I am undecided yet on where I fall.

DiyaKash thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

I am not sold yet!


Today's episode left me wanting - wanting more clarity on what really happened that day (my hope of dolly's son is dashed with this 😭), wanting to understand how SK does not remember any of this, wanting a more stronger reason than 'I cannot lose her' for walking down the path of deceit and lies, wanting more in terms of KV's acting...

I realize that there is more to unfold in the days to come. But, coming off of a great episode the day before, yesterday's left me a bit numb and lost as to what I feel.

Not to criticize KV's acting. I think they were going for shell shocked. And he did that well! He had the lost, the deer caught in headlights look and I thought he nailed it.

But, a decision as momentous as this needs more flavours of poignant emotions from him - I want to see him breakdown, I want him completely undone and unraveled, I want him emotionally so cornered that he cannot see a path out of it but this, I want to see remorse and guilt from him for going down this path, not just for what happened, I want to see his characteristic rage towards Naani and Karuna ma for putting him in this spot, I want to see him utterly crushed with helplessness and desolation, I want to see more depth to his love for her than - you are mine and only mine and I cannot lose you, I want to see his struggle to make peace with this reality, I want to see him make amends to her in ways unheard of,...and the list goes on and on...

I can buy this storyline, I just want them to sell this right...

Edited by DiyaKash - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.3k

Users

6

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

Thabassum19 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Well said diya...agree with u...got to see his helplessness since yesterday ...wen he was getting married to her ...
He was marrying the love of his life ...the only thing he wanted to do was marry her , to win her he lost almost everything...but yet he cudnt enjoy it ,becoz of his harsh childhood deed ...
Which he dint even knew ...
To me Shaurya is the first victim...second is mehak..
Leandra thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
In two week we will know that what happened or what will happen

No idea how Cv going to turn this track, if mehak forgive him also how he can forgive himself
DiyaKash thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Leandra

In two week we will know that what happened or what will happen

No idea how Cv going to turn this track, if mehak forgive him also how he can forgive himself


Yes, hope so. They also have the tendency to leave things unexplained and forget about them - Rajiv for eg, we have no idea whether Showya knows that he was with maama and maami.

In the next few episodes we might get so embroiled in his struggles and Mehak finding out that they might conveniently forget to tell us what really happened on that dreadful night.
ms.nitya12 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Agree, this track has so much potential,
Instead of feeling complete with the happiness, Shaurya was left feeling incomplete, time warped & stretched, turning everything around him fluid and meaningless, his whole world shrank at an accelerating rate,as if there is one man in the centre of eternity, one blast from the past & his dreams of a happy future turned into a living nightmare, all because of the past that eventually caught up with him !!
Shaurya will be feeling like a helpless prey stalked around with no place to run or hide,it's the war within, with his conscience on one hand and his life,his love on the other ..the question is will he be able to build a future of love and happiness on the foundation of death and deceit 😕
Love is asking him to pay the biggest price & leave it to Mehak whether she will buy or not,it's not for him to bargain anymore
Leandra thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: DiyaKash



Yes, hope so. They also have the tendency to leave things unexplained and forget about them - Rajiv for eg, we have no idea whether Showya knows that he was with maama and maami.

In the next few episodes we might get so embroiled in his struggles and Mehak finding out that they might conveniently forget to tell us what really happened on that dreadful night.

it's a next big thing it cannot be hide or forget and move on but and it's not like a RB something much more very sensitive,

If she forgive him, will he able to for forgive himself?
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Hi Diya. 😊
Yes lets see what they show us today and henceforth, because even if they do a little of the lot that can be done with this story and these personalities at this point, they would have a good show on their hands. I like all of the options and possibilities you have outlined, but I'm not sure to what extent they will do justice to these possibilities, if at all.

I wasn't impressed by yesterday's episode. I got the shell shocked thing, but still felt disconnected because the very first scene was a continuation at the pool side of the previous night's scene and it all seemed a bit off to me. Karan was off and Karuna's character has been turned into not just a selfish person but an unthinking one. I don't particularly mind it, because I think that sometimes the people we think of as sweet and loving can do things that damage us even if they don't have the inattention to do so. My only problem is that her acting, while normally so good and dignified, seems a bit off here.

Perhaps today will be more interesting. After all, they're all back home and perhaps will have the mind-space to focus more on their scenes.


