Who is at fault? Naira? Kartik? Or leap?

kaira101 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Ever since the news of the leap did rounds before being shown on screen the million dollar question was why?? Then came the news of Shubhams death due to drug over dose or whatever. All seemed really rushed given the dark cloud looming over the cvs to revamp the show by introducing a leap of controversial amount of years (5, which then came down to 2).
Pre-leap: Shubhams downfall
So basically after his 3 day love story terminated after being engaged to the girl he claimed to have loved he went into depression. Simultaneously in this whole fiasco it was the cvs idea to parallel the psycho obsessvive stalker with shubhams depression. Not once did swarna or the goenka clan for once regard shubhams changed behaviour. Kabeer became the issue and then to top the issue cvs needed to give screen space to keesh through the miscarriage of keerti. Quite unnecessary since already there was too much happening at the same time.

Kabeer gets caught red handed and is given an apt or rather arguably controversial punishment for his deeds. Amidst all this shubham is ignored once again and vengeance for the daughter and daughter in law is highlighted.

Kabeer provoked shubham to take drugs. Not one individual understood that he was acting odd however Kartik understoof nannu was taking drugs but in this case he had no clue. Again the cvs are at fault for their characters undergoing amnesia. Coming to Swarna, 'mother' who backed out from all her duties ever since Naira came into the picture. This wasnt the first time Swarna put all responsibility on Naira and then blamed her. How can Naira help Shubham alone. All shubham wanted all his life was to be loved. When after so many years he found his family he could not accept them straight away given the circumstances his so called mother put him in all those years. Now all of a sudden her my jawan beta died rant sounds so meaningless. The untimely death of shubham is once again tge cvs call to adapt to what the channel wanted hence the rushed separation between the leads as a result the family.

Birthday and death day
Naira finding out about shubhams drug addiction should have confided in the family or atleast kartik. This is a mistake she commits in a repitive manner. Again the fault of the cvs to move the story ahead. However all she tried to do was to keep a promise. She was the only one who tried to make shubham feel loved and understood. But what did the Goenkas do? They put all responsibility on naira claiming that shubham listens tp her only. Where did that come from? Shubham knew that naira wasnt one to keep mum regarding his drug addiction thus he made her promise to not disclose the matter since he would. Again the cvs played their trump card to make naira the punching bag because let's face it kartik would not be blamed of he hid about shubhams drug addiction. End result shubham died. Reason doctors stupidity since they needed a girl to tell them yes he took drugs. Cos as far as the story showed shubham barely knew what drugs he took so how the hell would naira know? This death resulted in the gclan again berating naira and kartik telling naira to leave for the moment and her telling him I am waiting for you on the terrace.

The ever so dreaded leap
Ok so basically leap happens and we see Naira becoming this silent person who has no say left in anything. A bubbly girl has now gone into a shell. Likewise Kartik a happy go lucky guy has turned into this angry young man who cant stand anything related to the girl who was his life. With the leap came a thousand questions and loop holes which all needed answering. Eveything changed. The equation between the two families, individuals and even swarna took dadis kittu loving to a whole other level with mera beta. However what didnt change was the fact that these two loggerheads needed each other more than anything.

The most anticipated meet
So finally audience gets to see the meet of the century. A couple who has never held hatred towards each other is now angry at seeing each other. As much as they tried running away from each other destiny decided to bring them face to face. And thus they meet after countless number of hits and missess they meet only to bring back the painfull memories which led to this separation.

Flashbacks galore
So far most of the flashbacks have been Naira's perspective. Her confrontation with swarna, her injury, her seeking out kartik. Everything resulted in her saying you never came. Whilst she claimed that she was trying to move on kartik believes that he is still stuck there waiting for her (like he expressed to the dog). Yesterday's flashback seemed to have broken a lot of peoples understanding of kartiks perspective. The I hate yous said by both seems to be due to heat of the moment and quite forced by cvs if you ask me. Coming to the flashback I am left confused as to what kartik meant by you just left. He did tell her he doesnt care if she leaves. So did he expect her to stay back for a while until things calmed down. There seems to be another loophole in this flashback. A part of me wants there to be more because it doesnt make sense that if the separation was mutual then where was the misunderstanding. Naira did hide so she is at fault likewise kartik blaming naira for running away and moving on and shubhams death is wrong.

