**Spoiler** -- Manipulation: A Reality?

*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

A very valid point was raised here is that whether the results and the bottom 4 of the show are manipulated... I personally think all reality shows do that to some extent... some more some less... Even if the actual voting numbers are not manipulated (they even could be.. there is definitely a chance), the voting junta gets so for sure...

Arshpreet's elimination was probably the 2nd most dreaded one this week (after Abhilasha's)... She has always been an underdog, and inspite of being the best female voice (arguably over Abhilasha).. she would get more focus only over Prantika perhaps amongst all the finalists... The other reason was perhaps also the region she belonged from... Ishmeet has been reportedly getting a lot of support from his region and that does play against Arshpreet... I am happy that people stood by Ishmeet in this episode, after his tremendous 'Bheege honth', but then someone's gain was a terrible loss for many others....
Abhaas coming in the bottom 4 is an extreme surprise, and I am thinking what is the rationale behind the same (if any).. Is it the complacence from the voters on the highest scorer.. or is it the Agni mentor strategy that has backfired on them? Its like, OK they have downplayed the best singer of Prithvi.. so lets eliminate their best female singer and get the best male singer in bottom 4... Perhaps true..

The other thing that I find something different in this show so far is that other than the first elimination episode, more guys are coming in bottom 4 than girls... Is the show trying to give out a message that there is no gender voting here? Sumitra and Priyani being among the topmost hyped contestants just strengthens the speculation further...

Another interesting point analysed is that we have seen enough camera time being invested in the past weeks to cook up the Harshid Arshpreet story... Would Star want to put a full stop to all that investment so soon? I really wonder! Probably, this gives a strong suspision that Arshpreet may come back later as a wild card entry and there will be a selling drama created around that! For Arshpreet to come back on the show, I am ready to take in that drama...

The elimination of a Agni candidate this time was almost sure, as a 3rd elimination in a row would have made the Prithvi story very week... But then, that perhaps makes me think something else... It can so happen that the 'seemingly' less talented Prithvi gets eliminated early and there in comes a twist to the tale.. The final 6 probably get regrouped under these 2 teams and some of them hence get to work under 2 distinct mentoring styles... This is a huge shift and disruption in team dynamics.. the associated drama would be a new selling point... Is Gajji reading this?

Edited by *Jaya* - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.6k

Users

10

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

gk_09 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
You have brought some good points up but Im just so disappointed that if the news is true Arshpreet is eliminated! 😭
hothot43 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: *Jaya*


Arshpreet's elimination was probably the 2nd most dreaded one this week (after Abhilasha's)...



OMG, is Abhilasha gone ?? Pls tell me this is not true, I know, she screwed up last time, but she is fantastic nevertheless 😭 😭
kabhi_21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
the thing that the girls are getting support on this show is all the girls are really performing well.... in last episode amongst girls..... Abhilasha faltered with lyrics..... but she has been so versatile and in mind that we voted for her crazily..... and arshpreet was uninterested in the song... she paid for it... though i personally liked her performance as i had not heard the original....

second thing is as per spoiler, Ishmeet and arshpreet both are in bottom 4.... so is it that people are not voting for them as they think panjab will vote for them?????

punjab is a small state, many in suburbs are farmers.... and the votes are divided in harpreet, ishmeet and arshpreet.... people should vote them irrespective of whether others would vote or not....

whether star would take her back is undecided but i would not expect anything like that.... i just pity the girl who had the best voice amongst female contestants that she never got the public support 😭
ajooni thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
jaya,you have made some very valid points...just a few points..

abhaas being in bottom is somewhat believable,because we have been taking him for granted.he is my favourite yet i have not voted for him..i am so preoccupied with keeping the best talent pool in the show,it never occurred to me that abhaas needs it.this week on I will make sure to vote for him every week.

Arshpreet-unfortunately her mentors didnt have enough faith in her potential and it upset her I think.Also i feel that when one performs a song there should be a noor, a pleasant expression on the face even while singing a sad song..her expression is a bit forlorn-looking skywards while singing-so doesnt hold attention..(same is the case with harshit-he sings "tum mile dil khile" with such a murjhaya expression.)many in the forum felt that Arshpreet was the most vulnerable..I hope and pray that there is a wildcard and the take back one contestant for each gurukul 😃

priyani toshi and abhaas,i feel have the confidence and drive to reach the top 3.they choose the best songs,perform confidently and are at ease with themselves..we are only at top 10..a long way to go,cant believe a singer like Arshpreet has left so early😭 😭
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
There are 4 girls left now and of these Priyani and Sumithra seem to be
hyped by their gurus and popular with the Janta..

So one of my two favourites Abhilasha or Mirande are the next most likely
contestants to leave..
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Out of bottom 4 I thought Ishmeet should have left. Not any of those other 3. I want to hear good singers sing for longer time. I know someone has to go ea week but for a good singer to be eliminated prematurely feels sad. 😭
Edited by Dabulls23 - 18 years ago
jimhawkins thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
I dont think the voting results are cooked up... Arshpreet had been in the low vote getters right from the beginning... So also Irfan and Abhaas... If we see, the bottom contestants are pretty much consistent with just a few places up or down... I am sure Abhilasha, Toshi would prbably have been just somewhat better than these 4 but would still be in the bottom half... Its not as if the lowest of one episode gets the top 1-2 next week... The results seem to be genuine for voi...


kiti_g thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
agree with you sachin to an extent, i think the eliminations are happening as per the votes
that said i still feel that the others in the bottom 4 are cooked up based on some strategy cos it is difficult to explain both ishmeet and arshpreet in the bottom ...

but ... yday saw a preview of sumitra singing and the later comments and it appeared that she was in the bottom 4 so am kinda confused 😕
did anyone else see that preview and feel the same?
prnbghsh thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
So, who are in the bottom four....Can any one tell?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".