Balika Vadhu Episode Discussion Thread #5 - OPENED SEE PG 14 - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

83.4k

Users

45

Likes

2.7k

Frequent Posters

fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21
Haven't viewed the episode yet but looks like she has managed to ruin these clothes as well. What does she want Nimboli to wear? She herself can't afford anything. The child's mother buys her clothes that she can't let her wear. Don't know what her problem is.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: fast trak

Haven't viewed the episode yet but looks like she has managed to ruin these clothes as well. What does she want Nimboli to wear? She herself can't afford anything. The child's mother buys her clothes that she can't let her wear. Don't know what her problem is.

She has no means to raise a child not capable of getting any work neither is she capable of surviving in the real world. She has no claims on that child but still doesn't want to let go of the child.

Since the villagers landed at the court to give evidence as eye witnesses Akheraj will get convicted in Gopal murder case.

The family is already facing financial difficulties Kamili is feeding them right now. So where will Mangala go and how will she feed the child or raise that child?
If she did not know who the child's mother is then it's fine. How can she knowingly deprive the child of all this that belongs to her?


Ratan is the worst human being - but as a father he is much better than Mangala. He wanted his son to have the best possible upbringing for that he was willing to let go of his claims as a father though he is the biological father.That's what love for his son made him do.

Isn't Mangala supposed to be a noble soul?Or may be it is just an act?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: fast trak

It was Anandi that got kamli to talk to the villagers. It wasn't other way around. Kamli was a medium needed to request the villages about seeking justice. The villagers have witnessed the murder and it will work best if kamli pleaded with them. Anandi was needed to make this happen.

Anandi isn't very upset because now she has found her daughter and slowly she will build a bonding with her. The disappointment and jealousy is just for mangala who can't bear simply to see the child happy. She was enjoying when Nimboli suffered but when the child has found her freedom and happiness she just can't bear it.

True.This talk with villagers happened because of Anandi.
They got Akheraj arrested on Mangala's and Jagya's statements but conviction was not possible in any of the cases.
That was possible only with villagers coming as eye witnesses.
Till tne villagers entered the picture - everything that Akheraj committed looked like family issues apart from child marriage issue
Mangala's husband's murder Gopal's murder - looked more like disgruntled family members making allegations against Akheraj.

Still till Anandi took the initiative to meet the villagers and convince them the need to speak up against Akheraj neither the Vidhyaksa nor Kamili thought of doing it.
Kamili may have gone to ask them along with lawyer before telling Mangala that things are not working out.

Jagya arranged the meeting with villagers because it was Anandi who wanted to meet them.

Villagers have not seen how barbaric Akheraj's was towards Anandi and her child when he snatched her child from her but what Akheraj has done to Gopal was right in front of their eyes so Anandi told them that if they don't to see their children meeting the same fate as Gopal's they should ensure that Akheraj is punished for that.

Villagers connect with fellow victims more.They did not know who Anandi was till she told them that she is Nimboli's mother. They have seen what kind of treatment Nimboli has been subjected to so they connect with her pain and troubles as Nimboli's mother and think of her as one of them.

Till now they have seen only Kamili's efforts now they know that there is another person also trying to get Akheraj punished so they got bolder and that's how they came.

Jagya did what he can as a responsible citizen. Now it is the responsibility of the victims to stand up for themselves and they do so only when they see some of the victims trying to do something and that's what all this is about.

Empowerment is not about doing things with the help of Vidhyaksa but they themselves waking up to their responsibilities and gaining strength from their own resources.
It is about victims joining together.
Nobody can deny the fact that Anandi and her daughter are victims of atrocities committed by Akheraj just like the villagers.

The fact that Anandi would join hands with these women and villagers at some point is quite obvious right from the time Ver 2.0 started.
To tell this story of oppression of weaker communities and women and them rising against oppression they chose to bring Anandi's baby to the midst of these villagers to bring Anandi into the story.
Obviously it will be Anandi who will be helping these women including Harki find themselves and rise aboove themselves.

I m going to make a prediction here. I see Kamili contesting the elctions with encouragement and support from Anandi.



SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: aparnauma

True.This talk with villagers happened because of Anandi.
They got Akheraj arrested on Mangala's and Jagya's statements but conviction was not possible in any of the cases.
That was possible only with villagers coming as eye witnesses.
Till tne villagers entered the picture - everything that Akheraj committed looked like family issues apart from child marriage issue
Mangala's husband's murder Gopal's murder - looked more like disgruntled family members making allegations against Akheraj.

Still till Anandi took the initiative to meet the villagers and convince them the need to speak up against Akheraj neither the Vidhyaksa nor Kamili thought of doing it.
Kamili may have gone to ask them along with lawyer before telling Mangala that things are not working out.

Jagya arranged the meeting with villagers because it was Anandi who wanted to meet them.

Villagers have not seen how barbaric Akheraj's was towards Anandi and her child when he snatched her child from her but what Akheraj has done to Gopal was right in front of their eyes so Anandi told them that if they don't to see their children meeting the same fate as Gopal's they should ensure that Akheraj is punished for that.

Villagers connect with fellow victims more.They did not know who Anandi was till she told them that she is Nimboli's mother. They have seen what kind of treatment Nimboli has been subjected to so they connect with her pain and troubles as Nimboli's mother and think of her as one of them.

Till now they have seen only Kamili's efforts now they know that there is another person also trying to get Akheraj punished so they got bolder and that's how they came.

