CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Mansi caused Akshara's accident...it was an accident...Mansi wasn't adult that time...Her tau ji and father the great Goenkas concealed the truth...Karthik wrote a confession letter to Naira which she didn't read...when Naira and her family get to know the truth...Karthik Goenka took Mansi the teenager to SS fpr saying SORRY...Suwarna Goenka also went with them as she also thought Mansi should be forgiven...Naira forgave her...Singhanias forgave her...as punishing her won't bring Akshara back...When Naira didn't want to listen to Karthik and wanted sometime to recover from the shock...Karthik got angry with her and Naira had to apologize in joker's avatar to earn his forgiveness...Karthik Goenka told her you took right decision by forgiving Mansi...


Naira killed Shubham...Naira killed Shubham by not informing mighty Goenkas about his drug addiction which was a serious issue...that's true...who might have moved heavens and earth to save Shubham...Naira was slapped and pushed by Suwarna
...she was shown her boundary...she couldn't enter GV...her relationship with Karthik broke...because it was convenient and it is convenient for writers to drag a track...for few more months...they have actually made a mockery of depression,sadness, murder and death...

If Mansi...Karthik's sister can be forgiven for being a cause of someone's death...and Karthik considered it right decision...he didn't even once thought Mansi shouldn't be forgiven as Singhania family's loss is bigger one...why can't Naira be forgiven even if she is the cause of Shubham's death considering she forgave daughter of same house after losing her mother...thankfully she didn't cry a river...it was useless to weep for being accused once again...it was useless...when he repeated how many times he was there...forgetting how many times she was there for him...Naira also accused him for her mother's death but even after holding him responsible she closed that case...she didn't want him to be punished the very next day...would it be better if Naira also broke her marriage due to Mansi causing Akshara's accident and Goenkas hiding it...even Karthik not even once asked for apology from Singhanias...if he thought Singhanias would have forgiven Mansi without even any proper conversation before marriage...as forgiving is best...for peaceful life...why can't he forgave Naira? He held grudge of all previous incidents? What about Keesh's wedding and Soumya's death? When Naira had to go to her home...because he was angry at her...because he didn't trust her...They should leave some scope for Karthik to redeem...as this way...Karthik I loved is becoming more like any x y z hypocrite...
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

4.5k

Users

9

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

SakshiKR thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I have been watching this show since it started and this by far is the worst track, and this by far was one of the most hateful episodes. I used to love the way Kartik was with Naira, his love care and attention, and now after today's episode, I wish he never speaks to Naira. I am hating his character, the pettiness he showed today will actually justify Naira's actions later on. And don't even get me started on Swarna. That woman should go die somewhere, she has no right to be anyone's mother. I cringe whenever she comes on the screen and Manish and Dadi, the backbone that they had before the leap has been completely broken. I think the writers have been changed for YRKKH because they have completely forgotten the true essence of this series. Misunderstandings used to occur earlier also, but this much hatred towards someone you loved so much was never shown. I really hope that the writers understand that they are killing the wonderful-ness of the show and do something major to win the viewers back or else viewers will completely stop watching.
Naira has my heart for everything she has gone through and will go through, with the one fault she did of wanting to celebrate Kartiks birthday and informing the family few hours later of Shubhams addiction.

I am currently hating both Swarna and Kartik to no extent. It's time for some salvation for his character because if the writers keep destroying his character like they did today, nobody would want to see his sorrow and pain three four months later.
Roses4Moira thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I couldn't agree with you more...I really hope CV better show proper redeem track for karthik ..
vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I haven't seen the episode.. so my rant is based on what I read on the forum and on what I have seen in last 2 months.
Goenkas are super insensitive, selfish, rude and hypocrites.. and as of now Kartik is leading the clan with his amazing hypocrisy.

He can go around blaming Naira for Shubham's death, but Mansi - who was directly responsible for Naira's mother's death should be forgiven in a day! Say Hi to hypocrisy.
He will go around blaming Naira for their relationship's death but will not take any efforts to reconcile. None.

