Humsafar Discussion thread-2 - Page 114

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

178.7k

Users

38

Likes

2.8k

Frequent Posters

664269 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
ohh neerja, baby i love u for this post.. some thoughts echoed what i feel for Asher, that there are not many men who will not defend about them being a victim and take the entire blame.
Asher, is one of those kind, who did not tell khirad that his mother was evil, not a single accusation on his mother when he confronted khirad, but took the entire blame, he blamed his love, his trust, and that made him gain a lot of respect.
this episode has really put so much light into Asher and his thought process, the person really does not hold anybody responsible, just how he did not hold anybody responsible 5 years ago. The betrayal of his mother tore him apart, but the fact that he wronged his wife had torn him more than that.
natz thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: pinkeye

kis ka sad ending ? 😲


Sorry wrong thread... this is about Sadqay Tumharey 😳
pinkeye thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: natz


Sorry wrong thread... this is about Sadqay Tumharey 😳

oh okay. I thought what happened. 😆
hope its not sad ending fr the that show too. 😊
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Humsafar is the show which grows on you when you are repeating and credit goes to whole team . Director who has used the mirrors beautifully in the whole show . And should be giving the credit where it belongs. All the actors were good and Actor who played Farida was in her character , she did great job with her role . Fawad Khan from the starting and till the end did great job . Asher is the person one can hate but with his putting life in the character , you can forgive him and i really felt bad for him after that plotting fiasco . When he was shown on the beach and was shattered person , wiping his tears . Mahira was not in the form in the starting but she came up when she got separated and after that no looking back . Her persona with pride , her silence and her eyes as if accusing Asher which used to make Asher confuse and uncomfortable .
This Last Episode FK was just too in to his character when returns with Khirad . His silence where he knowing the truth now , still do not want the confrontation with his mother . He could have very well distanced himself from his mother . But Farida,s desperation and her accusations made Asher to take her to task .
Not once he was loud , very quietly and in stern voice he talked to his mother and his dialogues were very powerful .
Then Khirad standing alone and Asher comes to her . Khirad was never out of his love . She might have hated him but knowing the truth that he was also living in the hell created by his mother lonely . That time dialogues were beautiful .
People calling Asher weakling , i never found him weakling . Ye he was soft hearted person . The way he cares for his mother ,knowing she ruined the life , even though has the patience and caring for her like a child .
how can one not fall in love with Asher and Mahira, Both had suffered in the journey of life .
Felt bad for Zareena . i do not understand when Zareena saw Sara ,s behavior on the night of her suicide ,why did she not been bothered about her behavior . It was quite apparent that she was not stable and her eyes were telling her mental state . She could have taken her to hospital

Humsafar has made its place in the Indian viewers heart .

-Sadiaa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
Humsafar comes to an end !! I m feeling the same like I felt four yes ago ! Satisfied 😃

I loved being here , Love the dissection , Love the Long Long discussions tht made me understand HS more , Different perspective frm Beautiful,Intellectual ppl here !!
Thnk You guys as I loved being here (I missed the discussion on HS whn it ws airing as I didnt know abt Pak Forum) Bt thnks to Zindagi I lived the Humsafar mania All over again !!

Thank You all of you & Sorry If sometime I hurt you (Unintentionally) 🤗
sillage. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Neerjaa

Writing someone,s comments which kind echoes my thou=ghts but she has described the whole sequence quite very well .

( I loved that part when Khirad told Ashar on the stairs that she was going back with him because Hareem wasn't eating. The way he looked at her, as though it was reinforced to him again, that his wife hadn't changed one bit from what he knew her. She still believed whatever was she was told.
"Mummy jab mein paida hua, kya mere baap ne aap se gavahi maangi ki mein unka beta hoon ya nahi" "kya har ma ko apna shohar ko yeh saabit karna padti hain ki uska bachcha ka baap wohi hain" These had to be the lines what got all the kudos from me for woman empowerment. More so because it was from a man! Brilliant, is an understatement!
My heart stopped beating during this entire bit! Watching Khirad looking at Ashar, not quite sure what he was trying to say, and how he slowly unraveled to her, while telling his mother off, that he finally knew the truth. And got to know only today! I put Ashar back on a pedestal for the way he stood up for Khirad. He addressed every issue of the humiliation that Khirad was subject to. From his loyalties to his mother, framing and maligning Khirad and her character, to even thinking about terminating Khirad's pregnancy, Ashar didn't mince words, and didn't leave any part of his mother's evil plan unaddressed.
The next most heart wrenching part was Ashar ad Khirad finally having their time together. From the pedestal, Ashar went up another few notches in my eyes. For the way he took onus of the entire blame on himself. He finally understood the hatred he saw in her eyes in the last few weeks. But he never defended himself. Not once did he even try and mention that he too was victim. He took sole responsibility of deserting her and leaving her in a lurch. Forget men, there are not too many people in the world who will do that and take the entire blame. "mein toh mohabbat ke laayak hi nahin hoon" "hamari zindagiyon mein, jitni judaaiyan or dukh aayen hain, un sab ka aazaab dilanewala mein hoon" (taking onus of the bad time he gave Khirad before leaving for Islamabad many years ago) . I simply loved the way he asked Khirad "Mujhe ek baar phir kabool kar lo." Khirad's minimalistic nod in denial, was so so "Khirad" again.

