| First Three Seasons Frustration Thread #2 | [DT Note: pg-65] - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

895

Views

33.5k

Users

55

Likes

2.4k

Frequent Posters

shahsb_26 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 1 years ago


And Goenkas smiley7 did worst with her! Like her welcome and end was so different... So glad it wasn't with Goenkas...

shahsb_26 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Summer_Rain

Naksh and the Singhania family had two chances to pursue legal action against the Goenkas, once for a specific issue and another related to Akshara Sr.'s death. Both times, they chose to overlook it because of Naira's love for Kartik. Despite this, the Goenkas, especially Mimi, persistently sought reasons to belittle them. Over time, Kartik's character deteriorated, but despite efforts to redeem him, fans of KaiRa overlooked those red flags due to ShiVin's chemistry and majority were least bothered about the storyline which is why Sirat was also talked about since Shivi played it or else situation would have been soo different. It seems the writers favored the Goenkas, pardoning their many wrongdoings, a bias that has remained unchanged to this day.


The reason why Gen 2 got toxic so quickly... 3rd case domestic violence cass could have been filed against Goenkas for mistreating Naira...


As Adhya says Kartik will always be original baccha chor... No matter what...


Only good thing about Kartik and Naira ma relationship was that it had proper base... Thanks to Hina Khan for continuing Akshara with grown up kids, they had dating phase and all. But RS will never acknowledge role of Hina in success of Kaira smiley36 having said that... They also had benefit of spending sometime as couple after marriage and solving issues like Kirti ki domestic violence case and all... (Albeit I hated how legacy kid Naksh was just a add on masala for Kaira)... Naksh never really got this independent storyline without KaiRa after their introduction... And during their teen Naksh was central...


Off track...

Similarly, Kairav was little more relatable as a character in gen 3. He had met, spend time with Naira and had her parvarish... But... He was not even given a storyline... Didn't like him in childhood after his sirat jaap but still... He was Naira ki parvarish and only child to know Naira...


Abhir... More relatable character... Dead...


On track..

But Goenkas were step down to Singhaniyas... And Singhaniyas and Maheshwaris always stood up for Naira... They were definitely best! Wayy more progressive than Goenkas, Birlas and Poddars!

shahsb_26 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Summer_Rain

galthi se kiya hoo ya hype ke liye. his account jo chahe wo kare . I stopped speculating about these matters... jitna sochoge utna dimaag karab hoga. smiley36


Dumb question but Aise reels mein likes kaise check karte hai smiley36? I am only able to like/unlike the reel...

Edited by shahsb_26 - 1 years ago
Summer_Rain thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: shahsb_26


The reason why Gen 2 got toxic so quickly... 3rd case domestic violence cass could have been filed against Goenkas for mistreating Naira...


As Adhya says Kartik will always be original baccha chor... No matter what...


Only good thing about Kartik and Naira ma relationship was that it had proper base... Thanks to Hina Khan for continuing Akshara with grown up kids, they had dating phase and all. But RS will never acknowledge role of Hina in success of Kaira smiley36 having said that... They also had benefit of spending sometime as couple after marriage and solving issues like Kirti ki domestic violence case and all... (Albeit I hated how legacy kid Naksh was just a add on masala for Kaira)... Naksh never really got this independent storyline without KaiRa after their introduction... And during their teen Naksh was central...


Off track...

Similarly, Kairav was little more relatable as a character in gen 3. He had met, spend time with Naira and had her parvarish... But... He was not even given a storyline... Didn't like him in childhood after his sirat jaap but still... He was Naira ki parvarish and only child to know Naira...


Abhir... More relatable character... Dead...


On track..

But Goenkas were step down to Singhaniyas... And Singhaniyas and Maheshwaris always stood up for Naira... They were definitely best! Wayy more progressive than Goenkas, Birlas and Poddars!

