How dare they? - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

133

Views

10.5k

Users

30

Likes

630

Frequent Posters

goofyCat thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: The_Alchemist.

Lol. Shivam 's name is now Shankar Singh? He chose to go by Dr Jagadish Singh name and not by his dad Shiv Raj Shekhar's name? What a pity.



Is Jagdish Singh the only Singh in the entire universe? 🤪
Half of the characters in the show had surname Singh including Khajan Singh, HethSingh and Akheraj Singh.

Shivam obviously didn't want to use Shekhar surname.. He probably chose a name Shankar who is synonymous to his father's name Shiv and surname of the person whom he was closest to after his mother, Kalyani devi Singh 😛
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: russhmeSS



Is Jagdish Singh the only Singh in the entire universe? 🤪
Half of the characters in the show had surname Singh including Khajan Singh, HethSingh and Akheraj Singh.

Shivam obviously didn't want to use Shekhar surname.. He probably chose a name Shankar who is synonymous to his father's name Shiv and surname of the person whom he was closest to after his mother, Kalyani devi Singh 😛

@bold 😆
May be people don't know that Shankar is another name for Shiv. 😆
I remember after his mother it was his badi nanisa he looked up to.Then only came Kakasa and Kakisa.

hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: russhmeSS



Is Jagdish Singh the only Singh in the entire universe? 🤪
Half of the characters in the show had surname Singh including Khajan Singh, HethSingh and Akheraj Singh.

Shivam obviously didn't want to use Shekhar surname.. He probably chose a name Shankar who is synonymous to his father's name Shiv and surname of the person whom he was closest to after his mother, Kalyani devi Singh 😛



His mother was also Anandi Singh before marriage😆
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: The_Alchemist.

I fail to understand why people are blaming Anandi for what happened to her children after death.

It was a sudden untimely death.

@the above bold part - someone please tell me this is a joke😆.

Firstly - the way Anandi died without safeguarding her children's future inspite of having enough time is such a shocking act that no one even could blame Anandi. Everyone here was pointing out the the ugly flaws in the direction.

Secondly - ponting out this character Anandi had started when another character in the serial was pointed out for not using his supernatural powers to locate this hospital. It is always what others couldn't do for these orphans. What others could have done "more". While the mother treats her children like trash . What kind of a woman dies without telling her children whom exactly to approach once they are left alone in this world. Giving gyan before dying was never wrong. Nor did anyone here say that. So stop twisting statements. In that limited time she had, any human would first think of safeguarding the children. And with the rest of the time she can give gyan. Whoever asked her to stop?

And yes , when one sees the path Anandi laid for her children, it is natural to express the immense displeasure. When this act of directors is supported and other characters in the serial are blamed, then of course it has to be reminded which character is the actual culprit.

Why am I even explaining when it is obvious that the goal is to twist the arguments and support the character Anandi at any cost indirectly supporting the clumsy puke worthy direction.


once again... a well argued post.

hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#95
Did they show us the entire scene of what Anandi told the kids or to the hospital authorities?

NO

The scenes which were shown thru FBs where only scenes which were relevant to the present characters for those moment in bits and pieces When N was feeling low remembering her mother's words to gather strength. When she was remembering Shivam , they showed how they separated.

Whether Anandi told them anything about where to go, if Jagya could contact them nothing has been shown , whether they tried to call him or the Shekhars were not shown. Just for the sake of the story that they will be homeless and separated they kept everything on assumption . Otherwise logically they cant tell this story.

Then why these criticism?

If they would have shown the entire scene then it could be debated.

The kids know the place Jaitsar. Their phone numbers.May be J couldnt be contacted. May be J thought who is A to me so let me assume them dead.

Nothing has been shown.

They why these baseless criticism?

Good for them who thinks that any mother can think bad for her children specially the one who is dying to save her kids. May be they have seen such mother.

I have never seen such mother.

In Tagore's words kids can be bad but mothers cannot


GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: hisusmita

Did they show us the entire scene of what Anandi told the kids or to the hospital authorities?

NO

The scenes which were shown thru FBs where only scenes which were relevant to the present characters for those moment in bits and pieces When N was feeling low remembering her mother's words to gather strength. When she was remembering Shivam , they showed how they separated.

Whether Anandi told them anything about where to go, if Jagya could contact them nothing has been shown , whether they tried to call him or the Shekhars were not shown. Just for the sake of the story that they will be homeless and separated they kept everything on assumption . Otherwise logically they cant tell this story.

Then why these criticism?

If they would have shown the entire scene then it could be debated.

The kids know the place Jaitsar. Their phone numbers.May be J couldnt be contacted. May be J thought who is A to me so let me assume them dead.

Nothing has been shown.

They why these baseless criticism?

Good for them who thinks that any mother can think bad for her children specially the one who is dying to save her kids. May be they have seen such mother.

I have never seen such mother.

In Tagore's words kids can be bad but mothers cannot


it is because people love to assume the worst when it comes to Anandi so that they can have a blast picking on Anandi.😛
Shivam and Nandini were made to believe that Singhs are their family and it was not just Anandi who made them believe that but everyone in Singh family made them understand how they are all family.
Anandi knew that her family would look after her children. Don't all parents assume that?So why is Anandi wrong if she believes that her family would look after her kids?
For reasons best known to CVs Singhs have taken the place of Khazan Singh as well as Shekhars in the lives of Anandi and her children.
So where did Anandi leave them without anything?
Or may be it is Anandi's fault that she didn't survive long enough to see if Jagya had come over to take her children with him.

