vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
I understand Naira's journey post leap.. she might be wrong or right in whatever decisions she has taken.. but I understand that she thinks from her heart and there is a consistency in her thoughts. Her emotions also changed with how Kartik behaved with her.. if he was calm with her, she would be calm too, if he was angry with her, she would be angry too. Her behaviour is generally a reaction to his mood swings. And yet, she tried to keep her life together in whatever ways she could. The decisions she has taken seemed gradual and not weird or sudden.
On the other hand, Kartik.. I can't understand his thought process.. what he says, what he wants, what he does.. there is so much contradiction, it's super confusing. The only emotion he showed with consistency is - anger. Rest, every emotion has been dwindling like a see-saw. Oh, and Maa ka dard. Only CVs can understand his weird slave mentality to his mom. it's beyond me to be honest so I'm not going to torture myself with that. But seriously though there is something missing with Kartik's POV. Even when they do give him monologues, they don't make sense.. or they contradict to what he has done in the previous scene or what he will do in the next scene.

Like, he screams at her to NOT attend the engagement, and when she doesn't he blames her for being Egoistic? 😕
He doesn't want to take her name in front of his mother so when she does relieve him of that torture he plays victim card? 😕

Kya dikhana chahte hain?

I feel like shaking the writers .. to wake them up from this sad depressing place from where they are writing these pathetic tracks. Ugh!!

Stop it already!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

582

Users

5

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

SakshiKR thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Agreed!! There is no consistency in his character..or rather realisation...are they trying to show that he has completely lost his ability to behave like a normal person because Nairas not in his life, because everything wrong that he does is because of Naira...when will they realise that blame game is no answer...like how did Manish forgive Swarna for hiding Shubham?? Naira made them realise right...everybody makes mistakes, at least give her one chance to hear her out...it's such a depressing fest...they are trying to show a wedding track to reduce the negativity but the wedding track will also be depressing and negative no matter how many dream sequences they show...this show is losing its charms and the writers are in their own sweet world because they know the popularity of Kaira as a couple, so show whatever..people will keep watching👎🏼
Stardust91 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I feel you are right @Sakshi -- they do want to show that kartik is no longer in his senses because he does not have Naira and all he is faced with day in and day out is ma ka dard.
what a ma! and what a step brother. He died and along with him he took Kittu;s happiness and Kittu's most sacred rishta. As selfish as Shubham was when he was alive is as selfish as he was in death. It was always about him and still is. UGH!!
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Repeating what i said before ma ka dard guilt tripped him into not loving naira anymore...
He doesnt day dream of her...
He doesnt look at her lovingly...
His chinta turned off...
His usual politeness overly sweet nature is switched off and in place is left a rabid dog ready to bite anyone who isnt a goenka and naira...
I feel like there is a major mis balance with his scenes someone else mentioned this. We get to feel exactly what naira does but never kartik. Because he bounces from one direction to the next and we all are left confused.
Does he love naira?
He is angry because of shubhams death?
His love for his mother blinds him into becoming a bad husband...
He doesnt even get much scenes were he behaves like a normal human being...All he does is either talk nicely to a goenka and then 2 seconds later growls at naira. then three seconds later... bows his head down for mummy to pet...

Stardust91 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

Repeating what i said before ma ka dard guilt tripped him into not loving naira anymore...

He doesnt day dream of her...
He doesnt look at her lovingly...
His chinta turned off...
His usual politeness overly sweet nature is switched off and in place is left a rabid dog ready to bite anyone who isnt a goenka and naira...
I feel like there is a major mis balance with his scenes someone else mentioned this. We get to feel exactly what naira does but never kartik. Because he bounces from one direction to the next and we all are left confused.
Does he love naira?
He is angry because of shubhams death?
His love for his mother blinds him into becoming a bad husband...
He doesnt even get much scenes were he behaves like a normal human being...All he does is either talk nicely to a goenka and then 2 seconds later growls at naira. then three seconds later... bows his head down for mummy to pet...


Even my grandma who was watching today's episode with me was so angry when Swarna came ; she was like "pagal aurat; broke her own son's house"

He has PTSD --- and his trauma was not Shubham's death it was Naira telling him she wanted out
In Mumbai he was still better than he is now
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

Repeating what i said before ma ka dard guilt tripped him into not loving naira anymore...

He doesnt day dream of her...
He doesnt look at her lovingly...
His chinta turned off...
His usual politeness overly sweet nature is switched off and in place is left a rabid dog ready to bite anyone who isnt a goenka and naira...
I feel like there is a major mis balance with his scenes someone else mentioned this. We get to feel exactly what naira does but never kartik. Because he bounces from one direction to the next and we all are left confused.
Does he love naira?
He is angry because of shubhams death?
His love for his mother blinds him into becoming a bad husband...
He doesnt even get much scenes were he behaves like a normal human being...All he does is either talk nicely to a goenka and then 2 seconds later growls at naira. then three seconds later... bows his head down for mummy to pet...


@bold Exactly MKD has made him a completely different person than he use to be...he still loves Naira there is no doubt in that...but Naira is unforgivable for him...Naira should never ever give up on him...even if he repeatedly give up on her and taunt her...
vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


@bold Exactly MKD has made him a completely different person than he use to be...he still loves Naira there is no doubt in that...but Naira is unforgivable for him...Naira should never ever give up on him...even if he repeatedly give up on her and taunt her...



I don't mind him not day dreaming about her honestly. In that way at least there is some consistency in his words and actions. In Mumbai, he used to say I love you Naira in dreams and then shout on her when face to face and break things - that was so weird.
With his dreams gone, his chinta for her gone, he comes across as a lesser hypocrite. May be he doesn't love her anymore?🤔 All that is still understandable.. but why is he rude? That tone, my god. I feel Naira's pain more than his because his pain is lost to me in his high pitch shrieking.
Genuine request CVs, ask Momo to tone it down please. Kartik's words are enough to convey his hatred for Naira, it's stinging with his normal voice also, no need to put that extra effort.

@bold: Seriously, this is some another level hypocrisy. But hypocrisy is Goenka's middle name, so.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

3 days ago

Leap will start in November.

Similar to Gen 4 Maira will grow older being looked after by her Dadi and Bari Dadi but no confirmation regarding who is in the picture Arman or...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

These 2 Actors Finalized For YRKKH Gen Leap!!!!

These 2 Actors Roped In For Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Generation Leap!! Namit Shah, who is best known for playing Kabir in the Disney Channel's...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

YRKKH to take a generation leap!!!

StarPlus Directors Kut Productions start preparation for the next generation leap!! Drop whom you want as new leads!!!

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

2 months ago

Itv journey now a days

The first material we see is the promo. They make it larger than life,huge set,costume big dailogues.. good locations. We felt happy, They...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

3 months ago

Which Child leap serverd better?

Portal is open : As well as your options. Generation 4 just started but you know what's gonna happen in future : Mount Abu hit and miss moments,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".