Why Keerti not talking with Manish?

-Lakk- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
This is a big question in my mind. I could understand Keerti's
misunderstandings with Suwarna because she dosent wants Kaira to be together again and Keerti thinks the other way round but why she broke relationships with Manish , Akhil or Sulekha..Even they want Kaira to be together like Keerti so why? Knowing she is her daughter..Keerti dosnet even inform them that Naira and Naitik are in Mumbai. They are just showing whole Goenkas against Singhanias without any valid reason.

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

2.5k

Users

5

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Yup..The bottom line..Without any valid reason . The world goes. By the principle of cause and effect ..But in yr it's only effect, no cause
Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago
Apple_Amber thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I guess it all happened on the funeral time/prayer meet. Niara disappeared for Karthik coz she met with an accident. Karthik could not see her falling and he left with other males, while Suwarna got to know about it. She sent Niara to Singhaniyas from hospital may be and they too miss one or two rites as they were ttending Niara.

Singhaniyas witnessed Naira's physical and mental misery, came at Karthik's place to be part of their sorrow and to make them aware of Naira's current state to Karthik and others. But suwarna in her hysterical state did not let it happen and Karthik never got to know that why Naira went absent in tough times.

Then Suwarna gave her ill famous decision that Naira can't return back to Goyenka Villa. May be she took Karthik in confidence or emotionally blackmailed him to support her decision of throwing Niara.

Karthik never bothered to confirm the facts from n injured/unfit Naira much to the shock of Singhaniyas and keerti and Niara felt cheated after knowing it all that Karthik has no trust left for her and didn't not offer any clarification this time.

First Naksh broke ties with them followed by Keerti who took stand for Naira and told them that she will never ever keep any relation with Goyenkas if they throw Niara out but Suwarna was adamant and Karthik in his aggressive and puppet mode never bothered and let it be. Plus he complied with Suwarna's every order coz he wanted to payback her for his mistreatment of her since his childhood.

So basically I guess Suwarna played a vamp in any which way!

She either asked Naira to leave Karthik if she needs Forgiveness from her!
or She hid Naira's accident from Karthik to let him misunderstand Niara in response to Naira hiding Shubham's drug matter.

Thats not any spoiler just my assumption.

Am reminded of conjecture before Parul's entry in the show that her character is negative and she will play a vampish step mom. Well it was not supposed to be but finally cvz did it.
Parul is a great actor and I find her pretty too! And She is also a great dancer!

Can't call her step mom because she did no good to her own born too! Forget Keerti and karthik!


Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Apple_Amber

I guess it all happened on the funeral time/prayer meet. Niara disappeared for Karthik coz she met with an accident. Karthik could not see her falling and he left with other males, while Suwarna got to know about it. She sent Niara to Singhaniyas from hospital may be and they too miss one or two rites as they were ttending Niara.

Singhaniyas witnessed Naira's physical and mental misery, came at Karthik's place to be part of their sorrow and to make them aware of Naira's current state to Karthik and others. But suwarna in her hysterical state did not let it happen and Karthik never got to know that why Naira went absent in tough times.

Then Suwarna gave her ill famous decision that Naira can't return back to Goyenka Villa. May be she took Karthik in confidence or emotionally blackmailed him to support her decision of throwing Niara.

Karthik never bothered to confirm the facts from n injured/unfit Naira much to the shock of Singhaniyas and keerti and Niara felt cheated after knowing it all that Karthik has no trust left for her and didn't not offer any clarification this time.

First Naksh broke ties with them followed by Keerti who took stand for Naira and told them that she will never ever keep any relation with Goyenkas if they throw Niara out but Suwarna was adamant and Karthik in his aggressive and puppet mode never bothered and let it be. Plus he complied with Suwarna's every order coz he wanted to payback her for his mistreatment of her since his childhood.

So basically I guess Suwarna played a vamp in any which way!

She either asked Naira to leave Karthik if she needs Forgiveness from her!
or She hid Naira's accident from Karthik to let him misunderstand Niara in response to Naira hiding Shubham's drug matter.

Thats not any spoiler just my assumption.

Am reminded of conjecture before Parul's entry in the show that her character is negative and she will play a vampish step mom. Well it was not supposed to be but finally cvz did it.
Parul is a great actor and I find her pretty too! And She is also a great dancer!

Can't call her step mom because she did no good to her own born too! Forget Keerti and karthik!



You're right! Something extra must have happened between naira falling right at the end before leap and when 2 year leap happened. I have a feeling something happened to cause a further misunderstanding with karthik about naira's absence, and naira being upset/ feeling karthik failed her. Let's wait and see what happened, but the way suwarna is cutting off all connections and means of dialogue/ interaction between goenka's/ karthik with the singhania's, perhaps suwarna has a hand in naira and karthik's distances having grown to the point of karthik hating naira so much he doesn't want to hear her name, because stupidly, after kicking out of the house in anger, he later was surprised and upset that she did leave, so something must have happened that karthik hates her so much.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sammy17


You're right! Something extra must have happened between naira falling right at the end before leap and when 2 year leap happened. I have a feeling something happened to cause a further misunderstanding with karthik about naira's absence, and naira being upset/ feeling karthik failed her. Let's wait and see what happened, but the way suwarna is cutting off all connections and means of dialogue/ interaction between goenka's/ karthik with the singhania's, perhaps suwarna has a hand in naira and karthik's distances having grown to the point of karthik hating naira so much he doesn't want to hear her name, because stupidly, after kicking out of the house in anger, he later was surprised and upset that she did leave, so something must have happened that karthik hates her so much.


