories.
Edited by Winnertakesital - 6 years ago
Winnertakesital thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: shabla


finally...u r in this forum since march n now u made an account...achi baath hai...and ur from twitter...yeh toh sone pe suhaga hai..daire aayea lekin durusthe aaya...gud thing...at least ab tho mulaakat huwi aapse...waise at one look u sound lik an MID...kiski tht only u knws...leave it anyways...

now u wnt ekta n gul to take different route...kaun sa wala route...yeh tho aapne bola hi nahi...google map mein milega route shayad...bcz naagin its abt time to change skin n ujala lady is evn struggling to breathe...

And if u dnt knw abt why Adithya helped or troubled zoya or abt fake marriage thn sweety i doubt how much u have evn watched tis show...

And thn channel wanted numbers i agree tht...it was a costly shw tho numbers where sufficient...but purposefully ill treating a show which had great story...not acceptable at all...

ppl hated tracks n left mid way..again agreed...but as u r in twitter defo u might hav seen same ppl regreting their decision...as u say wht is done cannot be reversed...

And no idea abt DMG n HS but BP cam with a bang and went with a bang with a hand full of popular awards...no more proof needed fr tht...

And yaar woh one line wala reply na zyada convenient tha..ya thanks alot u decided to grace our forum finally...show end huwa phir bhi aap ka pyar barkarar hai..v missed u terribly...


Itna na karo mujhe pyaar Ronit Roy and Pallvi Kulkarni. This one was good in comparision ro Naagin and the rest which is currently on air.

Gul tried to showcase broken characters through humsafars.

A reality check for two producers who can dwell on fantasy cum drama.

So with Sony they too had to change their outlook. The difference was Gul's show ran for 106 and Ektas 200. Yes both weren't their soap factory churned soaps. This was d route i spoke abt.

Bp had its ups and downs

Yeh MID kya hai by the way ??
Edited by Winnertakesital - 6 years ago
Kiruravi thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: romancefan

Unless one is a regular viewer of ITV, it is not easy to spot instances of interference in a story. I'm not Indian and have not watched many Hindi dramas, so i'm not an expert at spotting when a story has deviated from the original script. Unless the deviations are very obvious and look out of place, like the snake in Zoya's wedding garland. BP has many foreign audience so this Channel interference is quite puzzling to them. They often don't understand these fights over lack of Creative freedom and hence end up blaming the poor Writers Pakriti and Ishita who got bashed badly on twitter.

I have read several comments here on this forum who bashed Ani and Cinevistaas for coming up with lousy and boring episodes . They also wanted Harshad and Jen not to work with this ph again. One of them even said that DMG, Humsafars and BP all had good beginnings and fell badly in the middle cos they had Anirudh at the helm. Don't know if the allegations are fair or not, but if these Creative differences are aired openly, the fans would not be pointing fingers at the wrong people. Just my 2 cents.


Fans who are observing the show frm the beginning can easily find where channel had interfered and where not!! Every show has a grp of fans who bashes the show always irrespective of tracks shown and BP too had such kind of fans. And i didnt see any fans on IF comparing DMG HS and BP may b u would have noticed it.

I wanna say one thing ani sir had story to tell problem is not with ani sir but with stupid ITV trp audience and with trp system. If some fans feel all the 3 shows of ani sir started well and inbetween got messed up then they have to blame the trp system because of this stupid system good quality shows are suffocating and forced to change the script inbetween by the channel.

Every show has certain boring trcks or irritating trcks and fans need to have patience during such phases..ek shows gul shows are showing all nonsense and ott elements still fans watch their shows because they have patience.

Ani sir and PH behaved professionally because berangu though was unprofessional gave the platform and a good launch to the show so both of them thanked and didnt say abt politics.

I guess u knw what online and IF members are hoping now, many of them understood the depth of the story and complimenting the crew. Fans who are blaming ani sir are in minority.
Edited by Kiruravi - 6 years ago
Kiruravi thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: Winnertakesital

I have visited this forum since March. Never made my account to write or discuss as all of you discussed everything in detail

I am on twitter. So tweet and let go. Half of twitter is sense and other half nonsense.

