Shut up I don't need any proof

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
It was one of the best episodes in terms of performances...

Naira despite of frustration and confusion told Kartik what must be told long before...but than she herself was confused...how could any girl be confused?...specifically regarding sensitive issues like these...but than how can a person worshiped by her family who supposedly empowered women be a sexual predator?...its not impossible to have confused and agitated state of mind for time being...specially when the abuser is a part of family...a man of grandfather's age...a devil who had a facade of angel...being touched inappropriately is not an issue to be raised for people like Suhasini Goenka...Puru's own confession of what he did with Mansi 15 years back acted as a trigger which made Naira confront dadi and reveal truth to Kartik immediately!...her keeping her mouth shut by pillow was very well enacted...her uttering "sorry Mansi I couldn't do anything for u" disappointed me...that time I thought she won't tell Kartik...but Kartik asked and she told without any delay...finally...Kartik's reaction was the best one!...I lovedd him...he told her to shut up with her "I have proofs"...his I don't need proof is a constant factor from Aditya's time...Momo was too effin' good portraying emotions of a brother and husband who was willing to kill that lech to a defeated man who couldn't protect his sister and wife...I lovedd Kartik after so long...Though they don't need to find proofs...but Goenka family didn't trust Kartik, Naira and Naksh when Naira slapped Aditya for touching her inappropriately...Manish inquired about the proof...he told Kartik u are blinded by ur love for Naira she might have misconception regarding the touch...asked them to apologize to Aditya...kind of people Goenkas are they need proof to protect their daughters and daughter-in-laws...it would have been logical if they tried to find proofs to get puru punished not to prove anything to useless family...Kartik would have actually killed or broke Puru's bones himself if Naira didn't stop him...the way Naira was frustrated and vulnerable after long time but than revealed truth with pain in her voice and tried to compose him was very well enacted by Shivi...

Shivin were too good with their performance...Kartik and Naira's conversation was highlight of entire episode...she revealed about Mansi,herself and dadi knowing the truth...how she feel disgusted...he trusted her even wanted to kill Puru...her frustration, helplessness and finally confiding in Kartik...his confusion frustration,helplessness and guilt the way she tried to compose him only she could do that...Momo's performance reminded me of his performance during the episode when he held their baby and lost her moments later...this one had glimpses of that level of perfection...
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

2.8k

Users

5

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
I wish there had been a maha episode to reveal pervert Mama's intentions. Today was very interesting and I'm glad that Karthik trusted Naira.
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
Sometimes I may have some issues with the cvs characterization of Kartik but one thing that I'll always adore is how Kartik always, always stands by Naira- proof or no proof. Like in this situation or in Aditya's situation. The ML-FL equation is one of the unique things that Yeh rishta always gets right.

Performance wise Mohsin was fab! (And so was Shivangi).
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
Kartik's anger was amazing felt the scene was rushed they could have went slower with it and showed his devestation finding out his beloved mama was a pedophile/sexual predator
But for me this proves that kartik is eternally selfish like i love him but if u really think about it

He used puru mama as a kid to probably make manish jealous right like he did with naitik

he never noticed keerti was being abused coz all he cared about was his own hatred for manish

he loved naira ddn care if his family disowned him all he wanted was her

When he got his own family back ddn ever give a side glance to a singhania

then when she did something that ddn please him threw her away like trash and moped because she allowed herself to be thrown away like how dare she

then when he got her back got this sick dependency/ obsession with her

The only thing that bothers him is things that keep her away from him naksh, rishab, herself at times...

other than that he is okay and oblivious to protecting her ...

from creeps ...

I still love him
but... wish he protected her more

He looks so damn handsome angry
Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
I have watched that so many times now. Just loved Kartik's reaction. Going by the cvs track of the few records, I was keeping my hopes low, but they didn't disappoint.

Mohsin and Shivangi's acting was top-notch. The change in emotions from frustration, to anger, disappointment, helplessness was beautifully portrayed.

Loved how Kartik kept saying I will kill that man and then Naira hugging him because she knows she's the only one who can control his emotions.

Kartik's breakdown on not being able to protect his sister and wife was so damn good. I liked how he kept saying meri behen instead of Mansi.

The family doing weird dance moves in between the scene could have been avoided in my opinion. They all looked stupid, no offence to the actors.

Hate Dadi. She's so damn selfish. I have a feeling the Goenkas losing their money is the next track because they keep saying that Mama helped them establish their empire.

Illa keeps giving weird looks. I have a feeling she knows about her father's misdoings.

Kartik noticed Mama looking at Naira in a weird way. Him trying to be cool and act natural was again so good.

I agree with you. I would have liked had they told the family and the family would have believed thm for a change. They could have found the proof to get him arrested.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Partyc

3 months ago

No need of third angle ka child anymore.

Looks like Patanjali and Armaan will have EMA and later they will marry and have a child who will become villain next gen. We had Aarohi in Gen...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".