Why did Birla’s abandon her?

I don’t understand how come Birla’s just abandoned Roohi and dumped her with Goenka’s?

I know they hate Goenka’s and would be traumatised after Abhimanyu and Abhir’s death but still what is poor Roohi’s fault in all of this?

Even if Goenka’s severed ties with them (though it should have been the other way round) couldn’t Birla’s have fought custody for Roohi just like they did for Abhir (could’ve asked Poddars for help)

Wouldn’t Manjari be more possessive of Roohi as she is her Neil and Aarohi’s aakhri nishani and her only grandchild after Abhir?

Wouldn’t it make more sense for Manjari and Shefali to raise Roohi rather than her Old ‘Great Grandparents’ who could drop dead anytime? How on earth is it safe for a couple of oldies to care for a young child?

I would understand if Roohi was Akshara’s child or if Akshara was living in Birla House but that is not the case.

Disclaimer: I’m fully aware that this has been done to purposefully in order to vanish Birla’s to keep DKPs favourite Goenka’s and to begin the love triangle but still it doesn’t make sense from a logical perspective.

After Abhimanyu and Abhirs death Manjiri would not have been in that condition to take care of a child,my guess is she would have completely lost her mental balance and would eventually die and even if she lives she would be too traumatised to take care of Roohi and the other Birlas would not have cared so much for Roohi,the Birlas never had a very close bond they were staying together not for love but for name and status.I think Manjiri was the glue keeping the family together after her all have gone in different directions.

Manjiri would have lost her mental ability...

Parth would have been in jail...

Shefali would have started focusing on Shivu more...

Aur kaun bacha?

Arre that episode happened naa where Aarohi dumped Manjiri and told her ek din sab ek ek karke aapko chhodke jayenge.

That was to show that Aarohi has dumped Birlas forever. And post Abhi-Abhir’s death, Goenka and Birla ka katti ho Gaya. So Ruhi inke paas hi reh gayi.

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Arre that episode happened naa where Aarohi dumped Manjiri and told her ek din sab ek ek karke aapko chhodke jayenge.

That was to show that Aarohi has dumped Birlas forever. And post Abhi-Abhir’s death, Goenka and Birla ka katti ho Gaya. So Ruhi inke paas hi reh gayi.

Exactly, jab arohi ki death hui tab arohi ruhi already birla house se exit kark hoenka house aa chuk the , humesha k liye.

To goekas kyu ruhi ko wapas birla house me drop karne jyenge . Waha par na aru h na Abhimanyu. Kisk pass chor k avenge??.

Manjari to waise hi psycho ho chuki hogi after Abhimanyu 's death . Shefali manjari ka Dhyan rakhegi .

And if you guys remember , mahima n Shefali were seen scolding ruhi in initial episodes . So they don't have that much love for them .

It does make sense to keep her with goenkas coz yaha Muskan kairav the Usk Khyal rakhne ko.

Bdw , it doesn't make sense that makers are showing that kairav muski are gone to America. Muski had gov job in udaipur, how come she left her hard earned job and went to US leaving old grand parents n her amma behind. And no contact with her beloved bhaiji's child . Wherase Surekha is still here away from her hubby n kids.

They should show that Surekha went back to US and kairav Muskan raising ruhi. They could have shown there kids . A better family at goenkas side!!

Originally posted by: Sakshi-deewan

Exactly, jab arohi ki death hui tab arohi ruhi already birla house se exit kark hoenka house aa chuk the , humesha k liye.

To goekas kyu ruhi ko wapas birla house me drop karne jyenge . Waha par na aru h na Abhimanyu. Kisk pass chor k avenge??.

Manjari to waise hi psycho ho chuki hogi after Abhimanyu 's death . Shefali manjari ka Dhyan rakhegi .

And if you guys remember , mahima n Shefali were seen scolding ruhi in initial episodes . So they don't have that much love for them .

It does make sense to keep her with goenkas coz yaha Muskan kairav the Usk Khyal rakhne ko.

Bdw , it doesn't make sense that makers are showing that kairav muski are gone to America. Muski had gov job in udaipur, how come she left her hard earned job and went to US leaving old grand parents n her amma behind. And no contact with her beloved bhaiji's child . Wherase Surekha is still here away from her hubby n kids.

They should show that Surekha went back to US and kairav Muskan raising ruhi. They could have shown there kids . A better family at goenkas side!!

Originally posted by: Sakshi-deewan

Exactly, jab arohi ki death hui tab arohi ruhi already birla house se exit kark hoenka house aa chuk the , humesha k liye.

To goekas kyu ruhi ko wapas birla house me drop karne jyenge . Waha par na aru h na Abhimanyu. Kisk pass chor k avenge??.

Manjari to waise hi psycho ho chuki hogi after Abhimanyu 's death . Shefali manjari ka Dhyan rakhegi .

And if you guys remember , mahima n Shefali were seen scolding ruhi in initial episodes . So they don't have that much love for them .

It does make sense to keep her with goenkas coz yaha Muskan kairav the Usk Khyal rakhne ko.

Bdw , it doesn't make sense that makers are showing that kairav muski are gone to America. Muski had gov job in udaipur, how come she left her hard earned job and went to US leaving old grand parents n her amma behind. And no contact with her beloved bhaiji's child . Wherase Surekha is still here away from her hubby n kids.

They should show that Surekha went back to US and kairav Muskan raising ruhi. They could have shown there kids . A better family at goenkas side!!

I'm surprised Abhira doesn't know about Muskaan. They could have followed Kairav and Muskaan to America. Atleast Abhira will have some relatives with her

Originally posted by: PrplPhoenix

I'm surprised Abhira doesn't know about Muskaan. They could have followed Kairav and Muskaan to America. Atleast Abhira will have some relatives with her

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

If Kairav and Muskaan are not retained in the script, Abhira unke baare mei jaanke kya karegi?

That's what I'm saying? What's the need to end their character. Atleast by keeping them, Akshara and Abhira will have someone with them. Just as Ruhi has her Manish, Swarna and Surekha. Abhira can have her Kairav mamu and Muskaan buami. It would be interesting to see Kairav supporting his sister and niece.

Aage jaake nahi pata but the script that they are VERYYYY loosely following requires the female lead to have no family. Aage ka pata nahi. Zaroorat padi toh laa denge