2.3 is lowest from past 9 months!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.8k

Users

12

Likes

109

Frequent Posters

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ShadowImbue

Agreed with all the points you put forth comparisons never went well on indian television. Surekha chachi is truly annoying she was really sweet when she entered but now her character has turned too irritating. How conveniently she forgot that she is indebted to Naira for saving her daughter's life? This same comparison repeatedly makes me change the channel every time it kills the essence of the show.



yess I remember when she entered most of the people considered her sweet positive character but now sadly she has turned vampish 😆 I mean lady you are jealous of a girl half the age of ur character? Even Kekta doesn't do that she do turns positive character negative all of sudden but not the indebted ones...As far as I remmeber Naira directly/indirectly didn't do anything that go against her...therefore showing Surekha against Naira is completely illogical...Surekha getting jealous of Suwarna who is given more importance being the eldest bahu is still understandable...I sooo wish someone reminds her of her daughter who could be in jail...


Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
At least have Singhanias (including Nani) remembering more often that they have a daughter/granddaughter/sister/cousin named Naira, who was (yes am using was because they seem to have forgotten) the life of everyone in that house.

Comparisons are a big no, no. It is not Kaira being compared to some other couple, because they are the leads which is wrong. Instead Kirti Naksh being compared to any couple of yeh rishta is wrong to me since these two aren't in love yet and the other's are and have much better relations, so comparing a non existent relationship with any relationship that has gone through stuff, like we saw how Yash Rose went through all the troubles that took place in their wedding, how Ranveer had first rejected Annanya.

Chachi is not exactly bad, just jealous, at the engagement I didn't mind her that much but then making her repeat the same negativity for the sangeet was the annoying part. Yes totally agree about Dadi coming in chachi's words. Dadi was always a strong opinionated person so it doesn't seem right, but it could be that she is guilty for having let Kirti suffered or make her feel unimportant earlier which led her to suffer silently.

Singhanias aren't mahan and neither are Goenkas really bad ore something, yes they have a bit to learn, but don't we all. I would say Singhanias are like a big tree trunk, which can't be moved a single millimeter by light winds, but can be cracked from between with a strong storm. Like when dadji died, Akshara was accused, she Naitik and children parted from the family. Then Sukanya death leading to Naira leaving. Goenkas are more like reeds, the blow with the slightest breeze but even strong winds cannot do more then blow them to the left or right and then come back once the air is still again. Like Karthik was send away to the hostel, but the family knew where he was. The might have done damad Jaan with creep but when they saw him about to hit Kirti, all stood up for their daughter at once. (Yes Dadi did come in crew's words later on for a while)

Yes character jaap is wrong be it Akshara, Gayu, Naira or Kirti, of course appreciating the person if it is well deserved is fine, but keep on repeating praises like for Singhanias when Akshara sarre were talked about, they forgot Naira is her daughter and has some right but when sangeet came, they came to Naira for work and started singing praises.

Forget marriage track timing, nothing is right about Kirti Naksh track, for me.
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: janvi0513

At least have Singhanias (including Nani) remembering more often that they have a daughter/granddaughter/sister/cousin named Naira, who was (yes am using was because they seem to have forgotten) the life of everyone in that house.

More than remembering her as daughter I want Singhanias scenes with Naira...its high time now...She developed such a unique bond with each one them from Badi dadi (eldest one) to Mishti (youngest one)...Papa-Princess after that N3 and Nani-Naira bond use to be writer's priority...but now the SS members specifically ladies have seemingly forgot their daughter completely...

Comparisons are a big no, no. It is not Kaira being compared to some other couple, because they are the leads which is wrong. Instead Kirti Naksh being compared to any couple of yeh rishta is wrong to me since these two aren't in love yet and the other's are and have much better relations, so comparing a non existent relationship with any relationship that has gone through stuff, like we saw how Yash Rose went through all the troubles that took place in their wedding, how Ranveer had first rejected Annanya.

Exactly! Keesh doesn't exist therefore the roots of comparison aren't there...be it their comparison with any other couple of YR...though CVs tried to develop their chemistry but failed...

Chachi is not exactly bad, just jealous, at the engagement I didn't mind her that much but then making her repeat the same negativity for the sangeet was the annoying part. Yes totally agree about Dadi coming in chachi's words. Dadi was always a strong opinionated person so it doesn't seem right, but it could be that she is guilty for having let Kirti suffered or make her feel unimportant earlier which led her to suffer silently.

The repetitiveness is what annoys the most...she is not evil...but she has developed certain characteristics of an instigating vamp...Its not that the focus is shifted from chachi to Naira...maybe they could've developed a base of chachi getting jealous of Naira because KD preferred Naira's choice over chachi's choice or something like that would be better...but CVs are making soo many efforts for Keerti guriya rani...by showing Keerti should get more importance than Naira in GV and Keerti jaap in SS...

