Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

3k

Users

13

Frequent Posters

scorpio_pk thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#11
If slap would be the solution of all problems then parents would definitely love to slap their children on every other thing, but the problem is the new generation who always go for the reasonings,they need to know all facts of life very clearly, truly.
Minnie thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 20 years ago
#12

Here I feel forced to compare the situation between Astha and Sia. Astha came to know that she was adopted and that too by her Dad's ex wife. She also came to know that Simran was supposed to have been the reason for her own mother's death.

How? An old woman who told her that. And she believed her and started hating her mom. Never tried to find out what the truth was. Even Poonam tried to tell her otherwise, but obviously that did not suit her taste for melodrama. Even now she knows that her nani is mad, a mental case. But instead of finding out the details, she chooses to blame everybody around her.

Yet with Sia, the worst thing that anyone could have imagined had happened. She was deliberately kidnapped, taken away from her parents and lied to. In that respect, Sia too should have hated her nani, her mom. Should have refused to forgive her mom even while she was dying.

Astha is far more better placed. Simran was supposedly responsible for her mom's death. But Sia's mom herself accepted that she kidnapped her and kept her in the dark, mislead her, acted foul.......what not. yet Sia forgave her mom, her nani.

Both the girls' moms tried to give the best to their respective adopted kids, the fear of the loosing them egging them to hide the reality, both the girls coming to know of their parentage in a very dramatic manner, one knowing her own mom is dead, the other forced to face an odipeus complex.......... I wonder who was worse placed?

This perhaps alone shows how selfish, how self centred Astha really is. Had she not been, Simran would have been the first person to bring Abhi and Sia home, and tell her daughter that her family was complete......

Astha is definitely the spoiled brat. And she is making everyone suffer.....................

Mulan08 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#13
I agree completely with Minnie.
dcsilsprgreen thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#14
Ok is just a show.... aastha (neha's daughter) is just playing her part👏. If you were in her shoes, there is a chance of you reacting the way that Aastha has. Dr.Simran just needs to have more control over aastha.😊
peacestead thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: hinduengg

Aastha is really malicious ! I wonder if she ever introspects .Even before her present crisis she used to be mean to anyone she didn't like and now she has gone so hyper that she thinks nobody else has a right to come wee bit close to her family.And look at the way poor Sid is being browbeaten to respond to Aastha's love even though he loves Sia. All because Baby would be hurt .Aastha then , really is a baby , a peevish foul mouthed one! She ought to grow up !

She takes everyone for granted.Its high time someone put some sense to her .She speaks exactly like her nani!

i second everything that you have written. i have never hated anyone on tv as much as i hate her.

peacestead thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: simi1295

its just that she was brought up that way...simran gave her everything she ever wanted and now she has gottn used to gettn her way.... i think its simrans fault for bringn her up that way...

what about basic humanity and empathy? that comes from inside!!!!! you dont learn these virtues, you either have them or you dont.Being spoilt doesnt mean being cruel and inhuman , simran did'nt teach her to be mean, nasty, small minded, suspicious , utterly lacking in remorse ? One can be spoilt silly and still have a conscience and a heart.

peacestead thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Minnie

Here I feel forced to compare the situation between Astha and Sia. Astha came to know that she was adopted and that too by her Dad's ex wife. She also came to know that Simran was supposed to have been the reason for her own mother's death.

How? An old woman who told her that. And she believed her and started hating her mom. Never tried to find out what the truth was. Even Poonam tried to tell her otherwise, but obviously that did not suit her taste for melodrama. Even now she knows that her nani is mad, a mental case. But instead of finding out the details, she chooses to blame everybody around her.

Yet with Sia, the worst thing that anyone could have imagined had happened. She was deliberately kidnapped, taken away from her parents and lied to. In that respect, Sia too should have hated her nani, her mom. Should have refused to forgive her mom even while she was dying.

Astha is far more better placed. Simran was supposedly responsible for her mom's death. But Sia's mom herself accepted that she kidnapped her and kept her in the dark, mislead her, acted foul.......what not. yet Sia forgave her mom, her nani.

Both the girls' moms tried to give the best to their respective adopted kids, the fear of the loosing them egging them to hide the reality, both the girls coming to know of their parentage in a very dramatic manner, one knowing her own mom is dead, the other forced to face an odipeus complex.......... I wonder who was worse placed?

This perhaps alone shows how selfish, how self centred Astha really is. Had she not been, Simran would have been the first person to bring Abhi and Sia home, and tell her daughter that her family was complete......

Astha is definitely the spoiled brat. And she is making everyone suffer.....................

I SO agree with you. what was astha lacking in her life, she could have had a much worse fate if someone else had brought her up, simran brought her up like a princess , I agree that to discover that the mom you thought was your real mom is actually your adoptive mom is very disturbing and can turn your life upside down but hey @#it happens in life and you gotta deal with it. SIa had it much worse, Astha was basically living Sias life, to discover that you were kidnapped and your rightful place is now taken up by someone else would shake the most reasonable human being, even then SIa has taken it in stride, she still bears no animosity towards Astha, and she still had feelings for her Nani and Mom inspite of the despicable action of her mother. Her heart was big enough to forgive and it is big enough for her to share her mom and house with Ashta.Both girls had rude awakenings in life but it is the grace and dignity with which sia faced her problems that makes her a better and more likable person.Sias heart has room for so many people but astha has room in her heart only for astha, its me, me , me all the time.

ANGADLUVSKRIPA! thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 20 years ago
#18
i just can't stan astha. she's a BIG spoiled brat!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".