Originally posted by: rose2015
It surprises me to see so much justification for Karthik's behavior. I don't think his character can be redeemed. In my eyes he failed as a son, brother, and husband.
The excuses presented are not valid reasons for his behavior. There is no justification to be so obnoxious and immature. As a married man he really needs to grow up. I want Naira to give him a hard time and not give in to his apologies so easily.
First he has a temper tantrum, gets violent, and spreads his toxic thoughts and spoils everyone's mood and later he makes a guilty face and looks silly trying to be apologetic.
Later he may apologize but his words and behavior will never be forgotten. Whatever Naksh did he didn't stoop down to the level of Karthik. You can say whatever about Naksh but he would never talk to Keerti in such a manner because he does respect women and he does value his relationship with all people especially Keerti. That is the main difference. Naksh values relationships and Karthik does not.
Naira better give a hard time to Karthik and make him feel remorseful for his behavior. He needs to learn that he needs to change his attitude and behavior otherwise he will forever cause problems with his relationship with Naira and other family members. Just look at Karthik's track record. After that if they show them making up believe me Karthik is going to look so fake. Any romance scenes they show after that are fake because that is not how you behave with your life partner. His relationship with Naira is shown as a love/hate relationship. It is not good to play pingpong in your marriage where you go from anger in one scene and then romance in the next.
Naira teach this guy a lesson that he will remember his whole life. Naira was only trying to fix relationships and mend them while he was so focused on breaking them.
I'm not agreeing or disagreeing with this post, this is a neutral decision. I see where you're coming from and you're right in some ways presented above.
@Bold: I agree with this one as Kartik has anger issues, he received this from Manish. Although Naira didn't make a mistake, she needs to stop ruuning behind Kartik and give herself some space. Yes Kartik needs to be remorseful for his behaviour but also his anger overpowers his relationship with Naira. Anger doesn't solve everything, but coming together and giving your partner a chance to justify themselves, is really important.
@Blue: This is who he is, he is angry bird yet a loving man. He loves Naira very much but is very sensitive when it comes to his sister or mother. It takes a lot of hands and pressure to crack and smooth the angriness that is in his mind. I don't think he failed as a son or brother or as a husband. As a husband yes he misunderstands but he does fulfils some responsibilities as a husband. As a son he was only 5 or more when his mother committed suicide and because of this, he thinks it was because of his father's extra marital affair. How can a 5-8 year old boy understand, he was a little kid who didn't understand. As a brother, he protected his sister, he thinks wisely and thinks better for them. Not once did I ever witness Kartik failing any of those relationships.
He's just a man who is very sensitive, a man who's anger overpowers. and most importantly he loves his family very much.
CID
73