My point in all this is that both are at fault. No one less than the other or more than the other. Both are equally at fault. Both need to hear each other out. Dont know how bringing dadi is going to pan out given dadi is the only consistent character in these two years (naira ne kiya hai crap). According to me dadi cant allow anyone to beat her in terms of blaming naira. Hence she left gclan. She couldn't bear that swarna hates naira more.

Hoepfully the cvs justify this flashback otherwise the milan will seem out of place.

P.s sorry for the long post


Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

4.2k

Users

7

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Yes there is no room for any misunderstanding ..It's.not a misunderstanding but their decision to live without each other ..I still see kartik's fault only post the leap and after naira left..He couldn't move on, that's not his mistake but he can't see naira living a normal life, trying to live a normal life , that irks me..two, him not giving naira a fair chance , not forgiving her ...Because if it was anyone in naira's place, say mansi or any goenka, they wouldn't be disowned like this...Would they? A dil has a maayka so she can be thrown out whenever convenient is the moral of the story . The whole family pressurized manish to forgive suvarna for hiding shubham's identity ..They tried to hide Mansi's crime of killing akshara ..Every time it has to be naira who should get out ..A wrong message being sent out by the cvs

Anyways it's gonna be the same naira same kartik same past same problems same shubham's death behind them, same suvarna..When their "milan" will happen ...
kaira101 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: _charu_

Yes there is no room for any misunderstanding ..It's.not a misunderstanding but their decision to live without each other ..I still see kartik's fault only post the leap and after naira left..He couldn't move on, that's not his mistake but he can't see naira living a normal life, trying to live a normal life , that irks me..two, him not giving naira a fair chance , not forgiving her ...Because if it was anyone in naira's place, say mansi or any goenka, they wouldn't be disowned like this...Would they? A dil has a maayka so she can be thrown out whenever convenient is the moral of the story . The whole family pressurized manish to forgive suvarna for hiding shubham's identity ..They tried to hide Mansi's crime of killing akshara ..Every time it has to be naira who should get out ..A wrong message being sent out by the cvs

Anyways it's gonna be the same naira same kartik same past same problems same shubham's death behind them, same suvarna..When their "milan" will happen ...


Yes Kartik needs to be given proper dialogues. Currently his perspective makes no sense. I still believe there is more to the flashback. As for blame game well as I said earlier naira being blamed was easier than blaming kartik according to cvs
vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: _charu_

Yes there is no room for any misunderstanding ..It's.not a misunderstanding but their decision to live without each other ..I still see kartik's fault only post the leap and after naira left..He couldn't move on, that's not his mistake but he can't see naira living a normal life, trying to live a normal life , that irks me..two, him not giving naira a fair chance , not forgiving her ...Because if it was anyone in naira's place, say mansi or any goenka, they wouldn't be disowned like this...Would they? A dil has a maayka so she can be thrown out whenever convenient is the moral of the story . The whole family pressurized manish to forgive suvarna for hiding shubham's identity ..They tried to hide Mansi's crime of killing akshara ..Every time it has to be naira who should get out ..A wrong message being sent out by the cvs

Anyways it's gonna be the same naira same kartik same past same problems same shubham's death behind them, same suvarna..When their "milan" will happen ...