I have watched shows on Sony. For this channel Ekta and Gul had to go through a different route.

do u agree everything was perfect in Bepannaah ? So many posts where members hated tracks, episodes and left mid way.

I did watch DMG, humsafars and Bepannaah ( dmg was pretty young to analyse). All these came with a bang and fell in between.

Humsafars was flawed from the begining. Only Vibha Chibber and Harshad Chopda did their jobs.

Bepannaah also had its share of technical flaws. I could not understand why a pilot who pumped in 5 crs paid off all debtors to trouble the FL. The manner in which Zosh got contracts was also defective. Aditya Hooda trying to create a fake marriage was child's play. No parallels at all.

Who wrote these tracks ? Cinevistaa or colors

The way this show was promoted it is clear they wanted numbers and not story

i also read Harshad's iv. He too thinks like Anirudh. Both sound two sides of d same coin.

No doubt the creator created a great story but it wad not implemented properly since the begining or i can say after the 1st week

.It looked like it ought to be on Sony and the channel which aired Bepannaah was also a wrong choice.


Everything was not perfect with bepannaah..nobody was saying tht bp was perfect..but was a much better show when compared to all other shows . It had beautiful story and wonderful cast and grt team.

u didnt find parallels in BP well it is ur perspective but majority of fans knw how many beautiful meaningful parallels bp had. Every show has certain boring or out of place trcks and also cliche trcks so do BP. But what matters is whether the whole basic crux of the story is kept intact or not bp kept its raw storyline intact and also kept the essence.

Channel did interfere with the storyline everybdy knw this and played with the timeslots like a pingpong ball which affected the show more.

Harshad and ani sir are ppl who give importance to scripts story hence they didnt compromise with the story.

Also there is something called trp pressure which ruins good quality shows, just to get trps shows are forced to change scripts inbetween. Even after facing all these problems ani sir and Creatives tried their best to keep the crux of the story which i can confidently say none of other itv shows can never do!!


Edited by Kiruravi - 6 years ago
mystique_4008 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: Winnertakesital

I have visited this forum since March. Never made my account to write or discuss as all of you discussed everything in detail

I am on twitter. So tweet and let go. Half of twitter is sense and other half nonsense.

I have watched shows on Sony. For this channel Ekta and Gul had to go through a different route.

do u agree everything was perfect in Bepannaah ? So many posts where members hated tracks, episodes and left mid way.

I did watch DMG, humsafars and Bepannaah ( dmg was pretty young to analyse). All these came with a bang and fell in between.

Humsafars was flawed from the begining. Only Vibha Chibber and Harshad Chopda did their jobs.

Bepannaah also had its share of technical flaws. I could not understand why a pilot who pumped in 5 crs paid off all debtors to trouble the FL. The manner in which Zosh got contracts was also defective. Aditya Hooda trying to create a fake marriage was child's play. No parallels at all.

Who wrote these tracks ? Cinevistaa or colors

The way this show was promoted it is clear they wanted numbers and not story

i also read Harshad's iv. He too thinks like Anirudh. Both sound two sides of d same coin.

No doubt the creator created a great story but it wad not implemented properly since the begining or i can say after the 1st week

.It looked like it ought to be on Sony and the channel which aired Bepannaah was also a wrong choice.