Singhanias aren't mahan and neither are Goenkas really bad ore something, yes they have a bit to learn, but don't we all. I would say Singhanias are like a big tree trunk, which can't be moved a single millimeter by light winds, but can be cracked from between with a strong storm. Like when dadji died, Akshara was accused, she Naitik and children parted from the family. Then Sukanya death leading to Naira leaving. Goenkas are more like reeds, the blow with the slightest breeze but even strong winds cannot do more then blow them to the left or right and then come back once the air is still again. Like Karthik was send away to the hostel, but the family knew where he was. The might have done damad Jaan with creep but when they saw him about to hit Kirti, all stood up for their daughter at once. (Yes Dadi did come in crew's words later on for a while)

I like Goenkas the way they are humanly and flawed but would love to see their character development...you presented a very good example ⭐️...I agree its somehow its KD's guilt for letting Keerti suffer that is making her being biased towards Keerti but KD listening to Surekha chachi without any bossiness is what I didn't expect from KD..

Yes character jaap is wrong be it Akshara, Gayu, Naira or Kirti, of course appreciating the person if it is well deserved is fine, but keep on repeating praises like for Singhanias when Akshara sarre were talked about, they forgot Naira is her daughter and has some right but when sangeet came, they came to Naira for work and started singing praises.

Repetitiveness is what kills the charm...CVs need to understand this...I love Naira's character among ladies even KD, Rajshree nani and choti dadi but I don't want any of my favorite character specifically sherni being appreciated again and again...The more u say it the more it will lose its impact...

Forget marriage track timing, nothing is right about Kirti Naksh track, for me.

Its base is wrong...being based on sacrifice for Naira it is turning more to Goenkas vs Singhanias...They are trying to create balance between Singhanias and Goenkas in a Wrong Way...the balance could be created by involving Kaira only...By giving Keerti more importance than Naira as she suffered a lot is to some extent same scenario when Gayu was compared with Naira or Naira was asked to sacrifice for Gayu by bua dadi and rama dadi...People who suffered in their lives should be made stronger than making them even more weaker or vulnerable that can only happen by treating them the way other members are treated...

anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


@bold KB has rise in viewership and position too despite of competition from KBC and YR its viewership is 2.4...KKB also retained viewership despite competition from KBC...Week before last week during Naira's supposed pregnancy track when YR was in top 5...KB's viewership was same 2.3 as YR is having now...So, competition is still between KB and YRKKH...Viewers who watch daily soap will continue watching daily soap on the same time slot whether KBC's timing coincide with daily soap timing or not...KB and KKB are an example of it...
Edited:
Here KKB and KB Example is given as a reference and not as a comparison...not all shows that comes under the same time slot as KBC are affected

Point is not about kb's viewetship rising.
U need to.take channel sequence into.consideration. most of our networks have zeetv and sony channels just 1.number away.
I use set top box of siti cable here..and we aren't getting starplus since a week. Same is the case with few other cable.networkd in india where either starplus is either 2 or 3 channels away from sony zee or they aren't getting star since a week or so..

Human tendency is u scan through channels and mostly watch two channels in sequence during break and not take pains of typing numbers to reach starplus..
So kbc has definitely affected both yrk and kundali alike.


anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15
And yeah these days i find keesh story and dadi chachi better than the incessant "we are brainless we cant do anything without naira" jaap.naira had this uniqueness of being flawed and thye could have shown her learn things one at a time like akshara did than make her multitalented multitasker machine.. she is a human for godsake..
And yeah..goenkas need not learn anything neither do singhaniyas..each family is unique and goenkas are more.close to reality than singhaniyas..

The balance yrkkh once maintained is now gone.. and the show needs to end before they bring another leap and make naira a 40yo and bring her kid as lead..
Edited by anu023 - 7 years ago
A HUGE FAN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
For me, everyone is out of character. Plus, some storylines are not making any sense and is finished too quick. Also, there's no real family scenes which YRKKH is known for... it is really lacking and missing. I like to see Naira with family scenes for fun... without Kartik.
beatsdongandy thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
the whole problem lies in the marriage of keerti n naksh..thr was no need of this marriage at all.they just had a 3months long kaira vivaah during jan feb march time n again to gain trp makers forcedfully brought this marriage track for which they r giving any kind of logic.the whole keerti falling in love just like that,dadi hurrying up the marriage,naksh saying yes for naira n then boom shadi is happening.yrkkh started getting low trp from the time they forced this marriage track.before that even that irritating kiran's track n naira's dance competition week brought trp n yrkkh was at top 5.problem isnt the naira jaap.yrkkh loyal viewers r known to such jaap.prob is this hapazard marriage.even in arrange marriage such illogical handling doesnt happen.just to show how goenkas arent valuing naira as beti they r devaluing naira as singhania's beti..singhus r more like for us both keerti n naira r equal crap n to show such equality they r devaluing naira.but they gotta understand simplest thing that the only thing that connected with vviewers after hina's departure is kaira..it needs time for keesh or anyone to hv such connect.give them time to even reach that level then do all this "dono jodo me pyar bohot hai" thr was gayu n mishtu who yrkkh target aud r known to but they vanished them like they dont deserve to b in naksh's marriage.cant they give 1single reason?its not like they r maheswari ppl or any relative.gayu mishti used to live in singhania so thr absence needs an explaination.anyways,till the time this illogical marriage ends nothings gonna happen.upar se the character of keerti n naksh went downhill to justify this marriage.the reason y suddenly teej iis been brought up after saying this year wont b any teej.the reason y baby track was brought.starplus should hv realised thr band baaja badhaiyan hv flopped n let yrkkh hhv its own run rather than a forced marriage.this marriage would hv been a fun if it had happened in nov-dec.hope this swarnish kartik track brings trp coz its most imp..if this doesnt work.makers should start thinking for fresh start.
Zara151 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
^Agreed completely, the rush of marriage is a definite no need. Keerti liking Naksh but Naksh only doing marriage for Naira doesn't give enough explanation. If they both had atleast some months to understand each other and give the audience some thinking whether they like the couple or not, but they rushed and the audience doesn't like the couple because of majboori or just that the couple hardly know anything about each other. They should've shown Naira getting fully accepted or becoming a daughter towards dadi first then the keesh marriage. It's all too rushed.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


