Comment your views on today's episode 10/9/17

Zara151 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Rate the episode out of 10 and also comment the reason why you rated this number.
My rating: 10/10

What I felt about today's special episode:

The beginning of episode consisting of Kartik supporting his wife despite being angry. When it comes to giving shagun to his in-laws, he will cover up the matter and put a smile on his face. Behind a smile there is always a pain that strucks so deep that it can't be shared to loved one's. Him being angry with Naira isn't shown in front of the Singhania's, but when he said goodbye to Naira, at least it did make her smile for one minute. Then we come across Naira running behind Kartik with a glass of water, but Kartik doesn't want to say a word. For him at this moment he needed to be alone. He needed to calm down. Just a minute before he left, Naira's hurt was shown and she asked for one last time if he would be there by her side on the day of teej. And he left straight after saying, "i don't know."
Right there, tears strolling down my face seeing Naira cry helplessly after her beloved Kartik leaving her with no choice. Her tears, she is hurt and she returns back into the house hiding her tears.

Scene 2: Suwarna sticking up for Naira but telling the truth needed to be praised. Just this one time can't happen Suwarna. When Naira gets blamed in your presence and you don't say anything that doesn't help. Just this one time where you support Naira can't happen all the time. A mother needs to speak out in her presence throughout, whether she's there or absent. I liked her saying that Naira isn't just at fault but everyone is.

Kartik coming home with anger and seeing the woman he hates the most standing there to speak, well im sure he doesn't want a word with her. The mother who supports her daughter in law and telling the son who has hatred for her, doesn't have a chance to believe her. The mother who tells her son that Naiar isn't at fault but Kartik tells her to stay out of their relationship and mind her own business. And he leaves but Manish comes into the way.

More tears rolling down my face seeing Naira in this condition and seeing that she had her loves name written in the Mehndi, when will you come Kartik? Yet again a brillian performance by her.

Kartiks tears, he's hurt. Looking at his mother's photograph just tells me that no matter what happens. He's just a sensitive guy who loves his mother beyond everything. I applaud Keerti for consoling and comforting her brother. If you are like this with just one person, why not stay like that in front of everyone. This one time that i like you Keerti, please don't ever remain silent in front of everyone who cries.

The Moh Moh ke dhaage; i have no words to say for this heartwrenching scene. Two lovers who want to be together for their first Sargi, but situations like this makes me sad. Kaira seeing each other not in real but brings the dream sequence last year. Wearing the same outfits, the small smile seeing each other but still, the pain can be depicted. Oh how we see that Kartik thinks why Naira didn't tell the truth to him or why she did this to him. My heart goes out to these two. I can't possibly describe how hard it was to watch this scene. More tears rolling down 😭

I can't explain much further but the last scene says it all. Naira fills her sindoor in his name, her Mehndi, her everything is of his. And him not being there just tears apart. It rips out your whole soul seeing her hurt, in pain and the need of his presence just there by her side. Thank you making me love you, i can't possible describe how much you amazed me with your acting. Fab performance Shivin, keep doing this everyday 👏

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.1k

Users

8

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
The episode was a roller coaster ride.
Kaira not revealing anything infront of Singhanias, just like I expected. They would have not even let the Goenkas know about it, but the snake entry led up to Karthik screaming the truth out. Kaira are people who will always bottle up their pain in front of others. Whether that be Naira after Akshara's death or Karthik after he was released. The only people they showed that pain too was each other. That is the reason why both of them of them are in so much pain today because the other is not understanding their pain and that is hurting them, that is breaking them.

Late but am glad Suvarna did support Naira in front of the family and decided that they must bring the truth in front of Karthik, though I felt her meri beti dialogue did more damage then good.

Honestly I wasn't very impressed by Kirti, she doesn't consider Suvarna Manish wrong, so she definitely knows something more but she has never attempted to fill Karthik's wounds, in all these years and this complaint is not only with Kirti but every member of GV.

10 for the amazing performance
Edited by janvi0513 - 7 years ago
divyasn thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
The episode was comparatively good one , but I have problem with Naira she is such a selfish character ,for her it is all about her ..and only her ..time and again it is the same ...
Does she think about Karthik , what he is going through ? She is worried about her teej getting spoilt and not her husband's pain .. did she even say once I trust you Karthik ...

She always want to do her manmaani and will use her tears and constant Jaap of I love you Karthik , to get her way out

How many times she has misunderstood and hurt Karthik ,how much accusations did she rain upon him and when everything becomes clear - she will go behind I want my karthik back - I love you karthik

In real life , any husband would have ditched and divorced a wife like Naira
.
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
10/10...overall a very well balanced episode with excellent performances ⭐️⭐️⭐️

1. Liked Kaira scene where Kartik behaved normally infront of Singhanias...and the way they teased them was so real specifically liked Ananya...Than Karthik being hurt talked about Naira's reaction during Akshara's case (specifically when Karthik did not caused accident)...Naira wasn't also willing to listen to Karthik during that time...When it comes to your parents specifically mother u become more sensitive...that's the fact..

2. Teej Dream was beautiful ⭐️...what more I liked about it was they talked it out which was pitch perfect according to the situation another good development...After agarbati dream sequence this will be my favorite Kaira dream...Shivin rocked!!...Kaira were in same attire as previous teej dream sequence...

3. Liked that Naira behaved normally with happy expressions infront of her family...Even when she broke down, was still able to handle the situation...Transition in facial expressions was effortless specifically when Naira entered SS after last encounter with Karthik...

3. Suwarna was too good today she spoke infront of KD and Manish that also unapologetically...For the first time Suwarna's character seem stronger and layered than it normally appears to be...Parul was good in all her scenes...

