Who will support Abhimanyu? - Page 10

Originally posted by: Noorain13

And to what extent are we going where we’re not seeing the pain of a sister who is seeing her brother fight for his life?
As professionals, we are prepared for such instances because we’re not always giving out positive news. There will be times we’re make the other person angry and so forth. For example, I was at an ER for work purposes last year and the doctor told this one guy that his child had passed away. Out of anger/emotions/denial he punched the doctor. If the doctor wanted, he could’ve pressed charges regardless of him being on call working or not but the doctor ended up hugging the man. They were complete strangers but the doctor knew what he was feeling and in this case, Abhimanyu is like a brother to Muskaan or at least that’s what he told her.

Here, Muskaan who saw Abhimanyu taking her brother and then she found him in that state is not in a position to think right. Akshara on one hand is pleading Abhimanyu to save her husband and Muskaan on the other hand has a different reaction, it could have well been the other way around. I’m in no way defending her actions but currently she’s not in the right mind to think.

There is a huge difference between what Abhi should do in this situation, and what Muskaan should do. Obvs, Abhi is not going to press charges or even do much here. I doubt. He will understand she is reacting to the situation. But that doesn't make her reaction right. That has been the point of this discussion is how they are showing people treating a doctor and if that is an acceptable way to treat a doctor. Not what the doctor should do in this situation.

Originally posted by: PhoenixRising

@bold - I was wondering if this poorly executed track was going to benefit the story in anyway! However, these statements in bold proved that it may lead to people understanding Abhimanyu's state of mind on WD. Thank you so much for saying this and making me feel positive about this track. 🤗

How is Muskaan pushing Abhimanyu and him divorcing Akshara in vulnerable state the same? Please elaborate.

Originally posted by: Noorain13

How is Muskaan pushing Abhimanyu and him divorcing Akshara in vulnerable state the same? Please elaborate.

Who will support Abhimanyu?

Makers with their washing powder nirma

Originally posted by: PhoenixRising

@bold - I was wondering if this poorly executed track was going to benefit the story in anyway! However, these statements in bold proved that it may lead to people understanding Abhimanyu's state of mind on WD. Thank you so much for saying this and making me feel positive about this track. 🤗

YOU SAID IT!! 🙌🏼

It’s not even the same though. WD was worse!

Cause here, Muskaan is behaving as if Abhinav is already dead, when he is struggling on his death bed awaiting surgery. Patient’s family assaulting an on duty doctor and stopping him from performing a life saving surgery. How is that understandable??

Muskaan needs to be put in jail.

Originally posted by: dotheDrama

YOU SAID IT!! 🙌🏼

It’s not even the same though. WD was worse!

Cause here, Muskaan is behaving as if Abhinav is already dead, when he is struggling on his death bed awaiting surgery. Patient’s family assaulting an on duty doctor and stopping him from performing a life saving surgery. How is that understandable??

Muskan needs to be put in jail.

Originally posted by: lagjagale

There is a huge difference between what Abhi should do in this situation, and what Muskaan should do. Obvs, Abhi is not going to press charges or even do much here. I doubt. He will understand she is reacting to the situation. But that doesn't make her reaction right. That has been the point of this discussion is how they are showing people treating a doctor and if that is an acceptable way to treat a doctor. Not what the doctor should do in this situation.

It doesn’t have to do with a doctor here, it has to do with her emotions. Her treating anyone like that is not right regardless of their profession. If she pushed Akshara or her husband like that, would it be right? No! It’s what shes going through right now and what extent she goes to. For example, if she shot Abhi and he died, she would still get arrested right and sentenced for 1st degree murder. Court won’t be like ke she was hurt so she killed him.

We are just outweighing the defense of a doctor on call vs the emotions of a sister here.

Originally posted by: Noorain13

How is Muskaan pushing Abhimanyu and him divorcing Akshara in vulnerable state the same? Please elaborate.

Yeah it's not the same Abhi was in a situation worse than Muskaan's, her brother is not dead yet. AB's brother whose wife was pregnant was dead his two unborn babies died his mom and the whole family was in a miserable situation. If she is not capable of thinking than AB was definitely not capable of thinking.

Originally posted by: Needhi.A

Yeah it's not the same Abhi was in a situation worse than Muskaan's, her brother is not dead yet. AB's brother whose wife was pregnant was dead his two unborn babies died his mom and the whole family was in a miserable situation. If she is not capable of thinking than AB was definitely not capable of thinking.

Yeah but muskaan is Abhimanyu’s said sister but Akshara was his wife, the love of his life and Abhimanyu is not hurt not even a scratch on this man physically nor any emotional hurt but Akshara was hurt both physically and mentally and also lost her twins.
We can compare the pain both Abhimanyu and Muskaan will go through because both are losing their siblings here but reactions cannot be compared due to who’s on the other end.

The only way this was comparable was if Kairav also went with them, jumped to help Abhinav which resulted in minor injuries and Muskaan went into the room where he was being treated and divorced him 😂

Originally posted by: Noorain13

It doesn’t have to do with a doctor here, it has to do with her emotions. Her treating anyone like that is not right regardless of their profession. If she pushed Akshara or her husband like that, would it be right? No! It’s what shes going through right now and what extent she goes to. For example, if she shot Abhi and he died, she would still get arrested right and sentenced for 1st degree murder. Court won’t be like ke she was hurt so she killed him.

We are just outweighing the defense of a doctor on call vs the emotions of a sister here.

Not sure what you are getting at. But no, it's not the same as if she were to push Ak or anyone else. It's a LOT worse because Abhi is a doctor and going to perform an operation. If she did that to him while they are back home, still not okay, but can be understood as grief. But here, she can see he is in his scrubs; he literally can't even touch anything cause he is sanitized and ready. At this point, she is making him fall. Lol, if you see the clip, Abhi is still keeping his hands up cause he doesn't want to touch the floor and not breaking his fall as a result.