Khirad, keeping in line with her character of being one with few words, communicated the anguish and pain at being abandoned so effectively "... beech raaste, tanha chhod ke chale gaye mujhe?" Ashar's "I'm sorry" was a classic case of "2 small words, but overloaded with meaning"

For those who couldn't believe that Khirad went back to Ashar, after all that he did to her, I want to share something I loved from Dur-e-Shehwar, in this context, which holds so true in many cases. It was from a part in the last episode there, when Shandana asks Shehwar about being able to love a man like Mansoor. Shehwar tells her that that a husband-wife relationship is ajeeb; that when one sees your husband with unconditional love for the child, something changes in the heart. No matter what he has done, with that kind of love for the child, it's not possible to hate that man.
The bottom line was they loved each other. Circumstances and situations made matters worse, but "mohabbat mari nahin, kho zaroor gayi thi" Given the way Ashar loved Hareem, and they way he regretted what happened with Khirad, it made sense to me, that she was willing to give reconciliation a chance.
The last rain scene was perfect. I always have a big smile on my face when Ashar runs away from the rain.
Fawad! What does one say to you? You thought you were going to be the weakest link in this drama, but this wouldn't have been what it became with anyone else in it! You were terrific and only you made Ashar the only man I was willing to forgive inspite of being a total ass.
And Mahira, take that bow again. And again. And again. Momina Duraid knew what she was saying when she kept telling you that only you could be Khirad.
Episode#23 was most the fulfilling ending and didn't leave anything more to be desired in the heart, but sighs and smiles and the desire to watch it all over again.
Humsafar will always be the the most heart warming romance for me. Ashar and Khirad have spoilt me for anything else. )


Very beautifully put Neerja!
You described Asher and Khirad very well.
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

ohh neerja, baby i love u for this post.. some thoughts echoed what i feel for Asher, that there are not many men who will not defend about them being a victim and take the entire blame.

Asher, is one of those kind, who did not tell khirad that his mother was evil, not a single accusation on his mother when he confronted khirad, but took the entire blame, he blamed his love, his trust, and that made him gain a lot of respect.
this episode has really put so much light into Asher and his thought process, the person really does not hold anybody responsible, just how he did not hold anybody responsible 5 years ago. The betrayal of his mother tore him apart, but the fact that he wronged his wife had torn him more than that.


The above post i posted , are not mine comments but read them written by someone else . while reading them i just felt same way i felt for the whole episode .
Asher taking care of his mother like a child who has destroyed so many lives , is the real Asher and you can not hate him . It shows his character .
pinkeye thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Mahira Khan @TheMahiraKhan

#humsafar tha, #humsafar hai.. Aur hamesha rahey ga. Bahot saara pyar, meray doston ke liye, sarhad ke uss paar. Thank you for all the lovex

Mahira's tweet for indian humsafar fans.
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: MamuKiBhanji

I jst love 2nd last Khisher scene...❤️ ❤️ !!
Khirad softness When she said "Mohabbat ki thi toh nibhani bhi thi na..!! Kesi mohabbat ki ap ne k beach raste main tnha chor gye mujhe..."

"Main thak gyi hoon Asher , Tanha jii kr , Zindagi se tnha lad kr " 😭 ❤️

& thn the Rain tht Clean all the pain & Freshen up the situation...
The way they smile ☺️ ☺️ Asher closong door & Going Behind Khirad 😳 ..!!



Beautifully you defined the rain and i loved the dialogues which Khirad says to Asher . both were lonely souls and At last found solace in each other .
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Neerjaa


The above post i posted , are not mine comments but read them written by someone else . while reading them i just felt same way i felt for the whole episode .
Asher taking care of his mother like a child who has destroyed so many lives , is the real Asher and you can not hate him . It shows his character .


exactly neerja, this is the real Asher, who always would think beyond his own miseries, and he did the same thing again.. you just cannot hate him.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".