Antagonists and Protagonists - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.5k

Users

6

Likes

82

Frequent Posters

580212 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
Great Post Shridevi...I'm not sure what to write. You guys have written some great points.
moniluvskinshuk thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail 16th Anniversary Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

GHAJAB! 😎

I am totally with you on that then. That is to say I have not found anything lacking in Krishna's reactions but I too would like to see her do something. Hopefully this will start happening after she becomes a BDO. The convincing way in which her interview questions were asked and answered (I loved her answer about Bihar with all the historical references!) makes me believe that there is someone on the team who is doing research so I hope the same continues when she is a BDO, hopefully soon now.

Actually it is good that I caught you. Ursh and I were thinking of starting a daily discussion thread about the episode where each of us writes a general overview of our opinion on it, and then we discuss as the spirit moves us. From my experience of doing this on other forums I would say it is nice for just making genreal or specific comments for which you don't feel justified creating a whole new post.

What say? You in? I am thinking of starting from today's episode. 😊



Samana There is already a seperate Daily Discussion thread and Would love 2 hav ur all analysis in tht thread . Noone posts there but If U , Shri,Angel all would strat discussing Episodes there regularly then We all can join u bcozz me ,Rachu n others do tht in DBPS thread . So WOuld love 2 join there also .

Here is the link n We all can start it frm 2dy . What say ? Dis will make d forum more active also 😊

http://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2503526
Edited by moniluvskinshuk - 13 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
@Moni: Thanks for the link but I have found that it works better when you open a thread for each day, rather than have it all on one thread. So if you don't mind I am going to try that way for a few days as it is easy to navigate the threads and the activity of the forum will be more with more posts per day. I am saying this from the experience I have had on other forums. 😊

Ok I am off to make the thread now.
Edited by Samanalyse - 13 years ago
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

GHAJAB! 😎

Actually it is good that I caught you. Ursh and I were thinking of starting a daily discussion thread about the episode where each of us writes a general overview of our opinion on it, and then we discuss as the spirit moves us. From my experience of doing this on other forums I would say it is nice for just making genreal or specific comments for which you don't feel justified creating a whole new post.

What say? You in? I am thinking of starting from today's episode. 😊


Sam, I think I went offline just around the same time u sent me this note. It was quite late for me and it was time to bid good night for myself🥱

Anyways, its now morning to me...😊

Yes, go ahead and start making posts each day. The more the better for AB. I already do the kind that you suggested for HD with some of my friends there. Btw I saw you and Borna and Pink Chocolate, Jyoti6 doing ur lengthy posts in Punar Vivah forum 😆 Seems the show is a big craze. Some of us were wondering what happened to Borna, not writing anything on HD this week and it was surprise seeing her there. I am not watching Punar Vivah yet. It is my silent protest on Shashi -Sumit Mittal for making DABH the way it is now😡

About me. I am a free bird. I reply to posts with my thoughts if i have anything to contribute to it. Subjects and content matter a lot to me. If I don't see anything apt subject wise to express what I felt that day, I open a new post. So as long we all enjoy what we are doing without upsetting anyone, definitely works for me
AngeloScuro thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

@Moni: Thanks for the link but I have found that it works better when you open a thread for each day, rather than have it all on one thread. So if you don't mind I am going to try that way for a few days as it is easy to navigate the threads and the activity of the forum will be more with more posts per day. I am saying this from the experience I have had on other forums. 😊

Ok I am off to make the thread now.




I second that! Sometimes it's so hard to find the topic I want to find. Also I'd be happy if it could be fixed at the top of the AB page .
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
Well, here is the link for today's thread:

www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=2802157

I have started the discussion. 😊 Everyone please jump in!
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
Continuing on Antagonists and Protagonists in AB.

Last we discussed was on 23rd February. Since then the developments have been that:

1) Pinto and TT Singh are clear protagonist and Antagonist with ample screen time provided. Almost the entire 24th Feb to 9th March period was devoted around it. I need not go into depth here. Bit all Kinshukians and Pintuians and Prishna and AB followers know how the screen time has been enjoyed to the fullest by everyone of us.

