Judges partial towards their favorites!

-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I've been noticing this for quite a while now, and interestingly enough, it happens a lot more with the boys than with the girls as such...

Karan, Aamir, and Akshat. The first three names that come to my mind.

Karan - Shilpa, even Arshad in some instances, are very partial towards him. Is it solely because of the name? Heck, even the cameraman has shown Karan more than ANY another contestant on that show. It's not like I am complaining, as you can see, am a huge KK fan, but if I have to look at it without any bias, it's obvious the channel is very keen to keep him the primo star of the show. All I am wondering, is why?

Akshat - The bit when Shilpa said she cannot believe Akshat would ever give a mediocre performance pissed me off. Again, I love watching Akshat dance too, I think he's superb next after Siddhesh, but that does not necessarily mean the guy will NEVER give a mediocre performance. Anything may happen anytime. Mistakes do happen after all. What was that all about? Shilpa really likes him over the others, perhaps at par with Karan, it's so obvious!

Aamir - What's with Vaibhavi and her "I love you Darling" to Aamir? I mean come ON! I've loved Vaibhavi as a judge since quite a while now, and I think that's really inappropriate coming from her as a judge. Again, don't get me wrong, I love Aamir as well, and as I said in another post, I think he was mind blowing in his last duet. But I really can't figure out why Vaibhavi keeps him on a pedestal.



You're welcomed to add more to the list. Seriously, as much as I am a fan of everyone mentioned over here, barring Shilpa though, I just wanted to point this out. Check me, it's not like am complaining having too much of Karan, on the contrary, I love it, but yes, I do feel if they're a team, it's very very very unfair to other contestants, especially some like Kapil who's face we get to see once in an episode if he's not performing. They're all stars in their own way there, the least the channel could do is give them all, if not equal, shared screen space!

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

5.7k

Users

17

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

-Mink- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
I agree Judges are Partial 2wards dere fav
among da gals
Arshad is partial 2wards Mukti and Vaibhavi is Partial 2wards Sanjeeda
Vaibhavi was da Judge wen aamir and sanjee partcipated in NB3 may be dats why she has a softcorner for them ..
Okay Even Da cameraman is Partial 😆He or she or wahever nvr focuses on siddhesh cmon he is da best dancer among the boyz team he shud not be Ignored like dat
-stuti- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
The logic I find behind the focus of camera, is the camera focusses on those who are seen enjoying themselves. They'll obviously not show any serious faces in between. It even depends upon which star is more popular. I m not against any contestant but as Arshad also pointed out, Kapil always has a very serious and a straight face while Karan is always smiling and seen enjoying the performances. So they'd prefer focussing more on him.
Abt the judges being bias...if it abt giving more points then maybe yes..but I m always satisfied with Vaibhavi and often Arshad's marking too. So I dont hv much problem with anything. 😊
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: DisneyDudette

I agree Judges are Partial 2wards dere fav
among da gals
Arshad is partial 2wards Mukti and Vaibhavi is Partial 2wards Sanjeeda
Vaibhavi was da Judge wen aamir and sanjee partcipated in NB3 may be dats why she has a softcorner for them ..
Okay Even Da cameraman is Partial 😆He or she or wahever nvr focuses on siddhesh cmon he is da best dancer among the boyz team he shud not be Ignored like dat



Lol... Yeah, since his snide comments to the judges, actually I would say intelligent comments, even he's been sidelined by the cameraman. 😆

Arshad loves Mukti, I noticed that too. Just didn't know how many over here did and that why I didn't mention it. Thought the other three were the best examples.

I agree Vaibhavi might have a soft corner for them, but that's not a reason for me. To a judge, every contestant must be judged equally!
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: -stuti-

The logic I find behind the focus of camera, is the camera focusses on those who are seen enjoying themselves. They'll obviously not show any serious faces in between. It even depends upon which star is more popular. I m not against any contestant but as Arshad also pointed out, Kapil always has a very serious and a straight face while Karan is always smiling and seen enjoying the performances. So they'd prefer focussing more on him.
Abt the judges being bias...if it abt giving more points then maybe yes..but I m always satisfied with Vaibhavi and often Arshad's marking too. So I dont hv much problem with anything. 😊



I don't have any problem with Vaibhavi or Arshad's marking either. It's their comments that I am talking about. And I was actually talking about screen space alongside the cameraman, which includes the hosts talking to him, like they almost often do with Karan. They even showed Karan-Kritika's segment the other day, before the show started.

See I am a Karanika fan too, so I am joyous about them being shown so much, but what about thousand other fans who watch the show for their celebrity stars or favorites? Isn't it unfair to be including their stars in the show and then tossing them aside except for 1-2 performances. It's not a question of only showing a face on camera...

Oh yeah, definitely though. That's one of the reason I've always loved Karan for sure. He enjoys what he does, or doesn't do it at all. He believes in what he says, always... He's always laughing around, smiling, joking or moving... Even in the Sasural Genda Phool, I remember seeing a bit where he was singing and dancing, surely because he loved that song. That's wonderful to see, of course! 😳
kmh2rockzz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
yup i agree judges r partial dey give good marks 2wards their favorites which is not good 4 other participants as dey r also putting more efforts
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sofsunmannee

yup i agree judges r partial dey give good marks 2wards their favorites which is not good 4 other participants as dey r also putting more efforts



I think the marks are very well given as a matter of fact. I want to clarify that I was NOT talking in terms of marks, but most importantly in terms of comments or gestures.
kawal_tak thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
i think arshad has a soft corner for mukti :)
-stuti- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -Sneha



I don't have any problem with Vaibhavi or Arshad's marking either. It's their comments that I am talking about. And I was actually talking about screen space alongside the cameraman, which includes the hosts talking to him, like they almost often do with Karan. They even showed Karan-Kritika's segment the other day, before the show started.

See I am a Karanika fan too, so I am joyous about them being shown so much, but what about thousand other fans who watch the show for their celebrity stars or favorites? Isn't it unfair to be including their stars in the show and then tossing them aside except for 1-2 performances. It's not a question of only showing a face on camera...

Oh yeah, definitely though. That's one of the reason I've always loved Karan for sure. He enjoys what he does, or doesn't do it at all. He believes in what he says, always... He's always laughing around, smiling, joking or moving... Even in the Sasural Genda Phool, I remember seeing a bit where he was singing and dancing, surely because he loved that song. That's wonderful to see, of course! 😳


Actually I Lovee Karan Kritika so wud want more and more abt them. But then they dont perform as much as the other contestants. So I want to see them dance more often in the coming episodes.
priyankumupal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
I agree with the topic starter....it's unfair by other contestants because they hardly show Angad and Kapil on the show....its like those two are invisible....I'm sure Karan is shown because he is very popular and is always enjoying himself. but what about the other fans...who want to see their favs on the show. I think Karan won the judges hearts with his lovable persona...because remember, the first week the judges were harsh with him....still its not a personality contest, so the judgement should be based on dance. As for Aamir, i think he doesn't get too much attention. just the right amount....and its better not to talk about Shilpa's judgement. because she is so partial towards who ever takes her fancy.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".