Originally posted by: kavya1994
If she was pretending since the beginning so for what she is waiting, this long........ waiting for the moment for Balli to put that lovey-dovey act of her in 4th gear, then she will tell her doubts about him to anyone?
If she was so sure that he is not Karan since the beginning then why she didn't try to collect proofs against him before Holi, why she was waiting for Holi only? If she was pretending since start, then before holi also, she got so many chances to collect such proofs, before informing it to Batra Sir but she had only one proof to prove her point before him that is blood report. She could have recorded his weird behaviour on date night, could have shown saving that CCTV recording of Balli losing grip on rope during training and that of dispensary scene, she had chance to caught him on Holika night but she wasn't shown doing anything like that.
Even if I consider that she had strong doubts and almost sure that he isn't Karan since the beginning, then not showing her doing anything in between all days, which she get to prove her point only shows that she brushed that thoughts thinking it to his nervousness because of proposal only.
If at ends makers wanted to show Monami narrating a story that she was pretending since beginning then atleast they should have shown her doing something to prove that in flashbacks, so that her story looks convincing.