what was the point of sumitra's letter? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

4.3k

Users

25

Likes

147

Frequent Posters

Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: apjk

Neither the letter scene nor Jagya and Gauri scene are fillers. Both the scenes are important in moving the story forward.There was only one scene which can be called as a filler.But I did not mind that filler scene at all 😉

Hmm..How was Sumitra's letter important in moving the story forward?:O
Yes, The JG scene was an important one , it was required but the length of that scene indicated that it they just wanted to pull up some minutes.
And , LOL..are you saying that the Shiv scene was a filler? Haha!! lol..well yes that scene wasnt really required like the letter scene but come on the CV's have to satisfy the large no. of AnSh fans who might not have watched all thsoe 1000 episodes but have helped give the show a push from the 5-10 rank range to Rank 2😆😉
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#32
Khushi - read through this thread and people have explained the import of Sumi scene beautifully, but beauty lies in the eye of the beholder, na? For you, shiv scene has value.. likewise for others Sumi scene has value.
Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 13 years ago
Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#33
@Anjana- I read them😊. As everyone said the scene was beautiful , it is important to console Anandi through this time and the scene was there to console Anandi but didnt she console her earlier as well through Skype? If the scene wasnt a filler then why didnt they show Bhairon giving her this letter earlier only instead of the skype chat? And Yes! The scene was good , it is important to console a daughter through this phase but How is that moving the story forward?? :O
Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: AnjanaYYZ

Khushi - read through this thread and people have explained the import of Sumi scene beautifully, but beauty lies in the eye of the beholder, na? For you, shiv scene has value.. likewise for others Sumi scene has value.

When did i say it has value Anjana?😕 I said that scene wasnt required but it was added just to make the AnSh fans happy😳 The Sumi scene as i said might have value but i dont think it anyway helped move the story forward.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: Khushi.

Hmm..How was Sumitra's letter important in moving the story forward?:O
Yes, The JG scene was an important one , it was required but the length of that scene indicated that it they just wanted to pull up some minutes.
And , LOL..are you saying that the Shiv scene was a filler? Haha!! lol..well yes that scene wasnt really required like the letter scene but come on the CV's have to satisfy the large no. of AnSh fans who might not have watched all thsoe 1000 episodes but have helped give the show a push from the 5-10 rank range to Rank 2😆😉

But it is not ANSH fans who made the show run for 1000 episodes.If they want their show to run for another 1000 episodes they have to continue to show the sensible thought provoking as well as entertaining stuff they had been showing over the past 1000 episodes.By the way when gauri made entry also the TRPs went up.When Gauri and Jagya story became monotonouus they brought in Shiv.If they keep on showing only ANSH scenes then also it becomes monotonous and the TRPs will drop.
Balika Vadhu fans existed much befor ANSH came into existence.
Mother's letter to her daughter is a very realistically done scene. Like I said befor Mother's' letters to her daughter will invariably be long.
Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: apjk

But it is not ANSH fans who made the show run for 1000 episodes.If they want their show to run for another 1000 episodes they have to continue to show the sensible thought provoking as well as entertaining stuff they had been showing over the past 1000 episodes.By the way when gauri made entry also the TRPs went up.When Gauri and Jagya story became monotonouus they brought in Shiv.If they keep on showing only ANSH scenes then also it becomes monotonous and the TRPs will drop.
Balika Vadhu fans existed much befor ANSH came into existence.
Mother's letter to her daughter is a very realistically done scene. Like I said befor Mother's' letters to her daughter will invariably be long.

AnSh fans are also Balika Vadhu fans. Yes, the major teenagers who have started seeing this show beacuse of Ansh might not be regular BV fans but if the those BV fans who made the show run for 4+ years are imp then the people who made it come to a TRP range of 5 are also important right? And well , i am damn sure that AnSh story will never get monotonous..not because we all love Shiv and want desperately see a love story but beacuse we all and i am sure you aswell want to see a happy Anandi living her life the way she deserves to. And you very rightly said that they obviously need to show the sensible part..its important in holding on to the regular audience and at teh same time they need to make it entertaining aswell..absolutely right . But, personally i would anytime skip the sad scenes , the melodramatic scenes and the undesirable scenes and obvious is the fact that if i see all such scenes as non-entertaining then i will obviously speak this way because this is my defination of entertainment and watchable stuff , yours can be different of course. And all i meant with my previous comment was that for me a Shiv scene is for what i watch the show- Its my choice of entertainment and my priority while seeing Balika Vadhu.😃
So, Yes! different people , different thoughts and different choices of entertainment. Agreed right?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: Khushi.

Hmm..How was Sumitra's letter important in moving the story forward?:O
Yes, The JG scene was an important one , it was required but the length of that scene indicated that it they just wanted to pull up some minutes.
And , LOL..are you saying that the Shiv scene was a filler? Haha!! lol..well yes that scene wasnt really required like the letter scene but come on the CV's have to satisfy the large no. of AnSh fans who might not have watched all thsoe 1000 episodes but have helped give the show a push from the 5-10 rank range to Rank 2😆😉

Sorry it got posted twice.
Edited by apjk - 13 years ago
Khushi. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: apjk

But it's not ANSH fans who made the show run for 4 years.I am sure if they want their show to run for 4 years they have to continue to show what they have been showing the past 4 years that is entertaining as well as thought provoking stuff which connceted with majority of the audience.
If I remember TRPs went up when Gauri entered Jagya and Anandi's lives.They showed GAGA romance for more than year,It got monotonous.That's why Shiv was brought in. If they keep showing only ANSH scenes then also TRPs will drop.

As I said before mother's letters to her daughter will always be long and repetitive.
As for Jagya and Gauri scene it is important because it involves Jagya who happens to be the other part of the bal vivah that happened.He is Anandi 's groom and equally important to this story.Balika vadhu is Anandi and Jagya's story and about the people they come across in their lives.That includes Shiv and Gauri.

Hey , I said what i wanted to above. I'll repeat it- We have a different choice of entertainment i guess , i would anytime see a romantic track and wont mind seeing it any no. of years!!really! For you the chocie of entertainment might be different- Its simple😃
prerna4rishav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: tinoo

sumitra has said the same things to anandi several times over ... so I didnt see the point of sumitra's letter to anandi today saying the same thing yet one more time...

was there any broader significance?


Broader significance in the sense, till now Anandi was their DIL.. Their responsibility.. The wife of their son.. ( even if they say Jagya is not their son anymore, he will always remain one )..

But after this divorce, it was an assurance to Anandi that they are still with her..It was a repetition of same dialogs, but the impact on Anandi's mind changes with time and situation .. It was a perfect time for Sumitra to convey to her laado that her relationship with them is independent of Jagya 😳

Now after few days, when Anandi will be married to Shiv, again Sumitra will say the same thng.. It will hold another significance that time too 😉

Waise bhi, keep telling your loved ones time to time about how much they mean to you, always carries a special feeling 😉😳 It gives hausla, strength 😳
Manasi_16 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#40
Gudddiii! I am loving both ur PRB Siggys😳😳😳😳😳 Which means I will now have to update my own...kya karti hai yaar...at least for some days let me keep the existing ones w/o wanting to change😆😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".