W/U 28/05/13 (J's journey to Udaipur)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

642126

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

#41

@Sidra

Well sorry but degree is NOT just a piece of paper. Jagya cannot do surgeries. It's no joke.

Lal Singh also did MS if I am not mistaken. If he did not then I am sorry for the oversight.

Quote

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#42

Skep - gotta agree with Sidra. Dr. Jagat is almost MS not just MBBS. And rural hospital mein its doctors do more things outside their expertise then in bigger hospitals. And Sonography is not surgery.

But, teaching?🤣 Now there CVs are stretching... Even Sanchi doing project on rural hospitals? Gimme a Break

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: Skepblun
@Sidra

Well sorry but degree is NOT just a piece of paper. Jagya cannot do surgeries. It's no joke.

Lal Singh also did MS if I am not mistaken. If he did not then I am sorry for the oversight.

No - Lal Singh only did MBBS not MS. They parted company before J started his MS.

Quote

Surish

@Surish

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#44

Quote

642126

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

#45

Well Anjana, legally he cannot do what he is doing without his degree. Secondly, even if he has MS training it's still odd that he does procedures in all departments be it neuro, ortho or gynae! (Gauri and LS also did the same. It looks improbable and is an obvious blooper)

Thirdly, I know he did just a sonography. But he delivery will also be done by him only. Operation toh Daaktar sa hi karenge. So what if he did not do operation now?

Fourth, yeah it is odd how he became guest lecturer at Sanchi's college. It's abrupt (without showing college authorities or theirt decision o justification for inviting him). Colleges don't invite guest lecturers for heck of it. And they don't invite just about everyone. Only exceptional people or most highly qualified and experienced ones are invited. Jagya does not fit any of these criteria. I don't know how he was called as guest lecturer!

LS is just an MBBS?! Wow! So another MBBS doing everything at village hospital! God save the Jetsar villagers! Some medical care they are receiving. Haha!

Sorry I was under impression his MS was done. He's surely below Jagya then in terms of training and expertise!

Quote

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#46

Skep - yup Jagya n LS are bin license jacks of all medical trades in BV. As for delivery, J already did one in Mumbai and even got offered a job in an obsterics practice, remember. Coming to Gauri, she is most qualified of the three both in terms of experience and education based on what they have shown. She in fact could be a better guest lecture as she was in-charge of an unit at a prestigious hospital in Mumbai and is more qualified.

Guess J's qualification is his MBBS and running a rural hospital built by his family. Also his handling of the Mahamari (Epidemic).

That said, Sanchi's university is probably as good as their star student🤣 so even Nathu could be guest lecturer on sabzi managment for a day.

Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 12 years ago

Quote

divine_ram

@divine_ram

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#47

Thankyou for the update. This whole week we have tolerate saanchi jagya story which is a repetition of jagya saving again saanchi from the same boys gang. I would rather watch jagya with singhs than with manipulative saanchi. If this whole drama is to create MU btw ansh then it's better skip the episodes.

Quote

aparnauma

@GoodDoc_2105

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#48

What Jagya and Lal Singh are doing is general practice.

A general practitioner can do a lot of things.

He can perform emergency C sections and surgeries give ante natal care for pregnant women treat am emergency care for heart patients accident patients or even handling epidemics etc So jagya and Lal Singh as MBBS doctors they should be able to do all these things.If they think they their patient needs a higher level of expertise they should be stabilise the patient and send them to facility which is of higher level

All those things they are doing do not depend on degree but experience and expertise and the facilities in their set up.

What he cannot do is open up someone heads or hearts and operate on them even if they do ultrasound they cannot sign out an ultra sound report or lab test report.

As for Jags delivering a guest lecture on management of rural hospital I guess it is quite acceptable even if he is giving it in a college that teaches business management.I am sure he can give a talk on how to set up and run financially viable health care unit in rural India.

But what the CVs show is obviously what they feel like showing

Quote

SPuja

@SPuja

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#49

Thanks Esha for written update.

And Happy Birthday Anita.

I am really disappointed with the way they show any profession/studies.

- Exhibition of latest medical equipment was held in MBA college.

- They never show Sanchi studying/attending classes. Even when she was in hostel, it was just friends, phone and movies.

- How and when Jagya made the project?

- Which college allows students to get the project made by outsiders and then go on inviting that person for lecture?

- And very bad examples of adult education also. First Anandi and now Ganga completing studies superfast. Ganga a third class pass person taking tenth board exams within a few months of studies. Do CVs know that there is a registration process for even open school exam. It is not that any person can appear in exam when exams are held. The woman who could not set the bag of a fifth standard student is giving tenth board exam whithin a few months- poor Nandu, he is still in fifth grade. This track gives wrong message that completing education after years of desruption is easy.Even regular students have to study hard to give tenth board.

- Cvs should keep emotional drama out of education/exam. There was no need to show she was allowed to keep the photo during exam. They could show that the lady invigilator was sympathetic, but followed the rules and did not allow the photo during exam.

- Wondering what was the subject of Jagya's lecture. He is no expert in management. Even the hospital was set up and was run till recently by others. He was made its head just because he is Bhairo Singh's son and not because he has some special quality in medicine or hospital management. They also did not show that the hospital was in ruin and then Jagya made it a good hospital due to his managerial skills.

- If CVs do visit the forum, I request them to make some research and show somewhat realistic tracks.