Irresponsible behaviour of both Family and Naira - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

4.8k

Users

11

Likes

82

Frequent Posters

rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#21
Exactly! No one has the right to take someone else's baby without their consent. That is a crime. By showing such an action they are butchering the character of Karthik. I work with newborns. What he is doing is illegal. It's a crime to steal another couple's baby. Hospitals have high security measures so that babies don't get stolen.

I wish writers would do some research before showing us this medical crap.
Posted: 6 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: rose2015

Exactly! No one has the right to take someone else's baby without their consent. That is a crime. By showing such an action they are butchering the character of Karthik. I work with newborns. What he is doing is illegal. It's a crime to steal another couple's baby. Hospitals have high security measures so that babies don't get stolen.

I wish writers would do some research before showing us this medical crap.


i call it kidnapping... taking anyones kid without the parents knowing is kidnapping/stealing.. really hope kartik doesnt steal the baby... whatever is left of original kartik that will be butchered as well...

im sure naira can take the news of her miscarriage if conveyed properly... like having her get attached to the kid thats not hers then her having to give it up is going to be worse..

like many ppl said im down to see kaira take care of keeshs kid until naksh/keesh get better but i really dont want naira considering it her own kid..
Aslesha99 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team Neutrals

Posted: 6 years ago
#23
New SBS segment Karthik crying his eyes out looking at the dead baby😭.
Edited by Aslesha99 - 6 years ago
Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#24
I highly doubt Kartik would go along with the baby swap. Naira believing Keesh's baby as her's seems like a temporary misunderstanding. It will be cleared once Naksh regains consciousness or the family members start asking about Keerti's baby.
The writers have preached about positivity and being real for way too long to go down this route now. They won't butcher Kartik's character to this extent.
It would have been a different case (not that I am saying it would have been right) had Keesh died but right now both the parents are alive. Naksh is still very much capable of looking after his baby and if not him, then the Singhania's.
Going by the segment promo, Kartik is crying looking at his baby (the most heartbreaking thing ever), I am sure Naira would see it too. Kartik won't let the baby go till she says a final goodbye.
After knowing the baby she had was Keesh, she might start panicking and instead of telling her, Kartik will probably bring her to this room and show the baby, thus telling her about its demise.
There's a mahaepisode this week as well but I hope the deliveries aren't dragged for that long.
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Fari_15



She didn't. The doctor was supposedly gonna come to their house after his clinic but he didn't (or at least it wasn't shown in the show).
Both of them just assumed the baby was alright because it kept kicking.


Ohh ! I forgot.


Heights of irresponsible behaviour by Naira.


I can understand Karthik and Family did not remember due to Keerthi's problems but what excuse does Naira has ?


After a lot of hardship she has become a mother but still doesn't value it.
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Jade05

From where I see it, I feel Kartik n both d families should have calmly explained her the situation abt keerti n naksh's accident, were they planning to hide it for next 2 months? Explaining her under calm situation would have been d most logical thing to do. Naira didn't go to d hospital for investigation, since Chachi lied to her abt giving her some surprise she concluded that this was d surprise she was talking abt. N she most probably thought that other house members are at d hospital as well, so her not calling them wasnt that much stupid that it becomes her fault that she suffered a miscarriage. What makers want to show is that Kaira baby took the pain from keerti upon itself, however illogical or absurd it may sound thats wat they want to show. So even if someone should be blamed for d situation, the families must top d list. All of them were doing some pooja rather than taking care of kids. Chachi was busy on phone for so long she didnt have a clue that Naira wasnt in d lawn. Chachi was so into her own world that even if Naira was in d lawn n tripped over something, she wouldn't have a clue abt dat as well


@bold _ nobody is saying that miscarriage happened due to she sneaking out.


I was pointing out to her irresponsible nature.


According to you , since family members are already at a place , it's ok to not inform the people who are there with you when you are leaving house for that place.


So its ok for them to panic while you dance away as after all you are going to a place where few family members are already there.


Moreover while they are in the house they should not do any other work and give you attention 24*7 coz the person whom they are taking care is a 5 year old kid rather than an adult and do not understand the meaning of responsibility and careless nature.


👏👏👏


Tripping etc is not in ones hand but saying and leaving house is.



Jade05 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: abhilasha_dream


@bold _ nobody is saying that miscarriage happened due to she sneaking out.


I was pointing out to her irresponsible nature.


According to you , since family members are already at a place , it's ok to not inform the people who are there with you when you are leaving house for that place.


So its ok for them to panic while you dance away as after all you are going to a place where few family members are already there.


Moreover while they are in the house they should not do any other work and give you attention 24*7 coz the person whom they are taking care is a 5 year old kid rather than an adult and do not understand the meaning of responsibility and careless nature.


👏👏👏


Tripping etc is not in ones hand but saying and leaving house is.




I don't think i said anything so offensive that u need to get sarcastic about d whole thing, calm down n we can have a discussion like adults.
Giving attention 24*7 is not what I meant when i said chachi was careless bt when u have someone to take care of at your house then it is only logical to keep a check on that person from time to time, especially when chachi is aware of d whole situation. Like Naira was away for atleast an hour n chachi did not go out at all to check if she is in need of something. Khair, leave that now coming to Naira being irresponsible, see she had no clue whatsoever that she would face such a dire situation at d hospital. She thought they all were planning for it as a surprise n she apparently cant tell chachi that I have come to know abt d surprise n I m going to see it as she won't even let her go. For us this kind of surprise seems out of place coz we know how tragic it is, bt she doesnt know anything its a normal day for her n she did not plan to go to some party bt a hospital, no prudent person will be able to comprehend that things could turn so nasty there.She was just as excited as anyone would be to meet her brother's baby
Aslesha99 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team Neutrals

Posted: 6 years ago
#28
I am feeling very bad for Naksh and Keerti. Karthik had no right to give their baby to Naira he thought about Naira but what about Naksh a man who is currently shattered with the news of his wife going into coma and you gave him more pain by snatching his son from him. What about Keerti? She is your sister the same sister who you grew up with, the same sister who ties you a rakhi and in return you promise to protect her is this how you protect her by stealing her baby and giving her sorrow.