Were they really sitting with scorecards in today's confrontation? Tumne mujhe kitne baar trust kiya and maine kitne baar? Can some one also put out a chart of how many times Naira was thrown out of GV and how many Kartik from SS? Naira will win for sure. 👏

Naira was treated like a DOORMAT so many times in that family. Kartik ko yaad hai kya? Scratch that.. Kartik ko pata bhi hai kya? I have never seen Naira complain to him about his badhtameez family. Never. She has always been helpful, respectful to even those who don't deserve. She tried to mend all his relationships with his family members. Even Shubham. And all she got was.. dhakka.

Naira, pls stop bothering that family. They'll next blame you for Mansi's pregnancy fiasco.. later on you will be blamed for cockroach's death in GV. Unko unki duniya mein khush rehne do behan. Maaf kardo unko.

But the point is.. CVs are in love with Kartik. They will not make him apologize for anything. They will prove Naira wrong every time... will create situations where only she will be blamed and she will eventually end up saying sorry. All this.. Kartik is husband goals has gotten in their heads badly. They can't seem to think beyond Kartik at the moment.. you can see it in little scenes and shots.. it's always how Kartik is sad, broken, hurt.. Naira is just a zinda laash. She just curses her life. What have they made her 🤢
There is no balance anymore. It's just how good and amazing Kartik is and how flawed Naira is.
They've taken the story to a point where as a viewer I don't want them together.
Pls.. alag raho.. but khush raho. Stop crying for god's sake
Jade05 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Agree with your points. Today's episode made me cringe, it was so poorly written. It looked as if Kartik was reminding her of all the favours he did on her by standing with her in her bad times, completely forgetting what all she did for him n his not so worthy family, m so disappointed. Can we somehow convey this whole thing to the CVS because going by their record I don't think they would make Kartik apologize for anything, they would make it a mutual thing or may be we would again see naira running behind him.
kirts123 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Naira is going to hide mansi is pregnant.. Mansi won't die but something can happen to her and she ll be like "bhabhi knows" gone.. thats it.. things will get beserk again.. even if Karthik slaps naira I wont be surprised. I hope they never do anything like that..
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
🤣if kartik can hate his dad for 20 years naira kya cheez hai is what the writers are thinking but they keep forgetting that firstly he was not even that close with shubham...
and secondly naira was his life. He could bury 20 years of hate for naira. And live with his family just for her safety all of sudden chose his brother for 5 months over naira...and the woman he hated for 20 years suddenly became his world...
I get he is a mummys boy. IF was not one he would not be hating his dad for 20 years etc...
And he wants to take her side bla bla.
but still them over naira???
Naira was his life his family his everything how? why? what?

Plus he dug his own grave today and went beyond redemption with his nonsense...
I want to see him crawl out of this...
Dressing him in blue and making him cute helps dow in making the track easier to watch...
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: SakshiKR

I have been watching this show since it started and this by far is the worst track, and this by far was one of the most hateful episodes. I used to love the way Kartik was with Naira, his love care and attention, and now after today's episode, I wish he never speaks to Naira. I am hating his character, the pettiness he showed today will actually justify Naira's actions later on. And don't even get me started on Swarna. That woman should go die somewhere, she has no right to be anyone's mother. I cringe whenever she comes on the screen and Manish and Dadi, the backbone that they had before the leap has been completely broken. I think the writers have been changed for YRKKH because they have completely forgotten the true essence of this series. Misunderstandings used to occur earlier also, but this much hatred towards someone you loved so much was never shown. I really hope that the writers understand that they are killing the wonderful-ness of the show and do something major to win the viewers back or else viewers will completely stop watching.

Naira has my heart for everything she has gone through and will go through, with the one fault she did of wanting to celebrate Kartiks birthday and informing the family few hours later of Shubhams addiction.

