Reflections and Analysis, Sept 1, 2007 - Page 3

Originally posted by: milleniumchief

I'm sorry but I cannot agree with the majority Here.

While Abilasha might have the best voice and all that, this is still a COMPETITION.

Forgetting your words 2 weeks in a row should be automatic disqualification. Abhas is just as old as her, he doesn't forget his lines so don't give me the excuse of "she's young so she forgot her lines"

Again, this is a competition, she should've been eliminated

I'd differ here. To me memorizing a song is not half important as singing it in sur/taal. Going by that, I'd see atleast half the contestants (incl. Toshi) go before her. Thats just another opinion.😊

Also, would like to write this for Sana :

Again to me the voice quality, her talent in singing in Sur (probably because of her classical training) is more important than the confidence she shows on the stage in the budding years. The more episodes she does, she will only gain confidence.
I have seen contestants (from other two shows) with tremendous confidence but horrid singing. Again going by that, I'd prefer talent(singing in sur) to confidence.
Again, this is just another opinion and as you said everyone has one.

@ sgsg: U're right that talent comes over confidence but when you're in a competition like this, unfortunately, everything counts as everything will counter for the votes out there. Had it been a contest judged solely by the judges and all, then talent would definitely be given preference. I've seen quite many results in recent years to see confidence and loyalty deciding a winner of a show rather than talent.. Quite sad a reality, but tis one...

Anyhow, for me, her voice quality is not extraordinary.. That's just me 😉 ~

Cheers,
Sana~

I find Abhilasha's voice very haunting😛 It stays in your mind long after you hear her sing... Its really sweet and special... She would be in my Top 3 anytime...

Abhilasha's voice surely stands out.. very very expressive, I guess... I seriously hope that she goes far in the contest!

But this is not an Abhilasha post... I will come back with my analysis of this week's show later 😳

Originally posted by: smartc

@ sgsg: U're right that talent comes over confidence but when you're in a competition like this, unfortunately, everything counts as everything will counter for the votes out there. Had it been a contest judged solely by the judges and all, then talent would definitely be given preference. I've seen quite many results in recent years to see confidence and loyalty deciding a winner of a show rather than talent.. Quite sad a reality, but tis one...

Anyhow, for me, her voice quality is not extraordinary.. That's just me 😉 ~

Cheers,
Sana~

Sure Sana. I dont intend to change anyone's opinion here. But dont you think intelligent people like us should see through the confidence quotient?

@ sgsg: I am looking at her overall as well. I guess talent lacking in confidence will often call undue attention to one's mistakes.

Cheers,
Sana~