Just for argument...

Page

Next Last

vellainsaan

@vellainsaan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

I have a question. Please forget the precap.. and for argument sake only...

Today Naira knows about Kartik's drinking habit. He is sloshed.

Should she taking him home to Dadi? Or Should she take him to her own flat?

Should she inform his family about his drinking habit or not?

I'm asking this because.. I found an eerie similarity...

Naira got to know about Shubham's drug addiction. Shubham begged for ONE day.. he took over dose and died. Kartik and his family blames her for his death.

Here Kartik has become an alcoholic. Should she tell his family about his addiction.. or she should trust Karitk that he won't kill himself unintentionally by over drinking and coming in front of a bus?

Quote

Frequent Posters

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Informing Suwarna mata means same torturous repetitive monologues "mera bacha" and "tumhari tabiyat toh theek hai Karthik" "Main abhi Mumbai aa rahi hoon" for 100th time...

Informing Manish means " Naira beta ab tum hi mere bete ko bacha sakti ho main ye responsibility tumhe deta hoon until I pacify my wifey dear"

Informing KD means "Direct Heart Attack or She will try to commit suicide in her subconcious the way she did during Low fertility track "

Informing Chachi means " Didi dekh liya apne ap apne doosre bete ko bhi nahin sambhal payin"

Informing Akhilesh means " Karthik mujhe tumse ye umeed nahin thi..stops"

He has a family? Sadly he doesn't have one...Naira was his family...and she united him with his family...there were times when he wanted to break ties with them during Flat track, Soumya's death track or Raghav track...but she didn't let him...sadly he preferred his grief and his so called mother's grief over his entire family and his first priority which has always been Naira...she became his life and his wife first than he acknowledged mata as his mother...sadly he could only see the pain of Suwarna mata and assumed things...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

AnyaRSingh

@AnyaRSingh

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom
Informing Suwarna mata means same torturous repetitive monologues "mera bacha" and "tumhari tabiyat toh theek hai Karthik" "Main abhi Mumbai aa rahi hoon" for 100th time...
Informing Manish means " Naira beta ab tum hi mere bete ko bacha sakti ho main ye responsibility tumhe deta hoon until I pacify my wifey dear"
Informing KD means "Direct Heart Attack or She will try to commit suicide in her subconcious the way she did during Low fertility track "
Informing Chachi means " Didi dekh liya apne ap apne doosre bete ko bhi nahin sambhal payin"
Informing Akhilesh means " Karthik mujhe tumse ye umeed nahin thi..stops"

He has a family? Sadly he doesn't have one...Naira was his family...and she united him with his family...there were times when he wanted to break ties with them during Flat track, Soumya's death track or Raghav track...but she didn't let him...sadly he preferred his grief and his so called mother's grief over his entire family and his first priority which has always been Naira...she became his life and his wife first than he acknowledged mata as his mother...sadly he could only see the pain of Suwarna mata and assumed things...

Sad but true naira is his life.

The goenkas may have him with them but his not really with them. And they only cared about the fact that they had him hence it took them two years to do something.

I feel sickened by them honestly

they blame naira for giving shubham 1 day yet it took them two years to notice or do something for kartik.

I honestly feel so depressed seeing kartik like dis my heart wants to cry...

Quote

Yourway

@Yourway

Beginner

Posted: 7 years ago

When you put it that way I guess the logical thing would be to inform anyone from the family. Considering similar situations led to disaster. And now I feel it would have made a great point as well.

Quote

vellainsaan

@vellainsaan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom
Informing Suwarna mata means same torturous repetitive monologues "mera bacha" and "tumhari tabiyat toh theek hai Karthik" "Main abhi Mumbai aa rahi hoon" for 100th time...
Informing Manish means " Naira beta ab tum hi mere bete ko bacha sakti ho main ye responsibility tumhe deta hoon until I pacify my wifey dear"
Informing KD means "Direct Heart Attack or She will try to commit suicide in her subconcious the way she did during Low fertility track "
Informing Chachi means " Didi dekh liya apne ap apne doosre bete ko bhi nahin sambhal payin"
Informing Akhilesh means " Karthik mujhe tumse ye umeed nahin thi..stops"

He has a family? Sadly he doesn't have one...Naira was his family...and she united him with his family...there were times when he wanted to break ties with them during Flat track, Soumya's death track or Raghav track...but she didn't let him...sadly he preferred his grief and his so called mother's grief over his entire family and his first priority which has always been Naira...she became his life and his wife first than he acknowledged mata as his mother...sadly he could only see the pain of Suwarna mata and assumed things...

And two years time isn't enough to open his mind and try to figure out things... IF at all he wants Naira in his life.. What efforts did he make? Scratch that... we know nothing about 2 yrs.. what efforts did he take to even listen to her NOW... once??!!

Then why does he drowns himself in alcohol and cries and cribs.. ? Jo baat hosh mein nahi bol sakte .. nashe mein bolke kya milega?