They are showing it only in bits and pieces with so many gaps in between and people are already assuming before it has even been shown😛

hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: aparnauma

it is because people love to assume the worst when it comes to Anandi so that they can have a blast picking on Anandi.😛
Shivam and Nandini were made to believe that Singhs are their family and it was not just Anandi who made them believe that but everyone in Singh family made them understand how they are all family.
Anandi knew that her family would look after her children. Don't all parents assume that?So why is Anandi wrong if she believes that her family would look after her kids?
For reasons best known to CVs Singhs have taken the place of Khazan Singh as well as Shekhars in the lives of Anandi and her children.
So where did Anandi leave them without anything?
Or may be it is Anandi's fault that she didn't survive long enough to see if Jagya had come over to take her children with him.

They are showing it only in bits and pieces with so many gaps in between and people are already assuming before it has even been shown😛



But I am loving this😃

Anandi is still centre of discussion even if it is bashing.😆

No current characters or previous characters are so important . But she is 👏

Atleast to bash her people are coming here and participating in discussion making Forum little lively else with the current show the forum already became dead.

But Anandi even after dying made the forum active. How many pages?😉
Edited by hisusmita - 9 years ago
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#98
@ Sushmita. Since nothing was shown why assume that J didn't do enough? Why were fingers being pointed at J the kakusa and the Vidhayaksa?
Why is J or any other character expected to do "more", and Anandi is excused for not even doing the basics?
------------

Lot of us were criticising directors for poorly ending Anandi's character and for unnecessarily making the kids orphans.

People are disappointed bse no one expected this kind of lame fate for Anandi and her kids.

We are not blaming Anandi for the way she died but for what she couldn't do enough while she was alive, so as to secure her kids future?

Now lets go back to what was shown.

Jagya searched for Anandi and kids and upon not finding them he assumed they were dead. This was clearly shown.

Have they shown Anandi and kids trying to contact J but failing? No - so why assume that they must have called but he couldn't be contacted.

Since it is not shown it is safe to assume it never happened. Anandi was not shown contacting J or directing someone to contact J, so we are simply pointing why was she wasting time giving gyan instead of ensuring that Jagya is on his way to pick up kids.

It is as simple as that.

And why shouldn't J assume that these people have died. Bse if they were any alive, wouldn't they contact him or come back home?



Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: The_Alchemist.

I fail to understand why people are blaming Anandi for what happened to her children after death.

It was a sudden untimely death.

@the above bold part - someone please tell me this is a joke😆.

Firstly - the way Anandi died without safeguarding her children's future inspite of having enough time is such a shocking act that no one even could blame Anandi. Everyone here was pointing out the the ugly flaws in the direction.

Secondly - ponting out this character Anandi had started when another character in the serial was pointed out for not using his supernatural powers to locate this hospital. It is always what others couldn't do for these orphans. What others could have done "more". While the mother treats her children like trash . What kind of a woman dies without telling her children whom exactly to approach once they are left alone in this world. Giving gyan before dying was never wrong. Nor did anyone here say that. So stop twisting statements. In that limited time she had, any human would first think of safeguarding the children. And with the rest of the time she can give gyan. Whoever asked her to stop?

And yes , when one sees the path Anandi laid for her children, it is natural to express the immense displeasure. When this act of directors is supported and other characters in the serial are blamed, then of course it has to be reminded which character is the actual culprit.

Why am I even explaining when it is obvious that the goal is to twist the arguments and support the character Anandi at any cost indirectly supporting the clumsy puke worthy direction.



No, it was not a joke.. From no angle it looked like a joke. I dont know why you are even assuming something written so seriously as a joke.😲

Rather it seems like a joke to them that we are not ready to accept that anandi was a great martyr who even sacrificed her children for the sake of her mission. 🤢

Secondly we were criticizing the new writer/director for ruining anandi's character and then shivam's... But objections were raised as if no writer in the world can ever make a mistake in depicting ananid's character.

And finally the sacrificial bakra was jagya. 😆

Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: hisusmita



But I am loving this😃

Anandi is still centre of discussion even if it is bashing.😆

No current characters or previous characters are so important . But she is 👏

Atleast to bash her people are coming here and participating in discussion making Forum little lively else with the current show the forum already became dead.

But Anandi even after dying made the forum active. How many pages?😉

Ofcourse people will discuss Anandi. Isn't it only logical for people to discuss a character that they were associated for 8 years over a character that has not even completed two weeks? 😉


Who else were you expecting to be discussed? When Shiv and even Saanchi ends up getting discussed despite only being present for two years in the show, why do you think Anandi won't be discussed who has only exited recently and that too after being present for 8 years.

Viewers are real people who behave as per natural phenomenon of life. We are not caricatures of Cvs who will develop sudden amnesia and forget 8 years long association with central characters and suddenly move on to Nandini. We need transition time because we are for real. Not like Nandini and Shivam, who immediately forgot JaGan post their mother's death.

However, Anandi may not be discussed for long. It's only the old viewers who are interested in her but are already reducing in their presence. The new ones don't even give a damn. 😛


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".