@bold : This is the worst part of Indian TV shows.. DIL is thrown out of the house as and when one wishes.. own blood will be saved at any cost even if he/she is a criminal...Nice 👏

Post leap Kartik's character has become crazy.. there is no connection between his talks, wants or actions.. I keep saying this.. but seriously.. kuch bhi dikha rahe hain Kartik ko.
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
I am team naira after ydays episode soul-ly because kartik claims naira just left him. And never came back. He kicked her out trice so what right does he have to be angry at her for moving away and changing. NO RIGHT
I was neutral before yesterdays episode as i felt both of their expectations were unrealistic but it truely is naira expects him freshly after his brother died to listen to her excuses while he expects naira to lie down on the floor while he walks all over her.
Coming to right now.
Kartik needs to wake up. And the only way he can realise what he lost is if someone tries to take naira away from him when that happens he will wake up from his funk and see the bigger picture
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I am team naira after ydays episode soul-ly because kartik claims naira just left him. And never came back. He kicked her out trice so what right does he have to be angry at her for moving away and changing. NO RIGHT

I was neutral before yesterdays episode as i felt both of their expectations were unrealistic but it truely is naira expects him freshly after his brother died to listen to her excuses while he expects naira to lie down on the floor while he walks all over her.
Coming to right now.
Kartik needs to wake up. And the only way he can realise what he lost is if someone tries to take naira away from him when that happens he will wake up from his funk and see the bigger picture


A third angle will not work imo..Naira is still married to kartik and they won't show her close to anyone else ..But yes, they can Introduce a genuine character who is a true friend of naira ..Girl or a boy...Moreover boys falling for naira is overdone in the show..
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: _charu_


A third angle will not work imo..Naira is still married to kartik and they won't show her close to anyone else ..But yes, they can Introduce a genuine character who is a true friend of naira ..Girl or a boy...Moreover boys falling for naira is overdone in the show..

I think it would work because firstly all the other characters falling or causing harm towards naira have never really sparked jealousy out of kartik maybe kiran but he had no feelings for naira so it was moot point there. (most of the other guys were more brought in to show nari shakti)

If someone was to fall in love with naira and accept her with all her flaws even if she did not reciprocate those feelings would shake kartiks world.

He is comfortable thinking of 101 ways naira wronged him but imagine how he will feel when someone else is in love with her and promises to make her happy.
Or asks for space in her life. and clearly points out he (kartik) never deserved her...

It would destroy him. And i would love to watch it😆

sonal36 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I think it would work because firstly all the other characters falling or causing harm towards naira have never really sparked jealousy out of kartik maybe kiran but he had no feelings for naira so it was moot point there. (most of the other guys were more brought in to show nari shakti)

If someone was to fall in love with naira and accept her with all her flaws even if she did not reciprocate those feelings would shake kartiks world.

He is comfortable thinking of 101 ways naira wronged him but imagine how he will feel when someone else is in love with her and promises to make her happy.
Or asks for space in her life. and clearly points out he (kartik) never deserved her...

It would destroy him. And i would love to watch it😆


Exactly!!!!! I would love to see that..
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I think it would work because firstly all the other characters falling or causing harm towards naira have never really sparked jealousy out of kartik maybe kiran but he had no feelings for naira so it was moot point there. (most of the other guys were more brought in to show nari shakti)

If someone was to fall in love with naira and accept her with all her flaws even if she did not reciprocate those feelings would shake kartiks world.

He is comfortable thinking of 101 ways naira wronged him but imagine how he will feel when someone else is in love with her and promises to make her happy.
Or asks for space in her life. and clearly points out he (kartik) never deserved her...