DiyaKash thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Vedika211

Hi Diya. 😊

Yes lets see what they show us today and henceforth, because even if they do a little of the lot that can be done with this story and these personalities at this point, they would have a good show on their hands. I like all of the options and possibilities you have outlined, but I'm not sure to what extent they will do justice to these possibilities, if at all.

I wasn't impressed by yesterday's episode. I got the shell shocked thing, but still felt disconnected because the very first scene was a continuation at the pool side of the previous night's scene and it all seemed a bit off to me. Karan was off and Karuna's character has been turned into not just a selfish person but an unthinking one. I don't particularly mind it, because I think that sometimes the people we think of as sweet and loving can do things that damage us even if they don't have the inattention to do so. My only problem is that her acting, while normally so good and dignified, seems a bit off here.

Perhaps today will be more interesting. After all, they're all back home and perhaps will have the mind-space to focus more on their scenes.



Forget coming to the middle ground like you were saying Ved, I am oscillating between high and low here...😊..

Yes, I am with you. Yesterday's episode had a lot of shortcomings for me too. Karuna's desperation to save her son, his life and his chance at happiness could have been shown better. I am thinking that was mainly because the focus was on what was happening inside the mantap and Mehek and they didn't linger much on Showrya and his mother. They probably should have.


I am sure over the next few episodes we will see more of this angst and distress and the whole lot. But, I would still like one episode where they show his complete breakdown in a way that has all of us connect back to him, feel his heartache, empathize and understand everything he will have to do henceforth.




dsr11 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Diya,
I won't complain about acting because they are doing their best given the half ass writing and hectic schedules. My problem with the current track is that they are drawing similarities between Mahek and Shaurya. Mahek was made to feel responsible for her parents' death for years by dadaji because she asked for a toy and they met with the accident when they went to get it (I think). Now they are trying to equate Mahek and Shaurya's situation, which in my opinion is wrong. Mahek wouldn't have dreamt that her parents would meet with an accident when they go out to fulfill her simple wish, because there is no logical reason connecting their death to her demand. But in Shaurya's case its different. He is a 14 year old who is capable of understanding the actions and their repercussions. He should know by that age that speeding can cause accidents. It is his mistake that they died. Why would a boy like Shaurya want to please someone or anyone is beyond me, but that's another thing! We can only talk about what they showed until now and what they are implying. So going by that, Mahek is not at all at fault for her parents' death and was wrongfully accused by her dadaji, but Shaurya is at fault for the death of her parents, though he was provoked by an adult. He is still guilty. I am just kinda weaning myself off from the show, because this kind of logic is not something I can stomach.
DiyaKash thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: dsr11

Diya,

I won't complain about acting because they are doing their best given the half ass writing and hectic schedules. My problem with the current track is that they are drawing similarities between Mahek and Shaurya. Mahek was made to feel responsible for her parents' death for years by dadaji because she asked for a toy and they met with the accident when they went to get it (I think). Now they are trying to equate Mahek and Shaurya's situation, which in my opinion is wrong. Mahek wouldn't have dreamt that her parents would meet with an accident when they go out to fulfill her simple wish, because there is no logical reason connecting their death to her demand. But in Shaurya's case its different. He is a 14 year old who is capable of understanding the actions and their repercussions. He should know by that age that speeding can cause accidents. It is his mistake that they died. Why would a boy like Shaurya want to please someone or anyone is beyond me, but that's another thing! We can only talk about what they showed until now and what they are implying. So going by that, Mahek is not at all at fault for her parents' death and was wrongfully accused by her dadaji, but Shaurya is at fault for the death of her parents, though he was provoked by an adult. He is still guilty. I am just kinda weaning myself off from the show, because this kind of logic is not something I can stomach.


Hi Rekha, I have mixed feelings abt this track. On one hand I see great potential in the story and the Acting that this could bring out from our leads and on the other hand i can't get my head around the love story they are trying to narrate. I guess my feeling will unfold too along with the story in the next few weeks... 😊


I agree with you that blaming Mehak for this accident is small mindedness and outright mean. But, I will have to disagree with you on the 14 year old being mature enough to understand his actions. An adolescent brain is a work in progress still. Their cognitive skills aren't well developed and neither is the part of the brain responsible for reasoning, second guessing etc. Plus there are also a myriad of environmental factors that shape this development. A 14 year old is still a child needing the guidance and nurture of an adult. So, for me, yes the 14 year old Showrya is responsible for their death, but I can't lay the guilt at his feet for this...


Edited by DiyaKash - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".