is aliya's truth justified? - Page 2

i dont know,wats the truth aaliya suppose to know from ayat..after confronting ayat alone and if she comes and tells infront of suraiya and others,suraiya vl tell ayat did for good purpose..mistake is a mistake,if it comes out infront of every1 is always valid and they vl get forgiveness...according to me aaliya is correct...even once aaliya told zain,in some cases lie is good,as she told for fahads case.fahad is from her inlaws side,ayat her own sister,things differ according to the persons rights...

ok I watched the epi. many say aayat deserved the slap...but really? did she... the slap was for the escort issue a thing she didn't even know she was involved in. but fahad who did everything knowingly doesn't even get shouted at let alone a slap. hypocrisy at its best. I know many will say fahad and ayat's mistake is poles apart, and I agree it is...but u cant help but compare the two... especially every1s reaction to their mistake... ayat was tricked into the escort thing, she thought she was going to do modelling not escort... if she knew do u think she would have got involved...? no way... at least give the girl a chance 2 speak rather than humiliate her and slap her without knowing the full truth.

Originally posted by: The.Lannister

What aliya told everyone was a half truth. If she is such a champion of truth she should get d whole story first n den make d grand revelation. And better not to forget that u cannot b truthful all d time * cough u trapping zain into marrying u* sometimes u need to lie, sometimes u need to shut ur mouth.

And if she is such a great believer in truth then y didnt she reveal fahads truth or shazia, gauhar, suraiyyas shop lifting truth?

Also a womans reputation is a fragile thing, and dis woman is ur own sister. What she did was wrong. She was conned n it happens to d best of people. Punish her but there was no need to humiliate her further. And especially in front of the 3 witches. Also this will humiliate not just ayat but ur own parents aliya dear!

V v disappointed by the tamasha she did today.

Edit : i wud have preferred it that aliya take ayat aside, talk to her properly, n show her d right path n ask her to confess like she did wid fahad rather than doing dis scene. ayat is explainable to her parents, not to suraiyya n her cohorts!!! Talk abt being ur own worst enemy!

I agree she proved herself hypocrite...First she encouraged fahad to confess truth himself..after lying straight for days and then she will judge others on truth...Thats best defined hypocrisy there...She even knew Suriya truth...She knew NAfisa truth why didn't she told everyone about Nafisa its her who put it there...Even she knew Saziya..father truth...why didnot she make public announcement of it...Ayat lied for her parents...Aliya lied for barkat VIlla...You cannot mold that lying for other is good ...but only if I do it...when other do ..its wrong ..thats hypcosiy

okay justified aaliya had no time to talk to her sister personally and confronted her but she had a time to slap her for the reason that she herself didnt know properly? is it justified

Originally posted by: manny136

the thing is ayat was gonna stay quiet no matter what and zain was gonna support her. aaliya was shocked about the whole thing and obviously she reacted but if she didnt tell the truth it would make her a hypocrite. Fahad is older and he made a mistake but he owned up to it thanks to aaliya even though he probably would have gotten away with it. ayat did get away but her lies started a chain reaction tht led to zain getting hurt and who knows when rocky would stop or if he decided to expose ayats truth as well. aaliya revealing the truth is better cause she can still control the truth unlike the three witches spinning it their way. I personally have not been a fan of ayats behavior since the online friends thing started and she need to know tht her actions have consequences coz she was lucky zain was there to save the day not all girls in this situation would have been tht lucky. aaliyas way might have been wrong but it was important the truth to come out like this than someone bad using it.

I think wht aliya did was absolutely right as a sister it did hurt her that how can her sister do that
And she was implusive
I like the thing that alya told the truth to everyone not that witches

Originally posted by: Nels

I still have to watch the epi, but after reading the update I personally feel that it was good if Aaliya exposed the truth. Had the honors been done by SAASUMA and her gang it would have been much more worse than this.

Further, the speed at which truth unfolded, I am sure Aaliya did not have enough time to talk properly with Aayat and get to know her reason. Considering that she is very well aware of Suraiyya and her bhabhi's opinion about her and her family, she must have easily realized the reason of getting her family as a surprise all of a sudden. So without giving them the leverage, she took the controls in her hand.

I know this all seems very dramatic and unbelievable, but at times one has to take drastic steps.

Originally posted by: The.Lannister

It looked like abhay deols trick in znmd to me😆 suraiyya started off with maine suna hai...and aliya blurted d truth fearing what all she might say.

The bad thing imo wasnt that she said d truth but d fact dat she believed that ayat came to mumbai to b an escort willingly. Never once did it cross her mind dat maybe she was conned by someone? and d other women r gonna manipulate these peeps anyways. dats wat dey do! So y make their work easy? Its not as if telling d truth is gonna make her any dearer to her mil