Was it an ufair desicion?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

attiya

@bushraw

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#21

The judgemnt was wrong to start the show with come on if u were to take a pole i bet u bakti would over karishma anyday he was way better and deserved to win. Im a girl and i thought that was sooooo unfair and i bet its all that stupid Malika's falt.

Quote

anusha_sony

@anusha_sony

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: pyaridilwalino1
dancing wise both the boys and girls have presented VARIETY! Western is not a variety of dance....boys have done break dance, popping and locking, and many different CONCEPTS! While girls have explored many forms of Indian cultural dances. They have also given their shot at different concepts. Bollywood is not a dance, but a concept... instead all songs were used from Bollywood movies! So the debate on variety doesn't seem to stand a chance, in my view. The tashan round should have been in the favor of the boys for sure...but everything else was FAIR! Gaurav Chopra said--"Jo badal garajte hai.woh baraste nahin!" and that's what the guys proved today. ALL that complaining and sulking when they didn't win a round brought them out to be referred to as SORE LOSERS! If they had a problem with decisions before voice them and make a point. Boys had a problem with Chaitu given a remark before he even performed...they never questioned the judges decision directly. In the beginning Bakhtiyaar is NOTED--and continuously noted to be a brilliant dancer...that doesn't mean just because he is a "brilliant dancer" he needs to win all the time. Boys need to grow up and learn to face a challenge. Decision was completely FAIR and if something was unfair was the treatment that the boys as a WHOLE gave to the whole cast and crew of Zara Nach Ke Dikha! Shweta

Agree with uuuuu

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Aditi

@adoremevirgo

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#23

Hi friends....i hv always been a silent member but today i just cudnt resist myself from voicing my opinion. this is entirely my personal opinion and i dont mean to offend anyone.

i hv followed the show from the very first episode and have not missed a single episode.

i always felt boys were fab in terms of concept and in most cases dances too. bakhtiyar is no doubt the best among boys and even overall he is one of the best along with mouni and ishita.

in the mega final....both girls and boys proved to be innovative. both the teams brought a uniqueness to the show...and the final episode was seeming to be a perfect ending to a wonderful dance show like zara nachke dikha.

i am not a very gud judge of dancing....but even then some things were clear to me. in the shadow dance the girls were without any doubt better than boys.

in the face off round i felt bakhtiyar was really really gud and it was one of his best performance but somehow i felt ishita had an edge over him and i felt that she wud win. only in the tashan round i was not sure whether karishma deservered to win or not although she was not bad at all.

the main problem was with the boys. they were not playing according to any strategy. they were overconfident and smug. they as saroj khan said was onlly depending upon bakhtiyar. he is best no doubt but that day girls were better than him.

who told the boys to bet 300 points in every other round. obviously wen they lost 300 in the very first round it was quite a blow for them which is very natural but they themselves r to blame for it.

in simple words i can say that it was not bakhtiyar's day, and it was wrong decision by the team to depend on just one person.

and what they did in the final round was totally wrong. in a competition one has to lose and every team shud learn to accept defeat gracefully. every competitor believes that he has given his best but maybe the opponent team was better and one shud learn to accept that.

the boys did not hv the right to spoil the effort of everyone including the girls, boys themselves and judges that was put in the last 3 months.

malaika, saroj khan and chunky noone has any personal enmity with boys, maybe in their eyes girls were better and they judged accordingly.

i think if boys played to strategy they had a chance of winning.

betting 300, 160, 250 points was just stupid thing to do. as if even before the performances the boys had alrealy decided that the girls wont be able to beat bakhtiyar. in a competition the very first thing every team shud keep in mind that they must NEVER underestimate the opponent team.

also i think at the very beginning boys made a major mistake. they won the toss and then gave the girls to dance first. as a result the judges were getting the impression the boys were repeating the dance steps which was very obvious in the shadow dance.

it had a psychological effect on the judges and so i felt the wise decision wud hv been the boys to dance first.

anyway, at the end of the day i must say that boys must learn to accept defeat and shud not decide in advance that girls can never win over them.

Quote

Nadia

@imroze123

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#24

THE DECISION WAS VERY MUCH UNFAIR ...BOYS GAVE THEIR 200 % but MALAIKA IS VERY STUPID AND UNFAIR. AND CHUNKEY REALLY NEEDS TO CHANGE HIS SEX...HE IS A DHABBA on MALE CLAN .

Quote

Kavya

@Bazinga

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: sonali.19281
just going by today bthe decision made in the face off and tashan round just didint make sense..oj even if i agree ashita stood a chance there is no way karishma was better...i think the tanshan atleast should have gon to the bouys..

In spite of being a hard core girls' supporter, honestly even I felt Bakhtiyaar should have won the Tashan round. Although it a very very close call Ashita truly deserved to win the Face Off round as she did such tough steps with amazing ease,energy and fantastic spirit , I knew Ashita was a good dancer but yesterday she took my heart away and she was better than Bakhtiyaar. I am not saying this because I am a girl's team supporter I am saying this from a neutral point of view!

Quote

Kanika

@Kanika05

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#26

Nope=). As per the 'Finale' yes the decision was FAIR!😳

In the Tashan round i think Bakhitiyar deserved to win but all the others im with the judges!

In Zara Hatke, girls performance had the main element 'Dance' while boys lacked the 'Dance' and only presented some roleplay sort off!😕

In Hum Tum, i think the result was fair.. in girls, Mouni was Awesomee , Jennifer was Okay and Rupali goofed up so like 1.5 points...And in boys, Gaurav was Great, Vikas managed very well & Amit was FINE...So 2 points...so clearly the decision was right!😳

Now Face off: Ashita was much better..her steps had variety & were much more difficult..Bhakitiyar's steps were repetative!..Choreographers fault..Well Bhaitiyar is known for 'Energy' but in this dance his energy was less than Ashita's as it was clearly visible he WAS EXHAUSTED! Who wudnt?..Not his fault!..he also goofed up at the end bcoz his jacket came on his face...!

Girls truly deserved to Win! I can bet that even if Ashita had lost Girls wudn't have said a word & wud have agreed with the judges!

I think what the boys did was the MOST Silliest thing i have seen ever! I mean if they trusted Bhakityar so much why didn't they make him the Captain instead of Ali who just follows what Bhaktiyar says..

Girls dont take risks & make those type of strategies which make sense!

My View..No Offence!

-Kanika😳

Quote

Shanti

@shanti05

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: sonali.19281
just going by today bthe decision made in the face off and tashan round just didint make sense..oj even if i agree ashita stood a chance there is no way karishma was better..my heart went out to bakhtiyar..besides malaika looked to be analysing his psyche more than his dance today😳..both decisions taken together just did it..i think the tanshan atleast should have gon to the bouys..but in ideal terms both the rou nds were better performed by the guy

I agree with you !! The result were totally one seided !! I think thats why the boys fet that they were waisting their time and walked off !!

Quote

armaanilicious

@armaanilicious

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

#28

tashan round bakhu deserved 300 points baaki all was fair...n them walkin out its pathetic jus cos ur loosin means u walk out! they hav major ego issues!

Quote

Kanika

@Kanika05

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: tasbib
i think it was unfair, i know sarojji never liked ali n bakhtiyar

helloo??...Saroj loved Bhakitiyar & trusted that he had the capibility!!

Ali?..im not sure but yeh Saroj has no problems with Bhakityar!

Quote

sumanforums

@sumanforums

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#30

Mallaika WAS partial at times. and my heart went out to Bhaktiyar yesterday. I would not mind them loosing the last round.....but Bhaktiyar loosing to Karishma and Ashita made me feel very bad.

And Saroj Khan only fuelled their wounds. She has always been bad. And again i feel the boys were not badtameez...they never spoke rudely to anyone......only did not dance the last round......how can you dance when you feel there is partiality going on the and the person who is judging you does not like you.

They also did not let Bhaktiyar speak at the end....that was very sweet of them. They never came across as rude.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 10

Was it an ufair desicion? - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics