Anandi, this is inexcusable - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

6.1k

Users

12

Likes

158

Frequent Posters

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: blushing

well Its not like that we are defending A's action of hiding things from family

but involving family won't solve matter at all... point get all facts clear get proof catch the dealer who is selling drugs name of Medicine.

that doesn't mean DB gets whitewash... if this proven DB indeed demand some nasha then its clear she is indeed guilty.

otherwise DB will still label herself been victimized. Doesn't matter it's pure lie...but no way to prove DB is faking.


I think way DB defend her action Anandi knew there is way of escape so proof needed.

Without any kind proof Anandi does not want to involve family...that's it.


****************************************
in real life too people get bails even they commit crime...

Court Law demand solid proof...for punishment...until even Accused can't be label as Criminal...

Innocent till proven guilty


Well said - the law of the land says everybody is innocent till proven guilty.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#32
So, the 'punishment' of family members is only to live with the fact that somewhere sometimes they did wrong with someone. But the punishment for a non-family member is not like this. They should also let non-family members with the same punishment. Why this difference?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#33
Punishment for family members - Is there a legal way to punish Dsa for what she had done to Jamuna?
Coming to Gehna what was her fight all about? It was a fight for her rights as a wife.Did she want the marriage to be called off? No. She got her rights as a wife and as DIL of the family without going to court.
Didn'Anandi get Dsa punished by what ever legal means available to her when Dsa decided to get Jagya married for a second time?If Gauri and her parents didn't think that justice was done to them it was teir own foolishness and later on when Jagya decided that he had enough of Gauri and dumped her it was her fault that she didn't hold him by his collar and questioed Jagya and not Anandi's.

Was there any legal punishment available for what Gauri adn Sanchi did to Anandi?

Was Jagya wrong to dump her or was he wrong in insulting her and abusing her ?Was he wrong in wanting Gauri as his wife? Was his marriage with Anandi his decsion?If he is being punished for breaking a marriage that happened without his consent then shouldn't her parents and Jagya's parents be punished too along with Jagya?The crime happened when she was a child and she was scared that police will take her parents away and she lied to the police and said no bal vivah happened. Shouldn't she be also punished for hiding the marriage?So when everybody was at fault why only one person should go to jail?

Didn't she make sure that Basant and Gehna got punished for what ever they did against that worker?Didn't she make sure that family from whom Jagya stole chapatis and caused grievious injury get justice? Even if it meant shaming the family in public?

So where did her family members get away when they were aggressors against weaker people and were indulging in criminal activities?


441597 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#34
Okay blushing, let's see what AnSh do after DB's truth is finally out. If Anandi hides this from the family even after that, we can conclude that DB got away. Because in no way she can be punished without the family coming to know.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#35
She stalled justice in roti chori case - panchayats are local self government for welfare schemes - law and order does not come under panchayats. She stopped Shiv saying that panchayat will deal with it - and gave 'punishment' just to help the family - J would have got jail for what he did - causing grievous injury to the person.
She did not file bigamy case. J was not wrong in wanting Gauri as wife - but he was guilty of bigamy - which was buried because he was family.

She could not punish DS because she herself was too young at the time the crime was committed. And the mahapanchayat was called by Bhairo and Gauri's father - Anandi was too young to do anything except to answer the questions asked by panchayat members. So, it is not right to say Anandi did whatever she could to get DS punished. And mahapanchayat punished the matchmaker by taking away her right to earn livelihood and DS just had to ask for maafi from Anandi and Gauri - while panchas agreed that what DS did was enough to send her to jail - but she was given benefit of her position in Jaitsar. That is how 'punishment' for certain people are given in this serial.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#36
It was Anandi who decided to fight and she said he was his wife and she will not accept second marriage of Jagya. The decision to fight came from Anandi and Bhairon Singh in his capacity as her guardian acted on behalf of her or else why would he go against his own mother?It was not Bhairon Sing's decision.But the fact was is that Anandi did make sure that Dsa was punished for what Dsa has done to her.
Stalled the justice or gave the justice that the people of the village wanted in Jagya's case?
Panchayats do dispense justice at local level and she did it on behalf of the village.