Jagya did what he can as a responsible citizen. Now it is the responsibility of the victims to stand up for themselves and they do so only when they see some of the victims trying to do something and that's what all this is about.

Empowerment is not about doing things with the help of Vidhyaksa but they themselves waking up to their responsibilities and gaining strength from their own resources.
It is about victims joining together.
Nobody can deny the fact that Anandi and her daughter are victims of atrocities committed by Akheraj just like the villagers.

The fact that Anandi would join hands with these women and villagers at some point is quite obvious right from the time Ver 2.0 started.
To tell this story of oppression of weaker communities and women and them rising against oppression they chose to bring Anandi's baby to the midst of these villagers to bring Anandi into the story.
Obviously it will be Anandi who will be helping these women including Harki find themselves and rise aboove themselves.

I m going to make a prediction here. I see Kamili contesting the elctions with encouragement and support from Anandi.




@bold - pity - they don't know what Mangala did for them - and how she risked her life. Perhaps they will never get to know - just because Mangala is not lead of this serial. Perhaps all will be made to sing song of the lead - even though she is the beneficiary of help from others - and no one know about that. 👎🏼 for creatives.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25
Some members have liked the DT warning on page 3 - and on the same page started bashing a character with names like noble soul, sick woman, mentally ill etc.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#26
A woman who behaves in such a way with a kid whom she calls her as her daughter - spoling her happiness manipulating her emotions and what's more hiding so many truths from that child.
Somebody gives her a gift and she spolis that gift just because she doesn't want the child to like that person.

Who behaves in such a way? How should this behaviour be described? If not sickening and disgusting?

Indulging in this behaviour in the name of motherhood is an insult to motherhood and mother's love.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#27
Attributing Mangala's behaviour to mental illness is actually is wrong.

In fact people under treatment for various psychiatric illnesses do not exhibit this kind of nastiness towards kids specially their own kids.

But knowing the writers how they attributed Teepri's behaviour to mental illness it will not be surprising if they do that with Mangala





ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#28
It has been crystal clearly shown in serial the villagers were impacted by Kamli's words not Anandi's because this point Kamli brought their children can have fate like Gopal as well if Bapusaa came out She hit their consciences and obviously they will listen to the village's daughter more than any random woman Anandi who neither did anything for them neither they know who is she
Yes Jagya arranged the meeting because Anandi could not arrange herself
If people are asking instead of Anandi they would have shown Jagya asking them to stand on their feet that would have more impactful scene because he could tell them Mangala's work as well how she approached him for sake of her villagers and today she needs same villagers support Villagers should support her too

but cvs ?? It is unfair Anandi took credits for herself i started this fight 🤢while everyone knows its Mangala who told Jagya about Akhiraj thats how Akhiraj was arrested
Edited by BeatifulSoul_ - 9 years ago
maria13 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#29
This talk of villagers happened because of Anandi?


This is misleading serial

In serial it was judge who ordered to bring in the witnesses from villagers to testify against Akhiraj if they have seen Gopal's murder then bring them in

Anandi needed Jagya's help to have that meeting otherwise she could never arrange that meeting because who she is to Jharla people that villagers will come to hear her bhashans?t They don't even know her who is she ? Thats why Jagya arranged that meeting

and hearing Anandi's bhashan the villagers were either looking down or looking away This is enough proof they would never have come to testify until Kamli would not have waken up their consciences by saying this their children too can have fate like Gopal then what they will do ? this is what hit the consciences of jharla people They don't want fate like Gopal for their children it is true if Akhiraj came out then there will more Gopal like victims in the village thats why they came to testify against Akhiraj so whose words impacted villagers Anandi or Kamli? It was Kamlis words and poor Gopal unfortunate death from the hands of Akhiraj

so why giving wrong credits to Anandi ?

Yes Jagya did what any responsible person will do He put Akhiraj on trial now time for Akhiraj's victims to help law complete its proceedings For Jharla people it is better someone from their village make them stand up i am glad Kamli did Kamli encouraged Mangala Kamli opened eyes of her villagers too

This whole court case was a blunder Nonsense drama but i will overlook if cvs in the end give credits to right people i.e Jagya Mangala and Kamli not to Anandi who did nothing special but this is too much ask from BV cvs 🤢
Edited by maria13 - 9 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#30
Anandi's fight with Akheraj did start 11 years ago.
True when she first encountered this man she did not know his name. She was doing her duty as a responsible citizen by trying to stop a child marriage. She did not have anything personal when she confronted this man.

Akheraj made it into a personal battle by snatching her baby.

Jagya is an elected representative and he is doing his duty when Anandi confronted Akheraj all those years ago she was just an ordinary citizen who is doing her duty. What she was doing was any less than what Vidhyaksa did?
She has been helping women all her life and she has been working for the betterment of their status in every possible way.

Who was Sarita and her daughter Pooja for her when she went to help them? Has she ever met them before?

It is another matter her daughter and her daughter's kidnapper could not be traced even with all the powers backing her and she searching for her and the other unexplainable things like how she missed Akheraj so narrowly so many times that too in BH and Jagya;s office - illogical ways to carry the story forward.

Why did Akheraj want revenge against her? Because she stopped Kundan's child marriage.She is social actvist who has been working to prevent child marriages.Did she have anything against Akheraj and his son when she went to stop the child marriage?

So how can it be said she is only doing for her own personal benefits?

Anandi has been working for women empowerment for so many years so why is it illogical if she goes to the village to meet the villagers along with Kamili?




Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".