An open letter to Creatives - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

5.6k

Users

22

Likes

265

Frequent Posters

ZaYa-Beintehaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
I am sorry but I completely disagree with your post.
Zubair has been brought in possibly to solve the track with Barkhat and can I stress this is fiction, not reality. Thus, there is no point comparing the consequences with what would happen in real life. The jealousy tracks is meant to be a fun one and I understand in real-life a third person in a relationship could bring about disastrous consequences but this is a t-v show and these consequences won't be replicated here.

Furthermore, the Barkhat track is a way to move Aaliya and Zain's relationship forward and the story forward too. And all that would happen then is that the two lead characters would fall in love and confess their love to each other in a period of some months but then what?

This is a love story and in a love story they have to show ups and downs, exaggerated from real-life. Imagine if Zain and Aaliya were to confess there love how much longer would the serial go on for (and still manage to be interesting) without a certain sense of drama?
annie07 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
@Gagan, agreed with your perspective about jealousy, thats why I wanted separation too before confession... and ok with other stuff you said, my only hitch is that I wanna see Aaliya confiding atleast abt her doubts on Mir Khan to him...

I had absolutely loved the start of Bawdi track for this very reason...that scene where she tells him she saw Suraiyya and his disbelief, yet he helped her... the next scene when she gets calls from Mir Khan, when she clarifies that he has no issues that she is Mir Khan is her chacha...and even the scene when she caught Barkat having beedi... I was in awe of them... coz I havent seen such a thing in any show till date... all they show either of the two hiding stuff, till its too late...

I am ok with Zubair, Zubbu and even Phubbu... mujhe bas wo Aaliya- Zain chahiye...
mazkachazka thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
omg! unnati darling! you're here after so long! missed your posts..though I myself am too inactive here..anyways good to see ya 🤗

about the Zubair track,yes I did find it little bit confusing specially when we know barkat/bobby's track isn't over yet,when we know she still wants the Abdullah family broken,she still wants Usman dead,amidst all this they introduce a jealousy track,which is a bit weird though I did want a Jealousy track like anything but yes hadn't expected it to happen this way.. specially with stupid conniving Bobby hovering around in the house :l..I mean first of all the writers ruined the Zaya love story realisation for me specifically since the time the freezer scene happened,I wasn't able to enjoy the depth of their realization of such an imp. emotion called love ..khair I anyways consoled my heart..let see
Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: annie07

@Gagan, agreed with your perspective about jealousy, thats why I wanted separation too before confession... and ok with other stuff you said, my only hitch is that I wanna see Aaliya confiding atleast abt her doubts on Mir Khan to him...

I had absolutely loved the start of Bawdi track for this very reason...that scene where she tells him she saw Suraiyya and his disbelief, yet he helped her... the next scene when she gets calls from Mir Khan, when she clarifies that he has no issues that she is Mir Khan is her chacha...and even the scene when she caught Barkat having beedi... I was in awe of them... coz I havent seen such a thing in any show till date... all they show either of the two hiding stuff, till its too late...

I am ok with Zubair, Zubbu and even Phubbu... mujhe bas wo Aaliya- Zain chahiye...


Annie Exactly. Bawdi track had a lot of potential and you saw a lot of growth in ZaYa's relationship as well, but then it came to a standstill when Barkat track took prominence over the main concept. I am sure we can pull excuses of getting Harshika break etc.. it happens in all shows.

As far as Aliyah confiding in him, I dont know what I feel about that right now. I will just see how they take it forward.
pinkeye thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
Who is phubbu now Annie. I thought that was Arjun kapoor nickname. 🤣
SunShine_A thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: pinkeye

Zain and Aaliya 's marriage is not a regular one I agree but it is more like an arranged marriage scenario where two people try to find love post marriage while exploring life situations together. They do develop fondness, care, affection and trust and most importantly love. I will equate Zaya marriage to that only. They were unsure about each other but with little little steps thwy started to know each other and that's what they acknowledged during second nikah. Zain even admitted she brought new meaning to his life. That guy cannot be this much immature all of a sudden to need the push in the form another man as wake up call to trigger his confession . people bound by arrange marriges do not even utter those 3 words , its their actions which says it all. If in real situation Guys tend to need another friend of wife post marriage to realise the worth, then sorry it makes that guy pretty shallow and his faith in marriage questionable.

