The New Track- Annulment

sunshinesamuef thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#1

#barristerbabu is a period drama. It is set in the year 1920. It was a different time, where every relationship required a name, women were treated like trash & a commodity basically, now in times like this, can we really expect AniDita to end their marriage & have a benam rishta?? & it will be especially difficult for Bon because she will have to face a lot of insults & taunts of the society for being a divorcee. Once their marriage ends, the society in which they live in will question thier relationship, maybe even call it names because for them a nameless relationship between a man & a woman is considered scandalous regardless of it's purity. I am not in favour of child marriages, just that this track shouldn't have come now, maybe after leap it could have been shown that AniDita raised their voices against the evil practice together like the storyline is meant to be. I don't know how makers are going to deal with this but I hope that they keep in mind that they are making a period drama where some amount of historical facts are needed to be shown correctly. You cannot take so much of creative liberty that you distort historical facts, Sharda Act was passed in 1929, 9 years from the year Barrister Babu is set in. It is just my point of view. No need for rude comments. Thank you🙏

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.7k

Users

5

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

mprvn36 thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#2

Pls don’t worry. Makers will be in more pressure than us. They also know how much backlashes they are facing from last month. Hope They will keep everything in mind. If Bonditha is targeted by society, will anirudh keep quiet. Definitely noooooo.....

NiharikaMishra thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 4 years ago
#3

The word Divorce is being added for extra drama.

Marriage getting annulled means their marriage was never valid and they just cease to exist as husband-wife. Divorce is separation of valid couples.

Also divorce is as per choice and optional whereas annulment is a law enforced thing.

Annulment is nullifying any marriage that is not as per the norms of the government of the country. Like if you do a court marriage or register your Hindu marriage today and do some error in paper work, the marriage registration done at that time is null and void and your are not legal husband and wife until you register the marriage again.

Not just age, marriages done when either person is not in right frame of mine, is under threat of life or intoxicated can be annulled if challenged in court.


I am only hoping they use this track to leverage Bondita leaving for Dalhousie and returning post-leap as a stronger and more aware woman because post-annulment it will be impossible for her to keep living with Roychowdhurys and continue education

sunshinesamuef thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: mprvn36

Pls don’t worry. Makers will be in more pressure than us. They also know how much backlashes they are facing from last month. Hope They will keep everything in mind. If Bonditha is targeted by society, will anirudh keep quiet. Definitely noooooo.....

Yes Ani will not keep quiet seeing Bon in pain but he will have no right to raise his voice...remember at the start when Ani saved Bon from sati & said he will take care of her, the people questioned him with what right will he do that. He's neither her father nor her brother & hence Ani had to marry her. To save her. But now, after they annul their marriage how will he save her??

And what irks me the most are two things: 1. Historical inaccuracy, creative liberty is fine but they should not distort history right?

2. We were always led to believe that AniDita are soulmates, their marriage is eternal & they are meant to be up untill the recent time where when Bon claimed Ani as her God shaadi shlok played in the background highlighting the pati patni aspect of their relationship & now with their marriage breaking, the main concept of the story i.e a husband fights the whole world to educate his wife & make her a barrister changes....this isn't done. If makers had planned this from the start then why did they lead us to believe differently?? We didn't ask them to do that.


I DO NOT support CHILD MARRIAGE...but these are some things I could not ignore...

mprvn36 thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sunshinesamuef

Yes Ani will not keep quiet seeing Bon in pain but he will have no right to raise his voice...remember at the start when Ani saved Bon from sati & said he will take care of her, the people questioned him with what right will he do that. He's neither her father nor her brother & hence Ani had to marry her. To save her. But now, after they annul their marriage how will he save her??

And what irks me the most are two things: 1. Historical inaccuracy, creative liberty is fine but they should not distort history right?