He hates her? It's anything but hate, what he is displaying 😛


Everyone wants to see them together except "ma" toh obviously she is responsible for the forced separation..What made kartik to please her to this extent?


Anyways full marks to suvarna mata..If tomorrow she has a child who she has to hide from manish, she will repeat the same mistake ..Kartik is doing just what shubham did, difference being drugs and alcohol , and concealing it from mata but she being the best mom can't see beyond what she wants to see..And of course nothing can happen to kartik..Uski paro bhi mil jayegi..Suhana aunty toh jail mein hogi😆
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: _charu_


He hates her? It's anything but hate, what he is displaying 😛


Everyone wants to see them together except "ma" toh obviously she is responsible for the forced separation..What made kartik to please her to this extent?


Anyways full marks to suvarna mata..If tomorrow she has a child who she has to hide from manish, she will repeat the same mistake ..Kartik is doing just what shubham did, difference being drugs and alcohol , and concealing it from mata but she being the best mom can't see beyond what she wants to see..And of course nothing can happen to kartik..Uski paro bhi mil jayegi..Suhana aunty toh jail mein hogi😆


@bold Karthik always prioritized Naira over his family...for him Naira had always been more important except during Naksh and Keerti's marriage...afterwards for prioritizing Naira his wife over other relationships he was termed "joru ka gulam"...during Raghav's track he was willing to stay away from Goenkas...during Keerti's miscarriage scenario he trusted Naira...but Shubham's death was major shocker for him...he starting sharing an overwhelming bond with his brother and lost him forever...Maybe he sympathize with Suwarna mata who lost her son and have him only as her son...did she ever had any daughter? ...
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: _charu_


He hates her? It's anything but hate, what he is displaying 😛


Everyone wants to see them together except "ma" toh obviously she is responsible for the forced separation..What made kartik to please her to this extent?


Anyways full marks to suvarna mata..If tomorrow she has a child who she has to hide from manish, she will repeat the same mistake ..Kartik is doing just what shubham did, difference being drugs and alcohol , and concealing it from mata but she being the best mom can't see beyond what she wants to see..And of course nothing can happen to kartik..Uski paro bhi mil jayegi..Suhana aunty toh jail mein hogi😆


@Bold- Remember, where there is hate, there is love. We hate those who we love and consider our own. So, considering how much hate he is showing for naira whilst imagining and thinking about her then getting mad at himself for thinking about her, he loves her like crazy even now.
Edited by sammy17 - 7 years ago
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


@bold Karthik always prioritized Naira over his family...for him Naira had always been more important except during Naksh and Keerti's marriage...afterwards for prioritizing Naira his wife over other relationships he was termed "joru ka gulam"...during Raghav's track he was willing to stay away from Goenkas...during Keerti's miscarriage scenario he trusted Naira...but Shubham's death was major shocker for him...he starting sharing an overwhelming bond with his brother and lost him forever...Maybe he sympathize with Suwarna mata who lost her son and have him only as her son...did she ever had any daughter? ...


It was dadi who called him jkg, I never had a problem with him prioritizing naira over his family, I said it that they shouldn't bother themselves with all this...And if he did it always and not doing now he is acting out of character ? You mean to say if ge found new love in shubham and suvarna, naira should step down from the pedestal ? Till the time naira was acting like a donkey serving his family, she was good but if she did a mistake , his mother abandons her , he loses touch with her he couldn't see beyond his and his mother's pain..When in love you do expect , kartik expected naira to be upfront but naira also expected something from kartik..He failed as a husband .
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: _charu_


It was dadi who called him jkg, I never had a problem with him prioritizing naira over his family, I said it that they shouldn't bother themselves with all this...And if he did it always and not doing now he is acting out of character ? You mean to say if ge found new love in shubham and suvarna, naira should step down from the pedestal ? Till the time naira was acting like a donkey serving his family, she was good but if she did a mistake , his mother abandons her , he loses touch with her he couldn't see beyond his and his mother's pain..When in love you do expect , kartik expected naira to be upfront but naira also expected something from kartik..He failed as a husband .


@bold well I also had no problem in Karthik prioritizing Naira...jkg track was overly stretched and they gave much importance to forced misunderstandings, catalysts etc...regarding Karthik being unable to see beyond his mother's pain...well...CVs yet again forced separation and created this "I hate u like I love u" kindda scenario...or maybe there is something more than feeling "betrayed"...

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

10 days ago

Why why why why

Anshuman's death was unnecessary, they could have gone months further with Abhira-Anshuman bond development....

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

a month ago

Manish Goenka ki zindagi

I was watching old episodes (Akshara's death sequence Gen 1) where both Akshara's (Hina) dadi and Manish Goenka were shown in the same episode....

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

3 months ago

Swarna and Manish should play Kairav and Muskan

They should not play Great Great Great. Swarna is not aging it looks so fake even Baa from Khunki saas still look realistic

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

4 months ago

7 Years leap Confirmed - Will Manish live on?

"It’s getting ridiculous with them now. They should have at least included three Gen cousins in the show—or even second cousins—rather than just...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: MsWhiskerson

4 months ago

Team The Immortal Fossil Manish Goenka - please moderators

https://youtu.be/6WLTaRagAIo?si=r_WHbXytBssEt-yA Manish slapped Abhir and earned my undying support with this Moderators, why is there a team...

https://youtu.be/6WLTaRagAIo?si=r_WHbXytBssEt-yA
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".