If Zain is mature enough to ask his mother to stay away from his marital dischord,if he is mature enough to assur Shabana that he is not going to leave AAliya nd warn his mother to not invove phups, if he is mature enough to handle his changing equations with mkb with clean heart, if he is mature enough to put forward the hand of friendship and go by the vows of marriage,then he is mature enogh to handle the closeness of his wife in form of friendship to another man.If a man does not realise the worth of spouse by her actions and spontaneously and nedd third wheel, then that respect will be always shaky imo. He needs to learn it by himself because its his marriage, his companionship.

I kind off disagree here too coz in an arranged alliance u look for love, Companionship while hatred/ dislikeness and family pressure was base of Aaliya Zain marriage. Aaliya was ready to compromise for her family and respect she has for institution of marriage. Zain has always been a family nan, doesn't matter how carefree and flamboyant he is, he put family above everyone and that has come out not once but many times. No involvement of phuohs was to save her from disappointment and pain but did his love stop Zain from attempting to make Aaliya leave him? No, thats all Zain about. And now Zain realise that he has feelings but those are not deep and like many other times he tried coming out clear here too but couldn't.
Harshad explained Zain's jealousy or insecurity well in sbb. Do watch
Zain has never seen Aaliya this close with anyone, never seen her so happy with anyone apart from her family so Zain has taken a backseat coz this all came as a surprise rather shock and as Gagan said that uptil now Zain was all that mattered to Aaliya, hatred, love, pain, hurt, friendship every emotion and relation was about Zain, was with Zain so now someone else sharing those emotions with her bounds to create a sense of insecurity and I really do not feel anything immature about it.
SunoNa123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#27
gagan while i agree with u on zain's side of jealousy , i dont think most of them have a problem with jealousy track, well who wouldn wanto see it, and as Aliya nd Zain have been equals , when they have shows aliya go through this phase its all fair if Zain goes through that as well.

But but my point is couldn this have been waited until the barkat track was wrapped up?? Now doesnt it make Zain distracted regarding Zubbu - Aluu , and get even more blinded on Barkats activities??.

My problem lies in that, this is just a 4 months old show, why hurry the confessions, they can take it slowly..

As long as they have Zain also get to know the truth about barkat, and aliya also confide in him with what little she knows i would be in for this track, but if its rather used as a distracting medium to keep him completely unaware of the happenings about barkat and it will be zubbu who will help it out to Aliya then that wouldn sit well me..
pinkeye thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#28
Ashlesha we differ in perception regarding the whole scenario and thus we will disagree on each point we out forward. So lets agree to happily disagree here. We do not share same views regarding the whole thing and its better to leave it that way.

Between I did watch sbb and saw What Harshad said. He says its awkwRd for Zain which I agrre in a wY but it does not make me believe that third person required fr him to confess.
Edited by pinkeye - 11 years ago
Aishahh_24 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#29
Nice to see you back :)

All I wanna say is, I think the CVs are so busy reading our responses after each supposedly false precap that to accomodate each qualm of the audience relating to a particular scene, they are messing up with the whole story. It doesn't seem like they have a well-scripted story up their sleeves beforehand.

I think ever since the Barkat track has begun, CVs have become paranoid reading everyone's responses. :P Now they can't end the track abruptly and they can't even show overdose of Barkat so they are showing sudden changes in the characters just to purely keep the audience happy.

If it not had been for the Barkat track, ZaYa's story would've progressed slowly and we would have seen more developments in Zain's character.

I think all they need is, some time to bring stability in the story. Let the Barkat track end, maybe then we get to see our old Beintehaa ;)
SunShine_A thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: -sylph-

gagan while i agree with u on zain's side of jealousy , i dont think most of them have a problem with jealousy track, well who wouldn wanto see it, and as Aliya nd Zain have been equals , when they have shows aliya go through this phase its all fair if Zain goes through that as well.

But but my point is couldn this have been waited until the barkat track was wrapped up?? Now doesnt it make Zain distracted regarding Zubbu - Aluu , and get even more blinded on Barkats activities??.

My problem lies in that, this is just a 4 months old show, why hurry the confessions, they can take it slowly..

As long as they have Zain also get to know the truth about barkat, and aliya also confide in him with what little she knows i would be in for this track, but if its rather used as a distracting medium to keep him completely unaware of the happenings about barkat and it will be zubbu who will help it out to Aliya then that wouldn sit well me..

I really think before making conclusions we should wait and see whats in cvs mind regarding track. They hv strtd trying getting show somewhere back so let them give certain time for it. And regarding confession well am not for into where leads take a year to fall for each other and then thy r inseparable, I don't believe in such relations. Every relation travel a certain journey and maybe thats what aim of cvs to show ZaYa's love getting transformed into Beintehaa love

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".