4. Loved the fact that they kept mentioning about Karthik's efforts for Teej preparations and how good he is as a husband...


5. Loved Suwarna-Karthik scene though its outcome wasn't good...but for the first time she directly talked to him...overall impact of scene was good kudos to their performance...afterwards loved Karthik-Manish scene too...again kudos to their performance...


6. Loved Naira's singhar scene where she got ready for teej...with yahan wahan female sad version... after soo long ...missed it...They showed Naira filling her mang for the first time right? Liked Naira's dialogues...also painful little shaky voice of Naira depicted her longing to be with her Karthik...Shivi was too good there...

7. Bad intuitions sometimes turn to reality specifically when u love someone and are away from them...liked that Naira inquired about Karthik's safety and well being from Akhil...

8. Surekha chachi's body language, expressions were positive today infact she unintentionally saved Suwarna from getting scolded...as I criticized her earlier...now when she is better I mentioned that too...

9. Liked Naksh-Naira and Karthik-Keerti scene too...Both sibling scenes were good...


Progress From Story's Perspective
Manish mentioning about Soumya's Promise to conceal the truth from Karthik and Keerti...
Suwarna finally taking a firm stand for Naira...
Suwarna talked about something that will give Karthik answers to all his questions...hinted towards future episodes too...
Karthik's efforts being acknowledged...

Message
Never give lift to strangers specifically during festivals...there are several rackets of robbers who take advantage of people specifically during festivals...
Isolophiliac thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: divyasn

The episode was comparatively good one , but I have problem with Naira she is such a selfish character ,for her it is all about her ..and only her ..time and again it is the same ...

Does she think about Karthik , what he is going through ? She is worried about her teej getting spoilt and not her husband's pain .. did she even say once I trust you Karthik ...

She always want to do her manmaani and will use her tears and constant Jaap of I love you Karthik , to get her way out

How many times she has misunderstood and hurt Karthik ,how much accusations did she rain upon him and when everything becomes clear - she will go behind I want my karthik back - I love you karthik

In real life , any husband would have ditched and divorced a wife like Naira
.

About 'why naira is so desperately trying to solve the issue between kartik and his parents' is because she knows how it feels to misunderstand your parents. She mu akshara and lost 5 of her most important years with her mom and when she came back, after clearing of mu she got a very little time with ak...And the guilt of misunderstanding her was always there..
Maybe she wants kartik to know as early as possible so that he can also understand his parents' love and the guilt will be a little less..
divyasn thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: abi_sanam

About 'why naira is so desperately trying to solve the issue between kartik and his parents' is because she knows how it feels to misunderstand your parents. She mu akshara and lost 5 of her most important years with her mom and when she came back, after clearing of mu she got a very little time with ak...And the guilt of misunderstanding her was always there..
Maybe she wants kartik to know as early as possible so that he can also understand his parents' love and the guilt will be a little less..


Sorry that is all your assumption, nothing like that is being shown in the show ..

Also pre wedding when Karthik told his mom committed suicide due to the extra marital affair .. did she believe that... Leave alone believe , she didn't have even 1% of doubt on Suvarna and Manish -her own family had the history of an e xtra marital affair , she is blind to that ? That is the problem with Naira's character

More than being a wife to Karthik , she wants to dance to Goenkas' tune ... she will misunderstand and torture Karthik for something he didn't even do , but will forgive Goenkas in just a snap if Karthik is out of picture - is that love ?

Seriously is there any development in their marriage except the bedroom romance ... ?

Why their relationship is so weak?



Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#7
@divyasn..There is no single heroine on tellyland who puts her husband above her in laws ..You are expecting too much...😃 this is not how bharatiya nari behaves on tv .
@reg the topic , the episode was good overall..Sorry I didn't like naira's garish make up ..


sigrid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Zara, Janvi and captive freedom, all of you covered the episode and wrote each aspect beautifully.
For me it was 10/10
Mind blowing performances by our Shivin and Parul.👏👏
-beena- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: abi_sanam

About 'why naira is so desperately trying to solve the issue between kartik and his parents' is because she knows how it feels to misunderstand your parents. She mu akshara and lost 5 of her most important years with her mom and when she came back, after clearing of mu she got a very little time with ak...And the guilt of misunderstanding her was always there..
Maybe she wants kartik to know as early as possible so that he can also understand his parents' love and the guilt will be a little less..



^ Absolutely true.Well said. 👏 👏
Naira has gone through the guilt and pain when she realized her mistake of misunderstanding her mother.She doesn't want Kartik to face the same at a time when it may be too late.
In one episode Suvarna was telling Priyanka, she hopes that everything gets fine atleast before she dies.It is better that Kartik faces some pain now than at a time when it is so late that Kartik may have to spent his entire life in guilt.


Edited by -beena- - 7 years ago
divyasn thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: _charu_

@divyasn..There is no single heroine on tellyland who puts her husband above her in laws ..You are expecting too much...😃 this is not how bharatiya nari behaves on tv .

@reg the topic , the episode was good overall..Sorry I didn't like naira's garish make up ..


Akshara is there

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

4 months ago

Charu said the right thing today

What Charu said to Abhir today was absolutely right. When he is hiding the fact that he is having an affair behind Kiara's back then what is the...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

3 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 2, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

10 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 26, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

24 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 12, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

Story Development - Zama Habib, Ghanshyam Bhatt Story Writers/Dialogue: Vaishali Nayak/ Divya Nidhi Sharma and Pankhuri Gangwal/Aparajita Sharma...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

1 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 5, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

Story Development - Zama Habib, Ghanshyam Bhatt Story Writers/Dialogue: Vaishali Nayak/ Divya Nidhi Sharma and Pankhuri Gangwal/Aparajita Sharma...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".