The forgotten misdeeds of family

Page

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 6 years ago

-Manish Goenka and Akhilesh Goenka used Kashyap and presented him as Akshara's murderer...to save Kartik...they deceived everyone including Kartik, Naira and Singhanias...Forgiven

-Akhilesh Goenka lied to Naira about her mother's accident to save his daughter Mansi...he didn't let confession letter reach her before their marriage...Forgiven

-Manish Goenka asked his daughter to treat her husband well because their company is going have merger with Aditya's company...if Aditya is happy with her it will be good for their deal...Forgiven

-Akhilesh Goenka became puppet in the hands of Samarth Goenka and tried to take revenge from his brother...Forgiven

-Samarth Goenka tried to destroy Goenkas...Forgiven

-Manish Goenka alongwith his mother tried to determine gender of unborn baby against law and had knowledge about ashes being mixed in their DIL's food without her knowledge...Forgiven

-Nannu Maheshwari pushed badi dadi from stairs...Forgiven

-Mansi Goenka caused Akshara's accident...Forgiven

-Mansi and Anmol lied about Mansi's pregnancy...Forgiven

-Naksh Singhania lied to get married to Keerti...Forgiven

-Shubham Goenka tried to frame Kartik in fraud case...Kartik went to jail in Greece because of him...Forgiven

-Suwarna Goenka lied about her son's death for 19 years...performed rituals for her dead son though he was alive...separated Kaira didn't informed anyone about Naira's conversation with her before deciding to divorce Kartik...deleted her son's call logs...Planned marriage of an already married man with her friend's daughter...Forgiven

-Suhasini Goenka threw her pota bahu out of the house without her husband's knowledge endangering her life...Stole conk...Instigated Keerti against Singhanias several times...tried to illegally determine sex of unborn baby...mixed ashes in food to change baby's gender...Forgiven

Naira Goenka hide about truth of Shubham's drug addiction...Not Forgiven...Mistreated...Was asked to leave GV...

Kartik Goenka swapped babies against law without knowledge of biological parents to save his wife from mental trauma...Not Forgiven...Mistreated...Is asked to leave GV...

What Kartik did can't be justified...but family is doing isn't also justified considering their own track record and their own share of deceiving their family members apart from that Manish and Akhilesh adopted illegal ways to save their children...framed an innocent man...kept the real culprit hidden from Singhanias...now they are talking about hurting family?...Manish Goenka hid his first wife's letters from Kartik so he won't have a heartbreak...let Kartik hate him...but didn't inform him truth about his mother's death...considering the fact that Naira may die because of mental trauma as Manish keep repeating it (newly discovered fact because of ML)...why can't there be any possibility that Kartik did what he did to save her?...though it hurt her lot more...it made her living dead person...but doesn't he has right to talk to her once...explain himself once?...wouldn't she be more hurt without any justification from his side?...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Fari_15

@Fari_15

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 6 years ago

I think Manish's reaction is laying the ground work for the future track. Idk how, but I do think his anger and disappointment in Kartik would be further explored in the memory loss track.
Maybe Naira will live with the Goenkas because she forgot everyone and Manish won't allow Kartik near her?
Or even if Naira lives with Singhania's, Kartik would he asked to move out of the Goenka Villa, hence he will be introduced as Kartik to Naira once again, not Kartik Goenka.
Maybe this hatred would continue even after Naira regains her memory, forcing Kartik to move out of the Goenka Villa with Naira.
All I am saying is, everything happens for a reason in these shows.Even Kartik would be forgiven in due time, just not right now because tbh they do have to show something to keep the show running.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

A HUGE FAN

@A HUGE FAN

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 6 years ago

Don't worry, Kartik will be forgiven soon.

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Fari_15
I think Manish's reaction is laying the ground work for the future track. Idk how, but I do think his anger and disappointment in Kartik would be further explored in the memory loss track.
Maybe Naira will live with the Goenkas because she forgot everyone and Manish won't allow Kartik near her?
Or even if Naira lives with Singhania's, Kartik would he asked to move out of the Goenka Villa, hence he will be introduced as Kartik to Naira once again, not Kartik Goenka.
Maybe this hatred would continue even after Naira regains her memory, forcing Kartik to move out of the Goenka Villa with Naira.
All I am saying is, everything happens for a reason in these shows.Even Kartik would be forgiven in due time, just not right now because tbh they do have to show something to keep the show running.