It would destroy him. And i would love to watch it😆


I am so up for this and it makes sense considering how karthik has treated naira in this track and how he is claiming he no longer loves her. This would be needed to make him realise that he is kidding himself if he thinks he hates her or doesn't love her anymore. Plus guys falling for naira has not even happened yet. Kiran had no feelings for naira, and karthik was merely jealous seeing naira dance with him and felt insecure. Kabeer was a stalker creep, and karthik was never jealous of him. There was that guy before kabeer who tried to kill naira, but he never had feelings for naira and was only there to blackmail her for revenge and made karthik believe he and naira were in love in rishikesh, but again the guy was never in love with her, and it was never really a jealousy track. So where have we had a track with a guy falling for naira and vying for her attention that made karthik insecure? Never! I really want this track to happen, especially after swarna gets to know about naira-karthik meeting again and taking karthik away. This track could help karthik realise he still loves naira and hasn't forgotten her. But I really don't want that guy to be that weird neighbour of naira. He doesn't look like a love interest type guy who would make karthik envious. It has to be a cool and romantic guy.
Edited by sammy17 - 7 years ago
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sammy17


I am so up for this and it makes sense considering how karthik has treated naira in this track and how he is claiming he no longer loves her. This would be needed to make him realise that he is kidding himself if he thinks he hates her or doesn't love her anymore. Plus guys falling for naira has not even happened yet. Kiran had no feelings for naira, and karthik was merely jealous seeing naira dance with him and felt insecure. Kabeer was a stalker creep, and karthik was never jealous of him. There was that guy before kabeer who tried to kill naira, but he never had feelings for naira and was only there to blackmail her for revenge and made karthik believe he and naira were in love in rishikesh, but again the guy was never in love with her, and it was never really a jealousy track. So where have we had a track with a guy falling for naira and vying for her attention that made karthik insecure? Never! I really want this track to happen, especially after swarna gets to know about naira-karthik meeting again and taking karthik away. This track could help karthik realise he still loves naira and hasn't forgotten her. But I really don't want that guy to be that weird neighbour of naira. He doesn't look like a love interest type guy who would make karthik envious. It has to be a cool and romantic guy.


I can so picture this in my head its raining and kartik comes home after seeing this guy talking about proposing to naira the next day. The guys words keep ringing in his head.
He is drenched from head to toe and suvarna is in the middle of his flat packing his shit.
Saying i have packed all you things almost we will leave tomorrow morning.
And he doesnt even really listen to her he just goes to his room. Where he sits near the wall and starts throwing a tenis ball back and front and every type he throws it harder when he thinks about the other guy near naira. Suvarana from the other side thinks oh after tomorrow they will be back home and she will never let kartik near naira again.
While kartik does not sleep the entire night
Kartik watches naira from below while she is on the balcony. He waits in some corner for naira who is all dressed to go meet (maybe keerthi came to visit) but kartik thinks she is going to see that guy.
Naira almost walks past but he grabs her arm Naira is already pissed (as syko suvarna told her to stay away from him or something so she pulls away from him)
she says she is late to go meet someone and he thinks its the other guy. He tells her that she is still married to him. And she is like W*F and says it doesnt matter
anymore coz theyr not together
which just makes him more mad. Naira pulls away to leave but her phone rings keerti tells her they cannt meet naira is like ok and turns to back up kartik is relieved watching her. kartik watches her go to her apartment.

I also want this scene where kartik is going to stop naira from being with the other guy and suvarna tells him not to go but to go home with her. And he pulls his arm away and walks out.
😆to follow naira
Edited by AnyaRSingh - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: madhuvan

3 months ago

Is Maira being made trouble maker for her future sister Naira?

Getting a feeling this time Legacy FL child will ne negative itself rather than the side or 3rd angle. Maira is too much of trouble maker. This...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

3 months ago

Maira Naira Daksh Naksh - - Makes sense?

not my idea... Bass instagram par dekha and thoda sensible laga... https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Shinning_AD

3 months ago

Is Abhira at fault?

If Pookie is really not being found after this incident, do you hold Abhira responsible?

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

These 2 Actors Finalized For YRKKH Gen Leap!!!!

These 2 Actors Roped In For Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Generation Leap!! Namit Shah, who is best known for playing Kabir in the Disney Channel's...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

YRKKH to take a generation leap!!!

StarPlus Directors Kut Productions start preparation for the next generation leap!! Drop whom you want as new leads!!!

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".