Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

4.9k

Users

9

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

Samaina12 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: dumas

Totally agree they behaving like she gave him drugs he died because he took drugs he was stupid .

drug depenance is an illness and u don't blame the patient for it. Naira isn't even school pass probably so lacks common sense and did not tell anybody. Same naira during nannu' sdrug case acted smart and told entire family!
Please similar incidents and same.person naira but here she is so lame in.shubham's caSe.

Naira mahaan devi ki jai!
5646 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
It was once a great show with a lovely couple and good storylines..but now its another joke of Indian Television..so over the top melodrama ..after leap surely Karthik will be a Casanova or self loathing loner and Naira will be a strict business lady and also a single mother..they will hate each other..the same old done to death story repeated for the zillionth time..I gave up watching this show two months back and today after a long time I checked it and it was so bad and changed the channel..
Edited by --Priyaa-- - 7 years ago
ErisedWitch45 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: dumas

Totally agree they behaving like she gave him drugs he died because he took drugs he was stupid .


Seriously!
These Goenkas esp that horrid Suvarna are acting like Naira is responsible for Shubham's death. Her mistake was not telling the family esp Kartik about the grave situation. In hindsight, she should have been more proactive (like she usually is in all tracks).

Suvarna's reaction to Naira was so disgusting (and I am not even a Naira fan). Suvarna is hands down the worst character. If she holds Naira responsible then she should blame herself the most. Coz she was the one who abandoned Shubham. She was the one who spoiled him rotten in the Suhana track, always fulfilling his demands to flatter him. That's not how real affection works. She was just trying to buy his love. (Although I believe Shubham's tragic death is due to his own immaturity, poor decision-making and circumstances. Not coz of any person.)
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: ErisedWitch45


Seriously!
These Goenkas esp that horrid Suvarna are acting like Naira is responsible for Shubham's death. Her mistake was not telling the family esp Kartik about the grave situation. In hindsight, she should have been more proactive (like she usually is in all tracks).

Suvarna's reaction to Naira was so disgusting (and I am not even a Naira fan). Suvarna is hands down the worst character. If she holds Naira responsible then she should blame herself the most. Coz she was the one who abandoned Shubham. She was the one who spoiled him rotten in the Suhana track, always fulfilling his demands to flatter him. That's not how real affection works. She was just trying to buy his love. (Although I believe Shubham's tragic death is due to his own immaturity, poor decision-making and circumstances. Not coz of any person.)


I always hated her...She is the kind of person who never takes any responsibility or doesn't have the confidence and when others do it , she quickly pounces on them and blame them..If she didn't keep shubham away from the family he would be a different person..Suvarna is also responsible for what happened to him ..Suvarna and manish both failed as parents ..


It was.not long back that she was given a bravery badge and she led the nari mukti morcha..She called herself ma but did she act like a mother to naira ? Ladkiyon ko kyun sehna padta hai , chup rehna padta hai..My foot!
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ErisedWitch45


^This. 👍🏼

I have never understood why everyone makes everything Naira's responsibility. The other day, K Dadi was saying the same thing as an excuse against Naira's further education. That if she studies, she won't be able to take responsibilities of the family! W*F? There are a total of 10 people in the house and a truck load of servants. Out of 10 people, at least 4 able bodied non-working people who can also take care of whatever household crap they have. Then why is everything on Naira?

The problem also is for any good thing that happens even any trivial good thing, the credit is always given to her. Always. And hence those people feel it's okay to blame her too. This just sets a disturbing trend and places all the burden of getting everything right on 1 person.

And yeah, Suvarna has always been a crappy character. She is selfish and plain disgusting. 1st she throws away her own son, tells her husband that the child died, keeps everyone in the dark and acts like she has done some mahaan tyaag. Then she spoils Shubham rotten and blames Naira if any small thing goes wrong. (during Suhana track).

Like you said, why is Shubham ONLY Naira's responsibility? Granted even grown ups need care and looking after sometimes esp when they are dealing with trauma, why is she the only one? The rest of the Goenka's just wait for Naira to fix everything so that they can enjoy the good parts. What Shubham needed was support and guidance from the family, not to be treated as an after-thought.

And Naira had many chances to tell Kartik. No matter what she had promised Shubham - drug addiction is not a joke. It's life-ruining. She shouldn't have hidden this from Kartik - the person who have time and again supported her and loves her and trusts her with all his heart. But I guess the cvs are more interested in showing her as an all rounder super woman so that they can do a blame-game track.


@bold I agree Suwarna after abandoning her son got chance to redeem but she can't think beyond shedding thousand buckets and giving gayan on being "maa" when son returns home in inebriated state its parent's responsibility not to ignore his state only because he is "depressed"...when son had been staying with company like Kabir its family's responsibility to keep check on him...when son is depressed its parent's responsibility to spend extra time with him, to encourage him to share his pain...thankfully they showed Karthik taking care of Shubham when their useless parents will be taking care of him...Suvarna's character is most disgusting character...even vamps are better than her they don't have that cloak of "mahanta" and "motherhood"...Naira hid truth of her low fertility for a day (during holi celebration) ultimately she told Karthik about it...here when Shubham was repeatedly asking her to give him a day...she chose to tell another day the way she chose before and later on informed him...BUT drug addiction is lethal...even if it was matter of 24 hrs and she was repeatedly keeping check on him...withdrawal requires assistance of professionals...as she took responsibility not to inform family for 1 day therefore she is held responsible being the only person who saw him taking drugs and chose not to inform Karthik or family...Naira was wrong here...but things could've went right too...she could've told the very next day...and Shubham might not be in state he was due to heavy dosage...regardless of anything, any normal possibility she could've informed Karthik even if it was his birthday..she was at fault..but before her entire Goenka family is responsible for Shubham's state..

@underlined I disagree here...Naira is not a problem solver here she is the one at fault alongwith other characters...her flaws are highlighted...if she was superwoman she could've saved Shubham miraculously...or she shouldn't have herself CHOSEN not to inform family if she was that flawless FL...it would've been circumstances only that didn't let Naira inform Karthik or family but here she chose not to inform even having several chances to inform Karthik atleast so that aspect exclude her from superwoman category...she is the flawed character...we are not use to irresponsible FL...we all including me want FL to act a "certain way"...khair...as the story revolves around Kaira and Goenkas and their changing relationship dynamics...to take it forward they put entire blame on Naira for Keerti's miscarriage and for Shubham's death...the way Karthik was blamed for Ak's death to take story forward...

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

13 days ago

Leap will start in November.

Similar to Gen 4 Maira will grow older being looked after by her Dadi and Bari Dadi but no confirmation regarding who is in the picture Arman or...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

These 2 Actors Finalized For YRKKH Gen Leap!!!!

These 2 Actors Roped In For Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Generation Leap!! Namit Shah, who is best known for playing Kabir in the Disney Channel's...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: imAariz

1 months ago

YRKKH to take a generation leap!!!

StarPlus Directors Kut Productions start preparation for the next generation leap!! Drop whom you want as new leads!!!

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

4 months ago

Which Child leap serverd better?

Portal is open : As well as your options. Generation 4 just started but you know what's gonna happen in future : Mount Abu hit and miss moments,...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Shinning_AD

4 months ago

How is the leap going to happen?

Will Pookie be found first? And then Armaan takes her away and moves away from family after this crazy incident he just saw. He might do that...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".