@bold this can only be possible if Naira forgot every single memory of her life...if she forget her parents, her family, her Rishikesh memories and the fact that she lived as Tina there for 7 years...only then she will live with Goenkas...but losing a part of life or her forgetting about Kartik is possible...but her forgetting her childhood memories, teenage, adulthood the three phases of life at the same time isn't possible...forgetting her parents, sibling and family seems unlikely if she is going to have retrograde amnesia...but as writers already did kachra of neurodegenerative diseases...we can expect anything...It would be good to see Goenkas taking care of Naira...but they can't make Kartik stay away from Naira for longer time...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago

Quote

rose2015

@rose2015

Voyager

Posted: 6 years ago

Do any of you fans find Karthik's possessiveness of Naira overbearing? I sometimes find it kind of creepy like he 24/7 is stalking her. That's all he thinks about. Today's scene with the bloody hand mark on the window was kind of creepy and scary. They have guards around their home. Were they sleeping and do they not have security cameras around Goenka villa. I was actually relieved when he was walking in the streets just so that Naira had her space to sort out her feelings without he being in her face all the time. It just comes off as a unhealthy/toxic relationship. He comes off as too controlling not allowing Naira to make any decisions on her own. It's as if she is not a whole person.

Edited by rose2015 - 6 years ago

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Team Critics

Posted: 6 years ago

i don't know why this one mistake/sin is SO overbearing that it overshadows the complete personality of kartik and everybody just forgot who he is and under what circumstances he took this bad decision. Yes he should not be forgiven so easily & he must be genuinely feeling guilty about it ...Whats the redemption for him? send him to jail or abandon him, disown him?

Quote

rose2015

@rose2015

Voyager

Posted: 6 years ago

I feel only Naira can make that decision on her own without anyone's influence.

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_
i don't know why this one mistake/sin is SO overbearing that it overshadows the complete personality of kartik and everybody just forgot who he is and under what circumstances he took this bad decision. Yes he should not be forgiven so easily & he must be genuinely feeling guilty about it ...Whats the redemption for him? send him to jail or abandon him, disown him?

@bold I agree...he made a mistake/sin...the circumstances in which he took that decision are completely forgotten and families are behaving as if they have been there with him handling the sitaution...what's wrong is wrong...but that doesn't mean a character will be mistreated to an extent it becomes difficult to sympathize with supporting characters who were also wronged...If Manish, Akhilesh, Mansi, Samarth, Shubham and KD can be forgiven even after committing crime...Suwarna for her wrong doings...Naksh for deceiving families...than why can't Kartik be forgiven?...just because he is ML?...he has to be mahan, ever sacrificing always morally correct?...

Quote

TeenRose1

@TeenRose1

Dazzler

Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: rose2015
Do any of you fans find Karthik's possessiveness of Naira overbearing? I sometimes find it kind of creepy like he 24/7 is stalking her. That's all he thinks about. Today's scene with the bloody hand mark on the window was kind of creepy and scary. They have guards around their home. Were they sleeping and do they not have security cameras around Goenka villa. I was actually relieved when he was walking in the streets just so that Naira had her space to sort out her feelings without he being in her face all the time. It just comes off as a unhealthy/toxic relationship. He comes off as too controlling not allowing Naira to make any decisions on her own. It's as if she is not a whole person.

He is obviously very worried about her since she has a clot in her head and she shudn't stress herself. She is obviously and he wants her to not be stressed bcos it is damage to her health.

Quote

arshibarunsanay

@arshibarunsanay

Beginner

Posted: 6 years ago

#10

Can anyone pls kill this naksh 😡 he's very annoying Wat happened with this show manhandling is not there before when people commit the hell of mistakes wat is happening can't they just stop and at least can't the parents mourn for the death of their only baby now memory loss 😡😡😡

Quote

The forgotten misdeeds of family

Related Topics

Explore Topics