KaiRa had a solid initial foundation owing to their beginnings, taking almost around 7 months to establish that. The Nok-jhok, Him falling for her, the angst and the phase of proper dating were all because of Akshara, the foundational pillar of Gen1. Despite any delusions held by RS, the truth remains that KaiRa had a strong basis, and Hina deserves full credit for it. She could have chosen to leave, similar to Karan, but she stayed for a few more months giving them the opportunity to establish Kartik and Naira's individual characteristics too. Through Akshara, the audience also could relate to Naira's perspective. Witnessing Naira's growth during her formative years due to Naksh, who was given central stage, was an added bonus. Naksh and Tara had a compelling storyline that could have been further explored, but they opted to replace the actor, resulting in KeeSh also getting prominence in the show. Otherwise, I couldn't understand why they wanted to sideline Naksh and reduced him to a mere accessory, bound to Kirti, merely for Suhasini Goenka's dominance over the Singhania family. The Goenkas will always bear responsibility for all the mishaps in Rishta. No other family can measure up to the standard set by the Maheshwaris, not even the Singhania's; they'll always lag a step behind the Maheshwaris in embracing the Nayi Soch. Lets not talk about Poddar's adam ke zamane se hai ye log.


Kairav even after being Naira's parvarish failed her the moment he stepped into Goenka Villa . Akshu might have Naira's blood but she will remain Sirat's parvarish only thats why i personally couldn't connect with her initially. Knowing Goenka's i dont think they would have even let her meet Naksh and Singhania's who could have made her aware of the real Naira.


Abhir was such a special kid, That kid didnt deserve such a fate. smiley19.

Posted: 1 years ago

Karthik was Krish's uncle. Akshu was Abhir's MOTHER

A mother deciding for her son. Uncle deciding for her sister's child will never be the same

Karthik was baccha chor. Akshu was not

Honestly, Abhinav as ABhir's dad was one of the best decisions AKshu took.

Abhinav was such a great parent

Posted: 1 years ago

The way she chose Abhinav as the father was wrong in every way!!!

That can never be justified. Abhinav too was a chor as he hid the abhir's truth from Abhimanyu even after learning the truth!!! 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

Posted: 1 years ago

Leap 2 ke baad abhi ko singer bana diya aur Akshara ko bhaisa ka case pakda diya 🤭🤭

DKP really hated Akshara's character 🤣🤣🤣

https://twitter.com/Rimi9414/status/1744387909233656037?t=jMi_YMve1kBz7QQ6UOp5DQ&s=19

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: JustaFan13

The way she chose Abhinav as the father was wrong in every way!!!

That can never be justified. Abhinav too was a chor as he hid the abhir's truth from Abhimanyu even after learning the truth!!! 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️


Abhinav did not Steal anything. AKshara who was Abhir's mother gave him the right to be Abhir's father

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Agni_Jytsona


Abhinav did not Steal anything. AKshara who was Abhir's mother gave him the right to be Abhir's father

Before accepting to be the father, he very well knew that the real father doesn't know about abhir's existence. Still he accepted the offer. He is Akshara's partner in crime. So yes. He did steal the child!!

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: JustaFan13

Before accepting to be the father, he very well knew that the real father doesn't know about abhir's existence. Still he accepted the offer. He is Akshara's partner in crime. So yes. He did steal the child!!

He did not. Neither did Akshara

They were Abhir's "Real" Parents. They raised him

Just donating a part of your genes does not make someone a father

Abhimanyu was the Biological father. But Abhinav was Papa

Akshnav were ABhir's parents

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

5 months ago

The Last Song ~ A Abhiru Three-Shot [Completed]

Author's Note: Based on the Prompt by @Jasminerahul in Submit Writing Prompt Thread who requested for writing a story based on the music video:...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: olsen_124

6 months ago

AbhiMaan TS-The Family of Three CHAPTER 4 UPDATED PAGE 2

Chapter 1 It had been 5 years since Armaan had left Poddar Mansion Firm.He had moved into another world with his wife and his mother...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Agni_Jytsona

1 years ago

Abhira Sharma/Samridhii Shukla AT|| DT Note P. 23 Abhira Sharma/Samridhii Shukla AT|| DT Note P. 23

“Nothing can dim the light which shines from within.” ― Maya Angelou That is the best way to describe Abhira Sharma- The Gen 4 Fl Her strength...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Arziya

25 days ago

YRKKH SM updates, BTS and Spoilers Thread #126 YRKKH SM updates, BTS and Spoilers Thread #126

Hello everyone! Welcome to the YRKKH BTS and Spoilers Thread! Please share any clips about upcoming story arcs or Behind the Scenes clips that...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

19 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 2, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".