If they had given this drinking problem to Naira.. everyone would have been up in arms.. phir kisi ko character ka "dukh" ya achha performance nahi dikhta... sab sabskaar baantne aa jaate 😆

Anyway.. they are just dragging it with stupid screenplay like MMS tracks.. otherwise there was so much to show... in a proper balanced manner

Why do I feel tomorrow Dadi will reprimand Naira for taking Kartik to her flat.🥱

Quote

vellainsaan

@vellainsaan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: Yourway
When you put it that way I guess the logical thing would be to inform anyone from the family. Considering similar situations led to disaster. And now I feel it would have made a great point as well.

Right? Logically .. he stays with Dadi right now.. that's the first thing Naira should do. Inform Dadi. She will be waiting for her grandson whole night (if they show him spending the entire night in Naira's flat). So so wrong to scare an elderly like that. That too when they are alone at home waiting for you.

So if something bad happens to Kartik thanks to his drinking habit.. the entire family will kill Naira.. oh u knew.. u didn't tell us... and if she tells dadi now about his drinking.. Kartik will probably kill her first. 😆

Please tell me.. how can she get out of this situation without being called an insensitive heartless person?????

Ridiculous is the word for this blame game.. more I think about it.. more I get angry on that madcap family.

Quote

CaptiveFreedom

@CaptiveFreedom

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Knowing Naira...I don't think she will inform KD...so writers can keep viewers glued to see Kaira's moments in Karthik's inebriated state and give us Singhanias overly sweet dialogues...tbh I liked KD today after long time...them deciding to stay together should be their choice liking that she is not anti-Kaira and still leaving the choice on Karthik...there milan shouldn't be forced one from either side...maybe KD see them together and assume that they want to be together...

Quote

parvs

@parvs

Rocker

+ 3

Team Armaan (Gen 4)

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom
Informing Suwarna mata means same torturous repetitive monologues "mera bacha" and "tumhari tabiyat toh theek hai Karthik" "Main abhi Mumbai aa rahi hoon" for 100th time...
Informing Manish means " Naira beta ab tum hi mere bete ko bacha sakti ho main ye responsibility tumhe deta hoon until I pacify my wifey dear"
Informing KD means "Direct Heart Attack or She will try to commit suicide in her subconcious the way she did during Low fertility track "
Informing Chachi means " Didi dekh liya apne ap apne doosre bete ko bhi nahin sambhal payin"
Informing Akhilesh means " Karthik mujhe tumse ye umeed nahin thi..stops"

He has a family? Sadly he doesn't have one...Naira was his family...and she united him with his family...there were times when he wanted to break ties with them during Flat track, Soumya's death track or Raghav track...but she didn't let him...sadly he preferred his grief and his so called mother's grief over his entire family and his first priority which has always been Naira...she became his life and his wife first than he acknowledged mata as his mother...sadly he could only see the pain of Suwarna mata and assumed things...

you worded it exactly how the goenkas will react... but swarnas comment will probably end with something like "yeh tumhari wajha se hua hai naira... tumne mere bete kay saath yeh kiya" and whatever other nonsense she comes up with because like everyone has been saying on the forum she is mother india and can never be wrong

and totally agree about the family thing for kartik... naira has always been his family... understood him better than any of them and was there for him... but like you said he only chose to see swarnas pain whom he acknowledged only for a few months and ignore naira whom he had fallen head over heels in love with for who knows how long

Quote

parvs

@parvs

Rocker

+ 3

Team Armaan (Gen 4)

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom
Knowing Naira...I don't think she will inform KD...so writers can keep viewers glued to see Kaira's moments in Karthik's inebriated state and give us Singhanias overly sweet dialogues...tbh I liked KD today after long time...them deciding to stay together should be their choice liking that she is not anti-Kaira and still leaving the choice on Karthik...there milan shouldn't be forced one from either side...maybe KD see them together and assume that they want to be together...

maybe she is the person who knocked on nairas door to ask her if she has seen kartik.. and if she knows kartik is there it can go 2 ways... either its a wake up call that they need to be together or her famous dialogue of " log kya kahenge" for naira to be with kartik like that since no one knows shes married to him

agree with what you say about them being together is their choice but i still found dadi to be a bit selfish though... only wanting naira in kartiks life if it makes him happy... what if naira doesnt want to be in his life? anyone consider her feelings? he kicked her out so maybe she doesnt want to be insulted every few months and thrown out like yesterdays trash

i couldnt watch the singhanias and naksh sulking... i cringe every time naksh acts like a child... those few minutes were like dragging had to forward to get to kaira scenes 😆

Quote

vellainsaan

@vellainsaan

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom
Knowing Naira...I don't think she will inform KD...so writers can keep viewers glued to see Kaira's moments in Karthik's inebriated state and give us Singhanias overly sweet dialogues...tbh I liked KD today after long time...them deciding to stay together should be their choice liking that she is not anti-Kaira and still leaving the choice on Karthik...there milan shouldn't be forced one from either side...maybe KD see them together and assume that they want to be together...

She won't inform, but Dadi will def get to know about him spending the night there. So. Let's see what insults Naira gets tomorrow 😆

Oh man if they don't give us a proper milan this time..😵 it should be just them.. just these two and no one else. To be honest the conclusion for joru ka ghulam track was so crap that my hopes are in negative for this one 😆

Quote

1 2

Just for argument...

Related Topics

Explore Topics