Was Jagya's case buried only because of the family? Jagya's bigamy case was only he responsible for what happened to him?Yes she didn't want Singhs to face the humilaition of seeing their son in jail?
But was Jagya only the culprit?In the entire scenario?



SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#37
Elected panchayat under local self government do not dispense justice - panchayat of village elders - khap panchayat or kangaroo courts do take law and order in their hands and their decisions are full of injustices.
I think for bigamy only J was culprit - not the family (Gauri was also culprit, but Anandi was not thinking of Gauri when she decided not to file the case - Anandi's concerns are visible when she recently got to know about Gauri's accident - thinking about J and not the person injured).
swathimanjula69 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#38
In a way Anandi&shiv is right too. It is drugs which DB cannot make. they want to find root source of such harmful drugs and to remove it from society. Being dist.collector shivs morale responsibility is to act on for the benefit of the society. Once they caught DB will be exposed by Alok to the family as he has seen DB purchasing material from fake baba. Anandi has very clearly told DB she will never pardon her for the crime DB did to her
goofyCat thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#39
Hiding things from family is definitely not going to help in long term.

But, is the whole story finished yet? What Anandi and Shiv did at that point was not hastily sharing it with family and add to the already tensed situation. They are handling situation in logical manner also- decided to catch the drug seller, collected the residual stuff from DB so as to use it later as evidence.

Anandi's reasoning might have been bit inexcusable there, but what she did was thinking from Daddu's point of view at that time. How does it make her selfish and one-sided 😕

The same Anandi didn't hesitate to go against Sanchi even though she was her family. Had anyone in their family committed a crime as offensive as Saruabh's, I don't think Anandi or Shiv had kept quiet and let the culprit go away.

In current situation, tracing the drug seller is their priority. After things are sorted out on that front, Anandi and Shiv can share things with someone else in the family and leave it to them to decide, whether to share with Daddu and others or not.

Lastly, don't want to see a repeat of Sanchi's story here.. What all things Sanchi did hiding from family never came to light. But hopefully that will not happen with DB!
jhansijhansi thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#40
I feel there is no meaning to judge Anandi's charecter it is pointless and worthless, we are used to say that Anandi is great so we see in that point and get dissapointed instead look Anandi also as one of the character next to saachi then we can watch the serial... since as a child she has been protecting her family and herself and get anyone arrested no value for other families in this world may be it is pooli's parents or saurabs parents except her parents and in-laws no one else will feel the pain.

Anandi is always been loved and supported by big people in the village bhairon and sumitra later dadisa and shiv collector and rest of the family is around her so instead of sitting at home she is giving bashans and time pass.

As a kid she did not tell the truth that she wanted to study and not marry to the police because she did not want her parents to be arrested, but with the help of bhairo she took police to pooli's marriage and got her parents arrested.

Vivek should be ashamed seeing anandi or even worth dying first thing being a lawyer and coming from a respectable family could not notice what her younger brother is doing what sort of friendship he is doing and at least warn his brother and never tried to change him except hating him...look at Anandi she saved saachi so many times in jagiyas case or even when she almost tired to kill ganga...and she knows that if the watchman would have not come then saachi and saurabh would have been together physically or atleast kiss, but still she did not let anyone know about it...if saurabh was in Anandi's family then she would have proved that saachi really loved him and proved that they both were in the saachi's bedroom, mai manthi hoon usne galathi ki aur vuskeliye hum vuse maf nahi karsakthe, but we need to think that he still really loved her and so because he does not want to lose her he did that so at least for two families respect and maa and baap ke kathir please let saachi forgive him i know it is difficult and would have made saachi marry saurabh.


It is best to watch her just like better character next to saachi, DB, Ira, sumitra, just bit cleaver and brave and good at giving bashans.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".