Arjun- copy of Castle

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

sehar mehrotra

@sehar mehrotra

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

After yesterdays case...I too think so...not exactly a copy but the cases are sumwhat similar!!!

This is completely a Police show while castle is only about Castle/beckett relationship+ a lil of police investigation...

Quote

elle..

@elle..

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: meghasingh
@trinitinyx you are absolutely right that criticism should be received nicely, but you can't expect this behavior from people who are in love... AND WE ARE MAD IN LOVE WITH ARJUN FROM THE CORE OF OUR HEART.

truly madli deeeply in love😳😳

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Raichu-

@-Raichu-

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: trinitynyx
You're absolutely right! Today's episode, especially, reminded me of Castle.

PS: sparkshimmer wasn't criticizing the show, he/she was making an observation. There's a difference.

PPS: a show and it's fanclub need to be able to handle criticism and constructive criticism. Everyone has their opinion and they have the right to express it.

PPPS: "Women exploitation, child mariage, organ dealing, bribe in education is something common in India that isn't in USA or UK"
False. These things do happen in the United States. If you lived here, you would know. I agree they are not rampant among the population as in India, but they do occur.

Sorry you have misunderstood me !!

I never watched Castle but I just said that even if it's a copy it's adapted to our culture !!

and I never said that Women exploitation, child mariage, organ dealing, bribe in education doesn't occur abroad, I said it's not COMMON ! But I have never seen any american serial to focus on it !

Personnaly I have watched a lot of detective serials (I'm a big fan of this genre) and I do know that at some entent the cases are similar.

It wasn't my intention to criticize anyone, I just wanted to share my POV 😃😃

Edited by R66725 - 12 years ago

Quote

parheezGM

@parheezGM

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: sparkshimmer
Castle the english television series which is a crazy hit which involves Richard Castle and Kate Beckett. Only difference is that Castle is a mystery writer and Kate is a police officer.

Arjun has a different cast setup but the crimes are exactly similar..!!

I know I know!! I came to this forum to say exactly that only. How pathetic is that!! They actually thought that they would show this and no one else would know? What rot!!

Quote

Tabassum

@Arieltabi

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

The case could similar. But I don't think its a total copy. I love detective stories. I have read a lot detective novels. While watching CID n other shows like that I have found a lot seen a lot of cases which r similar to my books. I think this shows writers get inspirations from various detective novels. So the cases could b a little similar.

Quote

sehar mehrotra

@sehar mehrotra

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: timepassTP

I know I know!! I came to this forum to say exactly that only. How pathetic is that!! They actually thought that they would show this and no one else would know? What rot!!

Guys constructive criticism is always welcome for the show, but do not directly point out or call the show "Pathetic/Rot". If you don't like it, dun watch it. You have that choice

Quote

parheezGM

@parheezGM

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: sehar mehrotra

Guys constructive criticism is always welcome for the show, but do not directly point out or call the show "Pathetic/Rot". If you don't like it, dun watch it. You have that choice

And I also have the right to post in any forum I want.

I am a big fan of the castle series and I find it pretty annoying when Indian writers devoid of any good ideas take up not only the stories but also the climaxes and pass it off as their own.

The rules of the forums states clearly that I should not say sexually graphic messages or use po*nographic languages or abuse anyone using slang or said something wrong about anyone's country or religion etc etc., since I have not done either then I don't see why u are being so uppity about it.

Many serials copy dialogues and scene from famous srk movies. And I. Criticize them as well. It is u who is narrow minded and can't accept any minutely negative comment of the show. I suggest some growing up is in order dearie!!

Edited by timepassTP - 12 years ago

Quote

sehar mehrotra

@sehar mehrotra

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#18

Give me break!!

Even I'm a die hard Castle fan, but just because one case had a similar story doesn't mean u start calling the entire show a copy.

If u read the character sketch u'll come to know how different the two are.

Anyways, I'm done with this topic.

Quote

parheezGM

@parheezGM

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: sehar mehrotra
Give me break!!

Even I'm a die hard Castle fan, but just because one case had a similar story doesn't mean u start calling the entire show a copy.

If u read the character sketch u'll come to know how different the two are.

Anyways, I'm done with this topic.

When did I say that the whole show is copied?? Are you sure you read the whole thing? I was only referring to the case shown on Saturday where the 'adla badli' factor has been copied from a case shown in castle. Bas that's it.

Quote

salta

@salta

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#20

ARJUN AND ARIYA LOVERS...please just stop commenting on this topic... we love arjun and that's it, I don't think we should give so much importance to those who thinks the show as 'pathetic' or 'rot'.
We do have better things... like drooling over someone😉 and imagining how hot he is gonna look today.😊

Quote

1 2 3

Arjun- copy of Castle - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics