Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 16, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread - Page 11

Originally posted by: Firefly_shines

He was imp.. I won’t generalise but will state my view, for me Ak was the problem, a chudail in human form.. Nav became a problem later when he started supporting her in all her crimes.. or else he was bearable in the beginning. Yes his stalking and empty photo frames were a bit icky but nobody out and out trolled that character when he entered.. they could’ve kept his character like RK and people would’ve thoroughly supported him. It’s when he started playing his victim card crying mera mera when people started trolling him… but he was an imp character. In fact due to off screen fiasco his character was given way more imp.. trust me last gen was no where like this one.. ropu and even sam will not raise their voice against Rajan no matter what kabada they do of their characters. HC refused for Abhirohi, ema and a lot of other things which made the makers go on a ego spree and ruined the storyline.. or else Geetmaan ke jaise Abhirohi hota.. They literally ruined Ak’s character, they way she jumped on Abhi within a month of Nav’s death same like Navri.

Also it has always been like this.. it’s not fl’s story. it’s how she marries ml, adjusts in that family, becomes Bahu to beti so obv ml and his family plays an imp role.. they cliffed off Naira but goenkas remained, similarly Abhi and Birlas were there till last day.. so we like it or not Armoron and his family will also be there till end

Even I’m not saying they should focus on one character.. they haven’t given any lead qualities/comforts to Ab.. agree or not!!

Actors sign the contract to portray their character no matter how it is written, they aren’t producing the show to reject it!! Even sam and ropu are doing coz of commitment, they said in their IV’s their perspective about the script..actors shouldn’t involve in the script, they should leave the show if that character doesn’t add any value to their career! Here Sam is a budding actress, if she opposes such big production house that would impact her career! Tell me which lead actors are successful after rishta??

The only reason I think rishta gen3 and gen4 ruined is upma.. they don’t want rishta to surpass upma trp’s! They are purposely ruining the show!!

Originally posted by: KyaBakwaashi

Even I’m not saying they should focus on one character.. they haven’t given any lead qualities/comforts to Ab.. agree or not!!

Actors sign the contract to portray their character no matter how it is written, they aren’t producing the show to reject it!! Even sam and ropu are doing coz of commitment, they said in their IV’s their perspective about the script..actors shouldn’t involve in the script, they should leave the show if that character doesn’t add any value to their career! Here Sam is a budding actress, if she opposes such big production house that would impact her career! Tell me which lead actors are successful after rishta??

The only reason I think rishta gen3 and gen4 ruined is upma.. they don’t want rishta to surpass upma trp’s! They are purposely ruining the show!!

HC & PR got to involve in script because they are cheated just like MohitP & Garvita are cheated in Gen4 but they are silent.... HC, PR raised Their voice against the script as they signed very different charecters & got different after 1st leap.... Even PR was very uncomfortable playing Ak sharma which she mentioned in many IV'S that time.... Even they roasted the script like almost in every IV..... I don't think they narrated any characteristics to leads as they copied Lost1, But here Garvita called quits when same track to repeated for 3rd time

Even pranali rejected playing 3rd wheel between AbhiRohi after 2nd leap.... She didn't wanted to renew contract after Ak's wahyad dialogues to Abhimanyu & jumping to him after Nav's Death.... She wanted the charecter like Aarohi, but Pranali couldn't get to play the independent single mother😒

Originally posted by: missFiesty_69

Personally I'm not a fan of Abhimanyu but damn Armaan sa has time and again proved himself what kind of a moron he is, and how even the worst of MLs, to the extent even JungleRaj might be better than this guy lol.

@b: I mean the amount of trolling that Armaan sa undergoes is also because actors will never raise their voice against Rajan no matter how bad he makes their character look. Normally actors work in rishta, then they become famous, only in HC's case, it was the opposite, so I'm glad he did raised his voice against RS's atrocities.

Originally posted by: sammmmmyyyyyy

HC & PR got to involve in script because they are cheated just like MohitP & Garvita are cheated in Gen4 but they are silent.... HC, PR raised Their voice against the script as they signed very different charecters & got different after 1st leap.... Even PR was very uncomfortable playing Ak sharma which she mentioned in many IV'S that time.... Even they roasted the script like almost in every IV..... I don't think they narrated any characteristics to leads as they copied Lost1, But here Garvita called quits when same track to repeated for 3rd time

Even pranali rejected playing 3rd wheel between AbhiRohi after 2nd leap.... She didn't wanted to renew contract after Ak's wahyad dialogues to Abhimanyu & jumping to him after Nav's Death.... She wanted the charecter like Aarohi, but Pranali couldn't get to play the independent single mother😒

Garvita is cheated? In what sense?? She got a whole character graph for Ru.. from being bad to good!! They didn’t keep her as audience rejected jeth-bhabhi rishta.. she quit coz she is doing another show with shahi’s daughter! Even sachin tyagi is in that show.. dunno when that show will air.. Even Naira’s character was spoiled by making her run away multiple times! Yet shivangi is retained as Sirat.. if they really wanted to keep the actors they would in some or the other way! Actors can’t decide the script as their role is only to act!!

In gen4 not only leads, other characters are also inconsistent.. this is an example of pathetic writing!!

Originally posted by: KyaBakwaashi

Even I’m not saying they should focus on one character.. they haven’t given any lead qualities/comforts to Ab.. agree or not!!

Actors sign the contract to portray their character no matter how it is written, they aren’t producing the show to reject it!! Even sam and ropu are doing coz of commitment, they said in their IV’s their perspective about the script..actors shouldn’t involve in the script, they should leave the show if that character doesn’t add any value to their career! Here Sam is a budding actress, if she opposes such big production house that would impact her career! Tell me which lead actors are successful after rishta??

The only reason I think rishta gen3 and gen4 ruined is upma.. they don’t want rishta to surpass upma trp’s! They are purposely ruining the show!!

When an actor signs contract, he’s given the character sketch and a basic idea on how the story will unfold. If tomorrow they show a complete 180 degree turn without any reason then actors have a right to question. But you’re right, HC has been in this industry os he has the power to influence script but if one is a budding actor, uts better to call it quits like Garv did post leap instead of running behind Ar for the third time. But being leads it becomes even more difficult to leave.

Wrt to success post rishta, Hina and Mohsin wanted to try movies and web series so didn’t do more shows except hina playing komolika.. shivi has done 3 shows and one web series, P did 2 shows

Originally posted by: Firefly_shines

And I’m more glad he didn’t extend his contact for 6 more months coz it would’ve badly butchered Abhimanyu. Him marrying Ak, becoming father to Nav’s child then Abhira’s daughter.. reading this itself makes me nauseous. Ak in true sense would’ve become a baby making machine.. it’s good they ended his character. He made mistakes had anger issues (though most of the time it was justified) but in true sense was one of the most beautifully written characters, esp post kid leap, his scenes with Rubhir have my heart.

Bold- he literally fought with shahi for those things.... That's the reason HC is defamed by Shahi anywhere.... Even PR denied contract renew.... So they kind of closed her charecter with kid with NAV🤭

Actually the EMA & AbhiRohi thing was kind of worst move by Maker's which both actors denied playing.... So they kept Ruhi as PL in Gen4, Actually it's supposed to be NAV vs Manyu daughter as PL & FL as usual Rubhir & shivu becomes like Ananya, naksh, yash or vansh, kairav, krishna types🤷🤷....

U- Actually HC & PR stood strong against it, both denied contract extension

So atlast both charecters comes as extremely selfish with Manyu abandon family & Ruhi.... Ak in sacrifice literally denied normal childhood to 3 lifes

Originally posted by: KyaBakwaashi

Garvita is cheated? In what sense?? She got a whole character graph for Ru.. from being bad to good!! They didn’t keep her as audience rejected jeth-bhabhi rishta.. she quit coz she is doing another show with shahi’s daughter! Even sachin tyagi is in that show.. dunno when that show will air.. Even Naira’s character was spoiled by making her run away multiple times! Yet shivangi is retained as Sirat.. if they really wanted to keep the actors they would in some or the other way! Actors can’t decide the script as their role is only to act!!

In gen4 not only leads, other characters are also inconsistent.. this is an example of pathetic writing!!

Bold- there goes your answer... Because TRP went down so she got good arc .... She was to return with Mohit in show along with kid Daksh, but she is disappointed with same repeat track executed in many different ways... So she called quits....

Originally posted by: Firefly_shines

And I’m more glad he didn’t extend his contact for 6 more months coz it would’ve badly butchered Abhimanyu. Him marrying Ak, becoming father to Nav’s child then Abhira’s daughter.. reading this itself makes me nauseous. Ak in true sense would’ve become a baby making machine.. it’s good they ended his character. He made mistakes had anger issues (though most of the time it was justified) but in true sense was one of the most beautifully written characters, esp post kid leap, his scenes with Rubhir have my heart.

Same sentiments here sis.

Post leap Abhi was a far cry better than the pre leap one, ( imo) and yes his bond with Ruhi as Poppy , and later with Abhir was lovely. It makes me sad to see that lovely kid Abhir, to the nonsense he's reduced to now.

Originally posted by: missFiesty_69

Same sentiments here sis.

Post leap Abhi was a far cry better than the pre leap one, ( imo) and yes his bond with Ruhi as Poppy , and later with Abhir was lovely. It makes me sad to see that lovely kid Abhir, to the nonsense he's reduced to now.

That's the problem even Mohit got same treatment as HC & PR.... Got different narration, different On-screen charecter..... He was totally butchered with his accident & charu jaap🤦, thoda bacha hua chance is ruined with impulsive marriage & EMA 🤢 🤮