So what if Abhi had several girlfriends

Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I can't believe that we would think a guy would be incapable of having a good heart or willing to do what is right if they happen to have had several girlfriends? 😕 I'm interested to see these girlfriends.
It's a pity though that he we didn't see them earlier; the show would have been more interesting as it would have made Simi (and the writers) work harder in explaining why he fell for her.
I have one word for the Sunshine team
L-A-Z-Y when it came to making the Abhi-Simi love story up.
By the way, the Anu is really cute. She's good competition for Simi. In front her, Simi does look old and frumpy.
Edited by Laila2009 - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.2k

Users

10

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

Bana thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
My thoughts exactly. Even a conservative person like RS would understand that given Abhi's age and high society background, it is normal for him to have had girlfriends - it's not like he was going around impregnating women a la Rajiv Bhalla!
Besides, that's in the past and as long as he loves only Simi now how should that matter. Even Anita was Anuj's girlfriend before they decided to marry, does that make Anuj a cad?
I truly hope the CVs won't destroy RS's character the way they done with others - he is shown as a level headed perceptive man who can tell genuine from shallow. How can he be taken in by Anita? Usually one reacts in the other extreme - when you have been wronged by someone you are unlikely to believe anything she says.
Besides as a self-confessed atheist (he doesn't have faith in Mata Rani), RS is already sort of non-conservative himself. I can appreciate if his disapproval stems from the consederable gap in age and background, and of course the feud between the families.
Lastly, I will never understand our typical Indian mentality of confusing a conservative v/s modern outlook with one's character/morality. There is no real corelation between having girlfriends, wearing modern clothes or going to the disc and being a bad person. Some of the worst bahus in real life are sari-clad sindoor-sporting homely types. And some of the most crooked businessmen are pious Tirupati-visiting family types!
Would be interesting to read members' views on the last mentioned.
carpe-diem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
having gfs doesn't make the person incapable at all...but the way anita has presented it is the worst way possible. there is nothing wrong with having a few gfs in the past but he is 21 now so how many has he had...to me three is reasonable 4 ok thats not too bad but more than that will make me wonder. and here we are also talking about a middle class family...but look at what neetu has done
Edited by prfan5 - 15 years ago
ReadLo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
I think it's just a turn of history nothing bad I do not want to see RS Manjuji become like it is supposed to be that shoulder Simi and who understands better than anyone then if it changes to be his protector cons Manjuji?
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Bana

My thoughts exactly. Even a conservative person like RS would understand that given Abhi's age and high society background, it is normal for him to have had girlfriends - it's not like he was going around impregnating women a la Rajiv Bhalla!

Besides, that's in the past and as long as he loves only Simi now how should that matter. Even Anita was Anuj's girlfriend before they decided to marry, does that make Anuj a cad?
I truly hope the CVs won't destroy RS's character the way they done with others - he is shown as a level headed perceptive man who can tell genuine from shallow. How can he be taken in by Anita? Usually one reacts in the other extreme - when you have been wronged by someone you are unlikely to believe anything she says.
Besides as a self-confessed atheist (he doesn't have faith in Mata Rani), RS is already sort of non-conservative himself. I can appreciate if his disapproval stems from the consederable gap in age and background, and of course the feud between the families.
Lastly, I will never understand our typical Indian mentality of confusing a conservative v/s modern outlook with one's character/morality. There is no real corelation between having girlfriends, wearing modern clothes or going to the disc and being a bad person. Some of the worst bahus in real life are sari-clad sindoor-sporting homely types. And some of the most crooked businessmen are pious Tirupati-visiting family types!
Would be interesting to read members' views on the last mentioned.

Well said, but in the minds of some people, a 22 year old guy with a girlfriend or even having kissed a girl is considered as a guy with lose morals and few values. I would think a guy who is 22, from an upper class family and without a girlfriend would be a guy who is a dweeb, loser or so unattractive he cannot find a girlfriend who would want to be with him. Despite his awful dress sense, Abhi is a guy who would be able to get a number of girlfriends. If people want to view Abhi is a virgin, that's fine, go ahead. However, to think Abhi as a character without ever having a girlfriend or having never kissed a girl is rather outrageous to me. Still, knowing the creative team, Abhi will be an unkissed virgin because this is what pleases the masses.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: prfan5

having gfs doesn't make the person incapable at all...but the way anita has presented it is the worst way possible. there is nothing wrong with having a few gfs in the past but he is 21 now so how many has he had...to me three is reasonable 4 ok thats not too bad but more than that will make me wonder. and here we are also talking about a middle class family...but look at what neetu has done

The problem is RS buys Anita's story without any questions. He should know better that she despises her own brother. But everyone's a sucker at 12/24 Karol Bagh.
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Laila2009

I can't believe that we would think a guy would be incapable of having a good heart or willing to do what is right if they happen to have had several girlfriends? 😕 I'm interested to see these girlfriends.

It's a pity though that he we didn't see them earlier; the show would have been more interesting as it would have made Simi (and the writers) work harder in explaining why he fell for her.
I have one word for the Sunshine team
L-A-Z-Y when it came to making the Abhi-Simi love story up.
By the way, the Anu is really cute. She's good competition for Simi. In front her, Simi does look old and frumpy.



yes, so what if Abhi had girlfriends? See the sentence - its in past-tense and not in present-tense. One should worry if he has girlfriends and not had girlfriends.

..and such a lame twist?ding ding ding ding .. creatives you lose all points!! You couldn't think of anything better than this?

I didn't like Anu, but I felt she had some similar facial features (sharp eye and nose) like Neil's and would suit him better!! 😆😆😆


Avatarana09 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Laila points out that Creatives want to maintain Abhi as a gentleman. Yeah they want that. I remember Anita asking Abhi" You broke up with Kangana. Did you give break up party?" What about Akansha? for which he replies she is just a friend.
But when he gives flowers to Simi at the temple during AA wedding, he says he never ever felt conscious in front of any other girl till now. I have never brought flowers for any other girl before and he corrects himself saying he has never given flowers to any other girl before.
But I feel having girlfriends/boyfiends is part of growing up. It may not be that every other friend is being given a marriage proposal and then being ditched.
Any ways, hope Simi has some sense regarding this.
By the way if for family sake, she can accept RB in spite of his loose morals, she should not have problem with so called (ex?)girl friend of Abhi if ever there is some truth to it.
Rumii thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
WELL,LOTS OF {EVEN 3-4} GIRLFRIENDS MIGHT NOT BE A 'HARM' AS TO THE FACT WHETHER ABHI'S A 'VIRGIN' OR NOT BUT..... BUT........THE FACT THAT IS THAT HE MIGHT NOT BE THAT STABLE IN 'RELATIONSHIPS' FROM 'HIS' SIDE,HENCE HE'S GOT THE 'HISTORY' OF LEAVING ONE,THEN ANOTHER,THEN ANOTHER,FIGHT WITH A 4TH ONE..N GOD KNOWS HOW MANYYYYYY🤔 SO..... WHAT'S THE GUARANTEE THAT HE'LL LIVE WITH N LOVE SIMMI FOREVER??????????????????????????????????
pop77 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
What Abhi had a many Girlfriens? What does any different? I don't wht creative try to saw us..
Creative read our post that Why Abhi love simi..Maybe that Creative give us answer?

I don;t think so RS gonna buy Anita story..He personally feel that Abhi is Different..He really like him..He wish that Kash Abhi is son..

Let see what store for us...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".