Karthik has gone mad in his love for Naira he stole his sisters baby. Keesh are the parents they have a full right on the baby he had no right to separate them from their own child for his own selfish reasons. Karthik did this for Naira but does he realise what will happen when the truth gets revealed? Naira would be very attached to the baby and Keesh would want their son back it will be very difficult to let go. He should have calmly sat Naira down and told her he truth she still would have been devastated but would eventually have been able to get over the pain of losing her baby. Now when she finds out the truth she would be pained over losing her baby and now also having to let go of the baby so loved like her own.

I hope once the truth comes out everyone including the family, Naira and Keesh scold him for his actions what he did was very wrong morally and legally.
Edited by Aslesha99 - 6 years ago
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Jade05


I don't think i said anything so offensive that u need to get sarcastic about d whole thing, calm down n we can have a discussion like adults.
Giving attention 24*7 is not what I meant when i said chachi was careless bt when u have someone to take care of at your house then it is only logical to keep a check on that person from time to time, especially when chachi is aware of d whole situation. Like Naira was away for atleast an hour n chachi did not go out at all to check if she is in need of something. Khair, leave that now coming to Naira being irresponsible, see she had no clue whatsoever that she would face such a dire situation at d hospital. She thought they all were planning for it as a surprise n she apparently cant tell chachi that I have come to know abt d surprise n I m going to see it as she won't even let her go. For us this kind of surprise seems out of place coz we know how tragic it is, bt she doesnt know anything its a normal day for her n she did not plan to go to some party bt a hospital, no prudent person will be able to comprehend that things could turn so nasty there.She was just as excited as anyone would be to meet her brother's baby


@bold_ You haven't got my post.


I am not blaming her for circumstances which happened in hospital.


Nobody can predict what is gonna happen with them the next moment , so Naira leaving home without informing is nowhere concerned to her having a miscarriage.


I am solely speaking about her one action - not informing before leaving.


As per chachi is concerned, we really do not know the time frame she hadn't checked on Naira. Her long time can also refer to 20 min or 30 minutes or more than 2 hours. So we can give her benefit of doubt.


Coming down to Naira being excited to meet her brothers baby , well that anybody would be but than behaving in the right way is what adults are all about.

Hope I am clear this time.
abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Aslesha99

I am feeling very bad for Naksh and Keerti. Karthik had no right to give their baby to Naira he thought about Naira but what about Naksh a man who is currently shattered with the news of his wife going into coma and you gave him more pain by snatching his son from him. What about Keerti? She is your sister the same sister who you grew up with, the same sister who ties you a rakhi and in return you promise to protect her is this how you protect her by stealing her baby and giving her sorrow.


Karthik has gone mad in his love for Naira he stole his sisters baby. Keesh are the parents they have a full right on the baby he had no right to separate them from their own child for his own selfish reasons. Karthik did this for Naira but does he realise what will happen when the truth gets revealed? Naira would be very attached to the baby and Keesh would want their son back it will be very difficult to let go. He should have calmly sat Naira down and told her he truth she still would have been devastated but would eventually have been able to get over the pain of losing her baby. Now when she finds out the truth she would be pained over losing her baby and now also having to let go of the baby so loved like her own.

I hope once the truth comes out everyone including the family, Naira and Keesh scold him for his actions what he did was very wrong morally and legally.


I agree.


I had been repeatedly telling this that the love which Karthik possess for her is toxic.


Whatever his Dadi tells him is true. as for him his world starts and ends with Naira and rest nobody matters for him.


He loses the sense of right and wrong without Naira.


Even when the doctor was explaining something important about Keerthy, his mind was on Naira. That itself proves how much he is occupied with Naira.


He was the worst man to have been handed over this responsibility of looking after Keerthy and Naksh as the person who can take paternity leave for 9 months would not be in peace after his wife escaped such a big accident. He needed another baby moon to reassure himself.


Coming down to handing over Kesh baby to Naira and giving immense pain to Naksh was wrong.


Leave the pain of adults , if the child would get to know about his real parents after a point where he gets attached to Kaira , he will not be able to adjust at all.


Karthik has no right to give the child so much of pain for his own selfishness.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: madhuvan · 3 months ago

Getting a feeling this time Legacy FL child will ne negative itself rather than the side or 3rd angle. Maira is too much of trouble maker. This...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 4 months ago

not my idea... Bass instagram par dekha and thoda sensible laga... https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Mehersudha · 1 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DNcDj8czKh9/?igsh=aWEzZ2FtN3hnajZ0 Geetu backs off seeing abheera maira hug She feels defeated Trophy is given to...

https://www.instagram.com/p/DNcDj8czKh9/?igsh=aWEzZ2FtN3hnajZ0
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Mehersudha · 1 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMrDQFISpl9/?igsh=dWdiaGM1ZGs2eHdi Ar misses mairu wants to talk to her Vidya sees fridge full of veggies fruits...

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMrDQFISpl9/?igsh=dWdiaGM1ZGs2eHdi
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 2 months ago

Those days were they had perfect family! Absolutely no one in this generation can even come close to precious rishta these three had! No...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".