I am currently hating both Swarna and Kartik to no extent. It's time for some salvation for his character because if the writers keep destroying his character like they did today, nobody would want to see his sorrow and pain three four months later.


@bold well I don't think viewers will stop watching...infact trps might rise due to the great showdown with pathetic dialogues and over dramatic camera shift...they are losing quality which they use to have even 3 weeks ago...
vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kirts123

Naira is going to hide mansi is pregnant.. Mansi won't die but something can happen to her and she ll be like "bhabhi knows" gone.. thats it.. things will get beserk again.. even if Karthik slaps naira I wont be surprised. I hope they never do anything like that..


Oh no no no... no slapping.. you see writers won't do that to Kartik perfect Goneka. They will show Mansi begging to "hide" this piece of info.. of course Naira will hide because she is an idiot.. and then later on Kartik can get a reason to blame her again. Full circle. Another month gone and the story doesn't move an inch. 👏

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: vellainsaan

I haven't seen the episode.. so my rant is based on what I read on the forum and on what I have seen in last 2 months.

Goenkas are super insensitive, selfish, rude and hypocrites.. and as of now Kartik is leading the clan with his amazing hypocrisy.

He can go around blaming Naira for Shubham's death, but Mansi - who was directly responsible for Naira's mother's death should be forgiven in a day! Say Hi to hypocrisy.
He will go around blaming Naira for their relationship's death but will not take any efforts to reconcile. None.

Were they really sitting with scorecards in today's confrontation? Tumne mujhe kitne baar trust kiya and maine kitne baar? Can some one also put out a chart of how many times Naira was thrown out of GV and how many Kartik from SS? Naira will win for sure. 👏

Naira was treated like a DOORMAT so many times in that family. Kartik ko yaad hai kya? Scratch that.. Kartik ko pata bhi hai kya? I have never seen Naira complain to him about his badhtameez family. Never. She has always been helpful, respectful to even those who don't deserve. She tried to mend all his relationships with his family members. Even Shubham. And all she got was.. dhakka.

Naira, pls stop bothering that family. They'll next blame you for Mansi's pregnancy fiasco.. later on you will be blamed for cockroach's death in GV. Unko unki duniya mein khush rehne do behan. Maaf kardo unko.

But the point is.. CVs are in love with Kartik. They will not make him apologize for anything. They will prove Naira wrong every time... will create situations where only she will be blamed and she will eventually end up saying sorry. All this.. Kartik is husband goals has gotten in their heads badly. They can't seem to think beyond Kartik at the moment.. you can see it in little scenes and shots.. it's always how Kartik is sad, broken, hurt.. Naira is just a zinda laash. She just curses her life. What have they made her 🤢
There is no balance anymore. It's just how good and amazing Kartik is and how flawed Naira is.
They've taken the story to a point where as a viewer I don't want them together.
Pls.. alag raho.. but khush raho. Stop crying for god's sake


I would have understood his inability to forgive Naira if Karthik considered Naira responsible for Shubham's death after getting Mansi punished for causing Akshara's accident...after seeking apology from Singhanias before proceeding towards marriage rituals...if he still acknowledged Naira's ability to forgive his sister and his weakness not being able to forgive and let go...but he did none of these...Naira will now be dumb again by hiding Mansi's pregnancy truth...but I believe she owe no explanation to Karthik for hiding any truth after them signing those papers again...Karthik Goenka can never be wrong...he has no shoulder to cry though in one of recent episodes he had Manish's shoulders to cry...even before that he cried hugging KD...Naira is handling it without playing victim means...oh so poor Karthik Goenka...with his deeper pain...guilt...responsibilities...Naira will be dumbest mahan...she will forgive Suwarna mata than Karthik...Writer thinks she is writing a masterpiece in the form of Karthik Goenka...who expect his wife to forgive his sister and can't forgive same person when according to him she killed his brother...In real life nobody would wish a husband like Karthik...who is a hypocrite...at present
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".