Nobody ever said Bepannaah was a perfect show. It had its fair share of flaws but overall it was much better than majority of the indian tv shows running. clearly you never and still don't understand the crux of the story. I do agree with you that the show should have been on Sony. But who knows if that channel would have been
able to afford jenshad since
both are highly paid actors. And I guess the PH were not looking towards Sony as an option since the producer of cinevistas said in an old interview their company is open to working with all channels. I seriously doubt whether colors wanted numbers. From the 3rd week onwards they started episodes late, by end of May timeslot changed to 9:30, then in September again change slot to 10:30 but only in the 1st week they started on time after that episodes started 15 mins late. Funny how you mentioned you have been visiting this forum since start of show yet only made an account after it went off air 😊
Edited by Cherryfairy - 6 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#47
What is the different approach of ekta and gul. I didnt quite understand your point. I am an Indian TV watcher from 90s. I have seen enough good scripts, good stories. Then these two ladies came and created cut copy paste dramas. I have not seen any different approach in them. Theme might change. Supernatural, broken family etc, just go close u will see cut copy paste of previous shows.
Then you are mentioning fake marriage track is child's play. Oh really. I didnt know you were a writer who have published so many stories, novels etc. Could you please let me know some of your works so that I can check the difference between child's play and real genius work. I really would love to understand the genius work because for me I respect an art and the artist because a lot of effort goes into creating something. It will have flaws and of course BP had its share of flaws but it was a beautiful story with its flaws. But since you found it child's play I would love to read some of your works.

@romancefan I do not know about DMG and HS. I have not watched both. Since you tell you are not watcher of Indian shows do you think it is right to form opinion just based on some views on director alone. Dont you think you need to read a bit, understand the industry a bit before going bashing script writers. We are mature people and we should show maturity. Or they should ask Indian fans who are regular soap watchers what is happening. Whether in TW, whether in IF or any online media portal there were enough impartial viewers who were giving valid criticisms. Who were understanding the problems. It is not the fault of Ani Sir or anyone concerned that some people read half baked information and go and bash script writers. In no industry dirty linen is washed in public. It is solved internally. But outside viewers do give impartial reviews. That's what journalist do. They give their view. They take the opinions outside. So that concerned people can take notice. That's why press is called the fourth pillar of democracy for understanding and reporting issues impartially without bias. I hope I am clear.
mystique_4008 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#48
I want to ask colourless, SP and zee who think success of show = high TRP. If a show's success is determined by its rating then how comes shows on Sony i.e beyhadh, kuch rang, YUDKBH, EDKV became successful despite only gaining TRP of 0.6 - 0.8

Like how is it possible that out of all 4 GECs, only Sony chooses content over TRP.
Winnertakesital thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#49
😊 @cherry why i made my acc post BP and in the month of jan. I might as well retain it.
😃
I was tweeting #BringJenshadBack from many days. I also made this accounf few days ago to ask many of u who have seen many shows including come back and Season2 of popular pairs.

So actually wanted to make a post if this online buzz matters as from Harshad chat session it looks as if he does not have any offers and tweets are just floating around that Cinevistaa is launching shows on Star Plus

I saw the TM makers post and gave my perspective. My main purpose was the tweeting and trending which is going on twitter. Whether it is going to help.

Somehow i responded to this post and i got a hell lot of answers. What i wanted to do is in d back burner
Edited by Winnertakesital - 6 years ago
shabla thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: Winnertakesital


Itna na karo mujhe pyaar Ronit Roy and Pallvi Kulkarni. This one was good in comparision ro Naagin and the rest which is currently on air.

Gul tried to showcase broken characters through humsafars.

A reality check for two producers who can dwell on fantasy cum drama.

So with Sony they too had to change their outlook. The difference was Gul's show ran for 106 and Ektas 200. Yes both weren't their soap factory churned soaps. This was d route i spoke abt.

Bp had its ups and downs

Yeh MID kya hai by the way ??


Maine bola Apple tu ne likha Orange...Maine bola Tamatar tune boli Aalu..Maine Boli Naagin tune suna Ronit roy...Mohtarma kya maine likha aur kya aapne suna...waise strategy achi hai...the game of dump dumper n dumpest...aur ekta n reshmi are not ma padosan...mujhe unki koi fikar nahi hai...

U r active in TW n dnt knw wht MID is...kithni boli hai re tu...kitna pyaara tujhe rab ne bhanaya...chalo teekh hai mufth ka gyan rakhlo...free mein hai...MID stands fr Multiple I D...yani ki fake id...Yani ki asli ID chupake fake id se darphok ki tara war karana...yani ke saamne asli id mein aane ki himmat nahi hai...i hope ithna gyaan kafi hai on MID...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".