AnSh AT 196 :'An Affair to Remember' - Page 28

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

54.7k

Users

38

Likes

2.9k

Frequent Posters

maahi11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
excatly chahat... uski ander ki mamta jag agyi,,,, i guess sun we will see ansh baby also...
Muktchand thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
awww such cuite pie Anagha...

AnSh adopt this one someone else 😕


Edited by blushing - 11 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: RTee

Yes, the adoption topic was too sudden. Yes, there was not much build up. But then, have not the best discoveries been a sudden Eureka moment for the discoverers. Take Einsteins's discovery of gravity. He must have been thinking about it, but all it took was an apple falling on him😆.

Similarly, our Anandi and Shiv have been talking about having "bachcha" almost since they have been married. 😳And this visit to orphanage must have been Anandi's Eureka moment. She discovered she did want her own baby, but also wanted to make an unwanted child's life beautiful. Her husband concurred. "Jab miyan, bibi razi...".


Let us see how events unfold!

Arti - that wanting to adopt feeling may have come suddenly to her.
But the build up to that talk with Shiv was not there.
They sould have shown her thinking about the baby the orphan status and so on so forth and her feelings about having a baby mother hood all these at least they could have given us some monologues.
BV CVs are famous in detailing when so much detailing was done about evry emotion which Sanchi was going through why did they not dedicate at least half an episode to elaborate on Anandi's mindset?
After that conversation at least they could have shown Shiv thinking about it or atleast shown how he felt about the idea of adoption even if did say yes.
Why can't they show these in detail?Or is it because only Sanchi's story desrves so much detailing and not AnSh?

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: blushing

Yo...Well As acting wise its superb scene

expressions...all well...BD also used in close up shots 😆

content wise...its bit...A looked demanding felt bad for Shiv.

A saw abandoned baby being super sensitive she felt we shd adopt child...Shiv agrees too.

When Shiv said Its good Idea. They will talk with family A got super excited. I feel A doesn't want to have own kid


I like fact Shiv asked her...don't A wanted to enjoy motherhood. A do yes though. But something was missing.

I felt if Ansh adopt child A won't try for own kid. Shiv again agree.

Why CV try make A like this...over sensitive.

This Adoption track is only for digging past of Shiv or AnSh really gona adopt baby.

At least along with me and Kushi someone else also feels that the scene feels incomplete.
--------
BDs in AnSh scene - I didn't think they were there.
Muktchand thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
@ appy really u gals feels same 😆


I think its Writers fault why on earth they are not showing depth of emotions with such sensitive topic

Acting wise its fine.👍🏼..content wise...Its nt at emotional...WHY 😡😡😡

Its kid topic Why Shiv and A conversation is always like Shiv teasing A 😕

I cried when Orphanage lady said baby Anagha got injury 😭😭


********************

BD well in close up shots...only...

A 's hair look Red from behind 😆


Edited by blushing - 11 years ago
RTee thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Arti - that wanting to adopt feeling may have come suddenly to her.
But the build up to that talk with Shiv was not there.
They sould have shown her thinking about the baby the orphan status and so on so forth and her feelings about having a baby mother hood all these at least they could have given us some monologues.
BV CVs are famous in detailing when so much detailing was done about evry emotion which Sanchi was going through why did they not dedicate at least half an episode to elaborate on Anandi's mindset?
After that conversation at least they could have shown Shiv thinking about it or atleast shown how he felt about the idea of adoption even if did say yes.
Why can't they show these in detail?Or is it because only Sanchi's story desrves so much detailing and not AnSh?


Frankly Aparna, last few months all AnSh tracks have been so poorly detailed and have been so sketchy, whatever the reasons for this may be (incidentally I realise what they are, but to me the reasons are inexcusable), that we have ended up getting just flashes of what could be happening in their lives. Instead of writers writing scenes properly, we viewers have had to allow our brains to work overtime for filling the blanks.

Today after a long time it felt that a track is finally being written for them. Can only wish that they talk some more about it. Else it is sure that the baby will be in KB on Monday.
Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: blushing

@ appy really u gals feels same 😆


I think its Writers fault why on earth they are not showing depth of emotions with such sensitive topic

Acting wise its fine.👍🏼..content wise...Its nt at emotional...WHY 😡😡😡

Its kid topic Why Shiv and A conversation is always like Shiv teasing A 😕

I cried when Orphanage lady said baby Anagha got injury 😭😭


********************

BD well in close up shots...only...

A 's hair look Red from behind 😆

Acting was fine from both sides.It is the writers who did a bad job.
Agree looked at that scene again there were BDs of both.

They gave it a feel as if Anandi is doing it like it is part of social service.Dialogue writer is at fault but shouldn't the director check whether those lines are okay before approving those lines?

The scene in the orphanage was more emotional and realistic.

Bruce_L thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Appy, no one around are happy with the scene. Its visible from the pace of AT.
Cant even say this loud as to avoid unnecessary criticizing happening of the characters cos if it was their fault as a character, then its interesting to get into debate but if its not their fault cos of screentime, then???
They showed she asked for adoption as like a toy, and her hubby to make her happy as always agreed to fulfil her wish.
Ofcouse, its the team fault. They did try to show her motherhood wish, when she went silent for a moment as he asked do she want to adopt a child. But then after that it went drain. That one moment was what I felt maybe more to it in coming days.
And to feel the depth of the scene, it should be always as
Quantity of screentime + Quality of acting = Depth of content, for any kind of scene.
Today's scene lacked Quantity, whom to blame?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: RTee


Frankly Aparna, last few months all AnSh tracks have been so poorly detailed and have been so sketchy, whatever the reasons for this may be (incidentally I realise what they are, but to me the reasons are inexcusable), that we have ended up getting just flashes of what could be happening in their lives. Instead of writers writing scenes properly, we viewers have had to allow our brains to work overtime for filling the blanks.

Today after a long time it felt that a track is finally being written for them. Can only wish that they talk some more about it. Else it is sure that the baby will be in KB on Monday.

Even I was so happy with this adoption track and all of sudden Shiv's past what ever it may becoming up because finally they have a track for them.In this scene they both did a good job acting so they cannot be blamed for it.

They probably wanted to give her some time to settle down agreed but now all those woes are over and whatever acceptance she can get she got it and now it is completely dependant on the tracks she is getting and how the tracks are handled.

She did prove that she can do a good job if the scene is written well.I don't know what the director is doing shouldn't he check the scenes and see how they have been written before he starts executing them?



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".