Regarding Kaira its your personal opinion...I personally love development in Kaira...
@bold well that's the reason...that's why don't like Keesh...specifically Keerti's character...I've been saying this from long time now...I mean a girl with all her vulnerabilities is soo sure of Naksh's feelings? Why she is not confirming his feelings for her? Why she has no vulnerabilities regarding her newly formed relationship? Will it work or not...A girl with previous bitter experience should realistically make sure that this time it will work...Naksh literally has same expression in all the episodes...which is kinda irritating (no offence)
@bold the balance they are trying to create is MAIN problem tbh...they need not show the two chachi's being on their respective daughter side...they need not show Kaira being compared to Keesh...These interlinked relations are main problem...For balancing Naira's importance in GV they are trying to balance Keerti's importance in SS which is not liked as Naira use to be SS's jaan...Now she doesn't even appear their close relative...They can't make Kaira and Keesh fans happy at the same time thought they are trying their level best to do this...


See, I dont see any reason for naira's fans to feel insecure from any couple, keesh do not qualify as a couple at all and by the look of it they will be sidelined soon after marriage like maheshwari s were..At least to make the story better, show some character growth , like maheshwari s were always better than singhania s if we talk of modernity and relations..I don't mind watching only kaira and goenka s if they have a better story ..IMO the only thing that worked and has worked for yr has been it's positivity ..7000 episodes ? Or 6k or 5k, there is no vamp or scheming going on or clichs which a normal indian viewer is subjected to ..I agree it's difficult to retain the interest of the viewers , I'd quit a lot of times n came back..


The format which they work with, the story gets stagnant very quick ..It's difficult to keep pace like this...Show every person getting married and introduce a leap..Yr has and had its loyal audience ..But sometimes I also change the channel thinking Its predictable or repetitive ..I personally love watching the marriage functions n all but it gets boring beyond a point ..Like a n episode on button nai lag raha and parlour wali nai aayi is too much..Just an example...Marriage hai, get over it ..2-3 weeks is ok not more ..Keesh marriage was a high point but it's spoilt already..Kirti is acting total dumbo , like a kg baby , while the family and sister who claim to love each other so much couldn't read naksh 's expression and his hesitation ..Post marriage I am only looking forward to suvarna story n whatever but it's anybody's guess , all mu's will be sorted by naira n goenka will become hum saath saath hai family ..Naira getting pregnant ? She is too young to cRry such a role ..Then what ? Suvarnas son and gayu can get married ..Yawn !


Balance doesn't mean kirti will get equal importance ..From balance I meant , it can't be a one man show..Supporting characters are also important n at least they must be defined well and not deviate , like it's happening with kirti and naksh ...They r trying to show naira as a superwoman who can solve problems for everyone so obviously everyone must be shown dumb to an extent ..It's not right ..Akshara was a superwoman too but there were many strong characters with her ..Gayatri, naitik, her parents , her grandmom..Even rashmi..

Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: anu023

Point is not about kb's viewetship rising.
U need to.take channel sequence into.consideration. most of our networks have zeetv and sony channels just 1.number away.
I use set top box of siti cable here..and we aren't getting starplus since a week. Same is the case with few other cable.networkd in india where either starplus is either 2 or 3 channels away from sony zee or they aren't getting star since a week or so..

Human tendency is u scan through channels and mostly watch two channels in sequence during break and not take pains of typing numbers to reach starplus..
So kbc has definitely affected both yrk and kundali alike.



When a strong good content or interesting content is shown people will make efforts to go past several channels to reach there...KB could get affected but the fact is it didn't it has rise in position too...

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shruthiravi

4 months ago

The Car Ride in melancholy- Repeat of the past for ar ru

When I saw RP and Garvita as ar ru in the car scene today reminiscing Ro, I was taken back to a similar scene in the beginning of s4 which Sheh...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".