2. We were always led to believe that AniDita are soulmates, their marriage is eternal & they are meant to be up untill the recent time where when Bon claimed Ani as her God shaadi shlok played in the background highlighting the pati patni aspect of their relationship & now with their marriage breaking, the main concept of the story i.e a husband fights the whole world to educate his wife & make her a barrister changes....this isn't done. If makers had planned this from the start then why did they lead us to believe differently?? We didn't ask them to do that.


I DO NOT support CHILD MARRIAGE...but these are some things I could not ignore...

if that is the case, then as per Sharada Act, girl should reach 14 years of age to get married. May be they will remarry with both of their consent.
sunshinesamuef thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: NiharikaMishra

The word Divorce is being added for extra drama.

Marriage getting annulled means their marriage was never valid and they just cease to exist as husband-wife. Divorce is separation of valid couples.

Also divorce is as per choice and optional whereas annulment is a law enforced thing.

Annulment is nullifying any marriage that is not as per the norms of the government of the country. Like if you do a court marriage or register your Hindu marriage today and do some error in paper work, the marriage registration done at that time is null and void and your are not legal husband and wife until you register the marriage again.

Not just age, marriages done when either person is not in right frame of mine, is under threat of life or intoxicated can be annulled if challenged in court.


I am only hoping they use this track to leverage Bondita leaving for Dalhousie and returning post-leap as a stronger and more aware woman because post-annulment it will be impossible for her to keep living with Roychowdhurys and continue education

Makers should clarify if they are annuling the marriage or AniDita is getting divorced & Bondita will leave for Dalhousie but after the Bon Maika drama with her Thakuma, Kakima & family & there won't be any leap anytime soon. They will stretch & drag this track on end.

sunshinesamuef thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mprvn36

if that is the case, then as per Sharada Act, girl should reach 14 years of age to get married. May be they will remarry with both of their consent.

Makers don't know anything about history.... they have proven it. So we should forget about a remarriage now, maybe after leap but not right now.

Indira12 thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sunshinesamuef

Yes Ani will not keep quiet seeing Bon in pain but he will have no right to raise his voice...remember at the start when Ani saved Bon from sati & said he will take care of her, the people questioned him with what right will he do that. He's neither her father nor her brother & hence Ani had to marry her. To save her. But now, after they annul their marriage how will he save her??

And what irks me the most are two things: 1. Historical inaccuracy, creative liberty is fine but they should not distort history right?

2. We were always led to believe that AniDita are soulmates, their marriage is eternal & they are meant to be up untill the recent time where when Bon claimed Ani as her God shaadi shlok played in the background highlighting the pati patni aspect of their relationship & now with their marriage breaking, the main concept of the story i.e a husband fights the whole world to educate his wife & make her a barrister changes....this isn't done. If makers had planned this from the start then why did they lead us to believe differently?? We didn't ask them to do that.


I DO NOT support CHILD MARRIAGE...but these are some things I could not ignore...

@Bold - Same here. We didn't ask them to show like that. Why were we made to believe something else and shown something else. Also, the crux of the show, a husband making his wife a barrister, while fighting against the norms goes for a toss.

But I think we should be a bit more patient to see how all of it unfolds. Channel, actors and makers are now hinting towards them only. We still have Thakuma to make an entry. It's not solely a marriage annulment or Dalhousie track. There is more to it and we should be keeping ourselves composed for that. Hoping for the best and preparing for the worst. 👍🏼

mprvn36 thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sunshinesamuef

Makers don't know anything about history.... they have proven it. So we should forget about a remarriage now, maybe after leap but not right now.

let us see. Cannot predict anything now. Let Bonditha observe the world.
Katy4566 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mprvn36

let us see. Cannot predict anything now. Let Bonditha observe the world.

yup but why did she agree with ani in the starting of ending this relationship ,i want to know the reason,is it because she wants to abide which i dont think so or she knows it will help her in guidance and bring a social reform,remember bon orayed durga maa and she became dtermined as he remembered anirudh explaining child marriages arew rong,regarding her experiences and decisions,it willcome later on her growing where she expains reason like ani does

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".