We shouldn't compare Shruti with Anupama

Historia thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago
#1

Shruti and Anupama both lived in different world . Shruti was independent, educated , unmarried and lived in USA for many years .


Anupama was born in poor family , got married at the age of 19 , was abused for 26 years

Both of them have very different life and I think we shouldn't compare with eachother . as one has good luck and had more opportunities but the other one has nothing (before Anuj entry)

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.2k

Users

10

Likes

38

Frequent Posters

SmithaRam thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago
#2

The very meaning of the name Anupamaa is - “incomparable” .The show’s protagonist has proved it time and again that she is true to her name. She is unique indeed! smiley9

Dee-Dee thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago
#3

How long will people keep using her 26 yrs of abuse as an excuse to justify her current situation?


Who compared first of all? Devi Maa ka koi comparison hai hi nahi! And who would lile to be compared with a woman like Anupama?

Maa had a chance to have everything Shruti had since birth or has now including Anuj - Maa was married to a billionaire, could’ve sincerely completed her financial literacy course and become independent but she chose Shahs over everything and she chose this life over that dignified life she had.


So its her own doing. Ab bhi nahi sudhri, pehle Amdavad ki galiyo mein beijjati karati thi ab International Level pe Madam ke photu chap rahe hain….she is ridiculous!

InsaneDivine thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Dee-Dee

How long will people keep using her 26 yrs of abuse as an excuse to justify her current situation?



Even if she was an abuse victim, where did she bring her abusers to justice ? If Shahs were her abusers shouldn't they be in jail ? Even if they are not in jail shouldn't there be a perpetual tension in her body language, when she interacts with them ? Wouldn't an abuse victim want to avoid her abusers to the maximum extent she can ? Did any of this happen ? I never saw it.. Abuser Baa became Maa, Mishter Shah became galat when he was indeed ghatiya. She spent maximum time with them. When she was not with them, mentally she was there. Now even her children are abusers and criminals but she would still feed them after getting shouted at for the millionth time. For this she sacrificed opportunities, love, responsibilities, family and a potential happy life.


I believe as storytellers if the writers, producers seeked sympathy for an abuse victim from the audience, it was their obligation to bring the perpetrators to justice. It should have happened through Anupamaa. They owed it to their viewers. Cleverly changing the narrative, diluting the impact of the actions of those abusers, after they got the requisite attention and emotional investment from the audience, for the sake of longevity and as a result minting more money is deceitful towards the viewers. No one may ever challenge them but what they have done is still wrong and extremely sly. Wish the audience saw this.

Bodhianveshika thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago
#5

Incomparable, indelible, invincible to indefensible!

STPrincess thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago
#6

But who's comparing them ?

Do they not know, the great Maa hona requirements are at a different level ?

strancho thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2

Sarcastic Chatterbox

Posted: 1 years ago
#7

Arey Anupamaa insaan ho to na koi insaan se uski comparison ho.. wo to insaan hi nahi hai smiley37

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#8

Anupama only drawback is that she respect baa and try to do everything all alone other wise I don't see serious fault in anupama


Woh apni taraf se sabke liye jitna karne ki koshish karti hai but log anupama ki acvhai ko yaad nahi rakhte bus khaali buraai hi yaad rakhte hai

She is also human being aisi choti Moti galti to sabse hoti Hai no one is perfect

Eik ek baat anupama se umeed lagana yeh sahi baat nahi hai

Har cheej ke anupama ko crictise karna use dosh Dena yeh sahi baat nahi hau


And Shruti neither has children from other marriage neither she is divorcee But anupama is divorcee and had children from previous marriage and moreover different in age

To dono Shruti and anupama ki condition mei bahut farak hai

Anupama is 20 year older than Shruti to dono ke age ke hisaab ke soch mein farak hoga

--Ruchi-- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago
#9

Who compares Maa with Shruti? Maa ka kisi se koi comparison nhi hai because she is not a human she is God kyuki wo Maaaa haismiley9

HoneyBee7312 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: InsaneDivine


Even if she was an abuse victim, where did she bring her abusers to justice ? If Shahs were her abusers shouldn't they be in jail ? Even if they are not in jail shouldn't there be a perpetual tension in her body language, when she interacts with them ? Wouldn't an abuse victim want to avoid her abusers to the maximum extent she can ? Did any of this happen ? I never saw it.. Abuser Baa became Maa, Mishter Shah became galat when he was indeed ghatiya. She spent maximum time with them. When she was not with them, mentally she was there. Now even her children are abusers and criminals but she would still feed them after getting shouted at for the millionth time. For this she sacrificed opportunities, love, responsibilities, family and a potential happy life.


I believe as storytellers if the writers, producers seeked sympathy for an abuse victim from the audience, it was their obligation to bring the perpetrators to justice. It should have happened through Anupamaa. They owed it to their viewers. Cleverly changing the narrative, diluting the impact of the actions of those abusers, after they got the requisite attention and emotional investment from the audience, for the sake of longevity and as a result minting more money is deceitful towards the viewers. No one may ever challenge them but what they have done is still wrong and extremely sly. Wish the audience saw this.


Once again, these dolts didn't even need to do anything special. This is a remake of the far superior Bengali show Sreemoyee.
They could have just copied the OG scene for scene and it would have fetched a lot of eyeballs.

They never needed to show this nonsense in the first place!

The worst part is how aggressively defensive Anupama stans have become defending her ridiculous actions of going back to abusers again and again and the utterly regressive debate of adopted v/s biological child constantly getting dragged in between, berating the male love interest who actually respected and loved her, all to glorify abusers and perpetuate the skewed image of how a woman can never move on in life to better things if she has an abusive past and/or kids.

What a waste of opportunity.

Related Topics

Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima

17 days ago

Anupama fails to make Rahi Apologise

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/anupamaa-anupama-slaps-pakhi-and-makes-her-apologise-but-fails-to-do-the-same-with-rahi_225897

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/anupamaa-anupama-slaps-pakhi-and-makes-her-apologise-but-fails-to-do-the-same-with-rahi_225897
Expand ▼
Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

16 days ago

Anupama Ki Mahaan Nautanki

https://x.com/employedmeg/status/1955238976794792117

https://x.com/employedmeg/status/1955238976794792117
Expand ▼
Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima

17 days ago

Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

23 days ago

Why doesn’t Prathana call Anupama Baa

Why does the grandkids not call Anupamaa Baa instead Anuma what the heck Prathana should call Anupamaa Baa or Dadi Saas

Expand ▼
Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: myviewprem

24 days ago

Anupama can never be role model

Anupama can never be role model to women empowerment Women empowerment is breaking norms of old society of abuse and oppression and going...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".