2) Krishna's antagonists are now clearly defined by the creatives.
Her antagonists are not Tuntun Singh or Bihari Raj or Pinky Raj.
Her antagonists are:
IGNORANCE in Public welfare places
CORRUPTION in Govt. Places

On 22nd episode she already displayed that we cannot afford to be ignorant in places like hospitals, knowing our rights. When she reminds the doctors that they need to attend on Pinky asap and discuss the police formalities later on, it was the common man's right being reminded. It showed us we did not need a powerful Tuntun Singh for having doctors attend to us over our emergencies.

Likewise, Krishna's decision on getting her results re-examined was a much needed plot in the story to bring the message across to AB viewers, a social message on Rights and Duties.
The way Krishna emphasizes on ADHIKAR and KARTAVYA, never before have I seen so seamlessly being explained to me while watching a show supposed to entertain me and where I can keep half of mind to rest.
The only way we can fight corruption is through us fighting ignorance. And ignorance can be fought through education, but what I got the message is that Krishna does not just educate herself from academic books, she educates herself through any written source. She can read any paper, be it newspaper, magazine, notices, pamphlets, but yet any written thing that has truth in it will force its way through ignorance.

Loved these two new developments.
734167 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
thanks for such a lovely post.
AngeloScuro thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

If stories have antagonists set against protagonists it all should end in resolution to the conflicts arising when these two meet.

I would like to take the example of Alice in Wonderland.

In Alice in Wonderland all characters who Alice encounters during her trip through Wonderland are antagonists. They baffle her, confuse her, and order her about and even try to behead her. Even those who appear not mean to her are antagonists, as their strange behavior confuses Alice.

Conflict is happening every time Alice meets all these antagonists. The main conflict occurs in the trail, last chapter of the book. When Alice is called to give evidence she calls all the creatures 'nothing but a pack of cards' that rain down on her attacking in rage.

The resolution to this conflict is she wakes up.

So what will be the resolutions to all these conflicts that Krishna in Afsar Bitiya is going to face, some conflicts she has resolved but what will be the resolution for her main conflict and what lies ahead in the grand scale of this show is yet left to be seen.

Or is it going to be open ended just like life?

Edited by AngelDark - 13 years ago
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: AngelDark

If stories have antagonists set against protagonists it all should end in resolution to the conflicts arising when these two meet.

So what will be the resolutions to all these conflicts that Krishna in Afsar Bitiya is going to face, some conflicts she has resolved but what will be the resolution for her main conflict and what lies ahead in the grand scale of this show is yet left to be seen.

Or is it going to be open ended just like life?


Angel,

Here's ZEE TV's answer to your question. The bolded portion below.

Set in Bhagalpur (Bihar), Afsar Bitiya throws light on the importance of female education and issues surrounding their education. It talks about a young girl's resilience, aspirations, dreams and motivation to work harder and make a mark in society despite all adversities. The story traces the journey of Krishna, whose life centers around getting a good education to improve her family's life. She is quiet and demure yet a go-getter. From a lower middle class family where no one had ever got a better job than a clerk, this girl rises against all odds and happens to become a B.D.O. (Block Development Officer) through her sheer hard work. Her life and her family's life change forever after she becomes an 'Afsar Bitiya'. Krishna's unexpected achievement brings in a lot of happiness for her family, but is her happiness meant to stay forever? Her sudden accomplishment attracts not only fame but many difficulties. Will Krishna's values remain intact after she becomes 'Afsar Bitiya'? Will her position in the society allow her to become a doting and caring wife? Will the nature of her job allow her to remain an obedient daughter and a devoted daughter-in-law? How an honest and determined girl from a moderate background adapts to changing situations is what makes the narrative of AFSAR BITIYA a poignant one!


So we are gonna list all her antagonists in the manner as they come. And these antagonists will not be human but will be non-human personifications or states of mind to be put correctly. Like dishonesty, indecorum, ignorance, corruption with collateral damage being her loved ones.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".