Are Woh to main jaanta hun!

C0raline thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

While a lot of discussion happened on the Monday's episode, especially the part where Mukhi said "why Aru needs to work no one seems to have noticed what he said earlier.


And THAT part was the gist of conversation for me. (He elaborated more on this in yesterday's episode). When she said that she can take care of factory without blinking an eyelid he said "Woh to main jaanta hun And that part stayed with me.


It was not just a fond pampering by a husband. It was a trust that she earned from him by her work ethics, grit and determination.


His reason for asking her why she needs to do this, I felt, was different than saying women need not work. He does not look down at any work or has stupid prestige issues. But he does not see her staying here for long and he does not think that she has to pay for her sister's deeds (in action by marrying him, or in amount by paying back the cost of the jewelery)


And I guess in one of the discussions about women working and their's husband's reaction to it, someone (I guess Vi) said about why guys feel it is a strike on their ego.


I think the wording he used "Tuze paise ki kya jaroorat, Jo mera hai wo tera hai instead of "Tuze jo chahiye maang le makes a lot of difference.


The key issue is not if women need to work out to earn money but that they should get respect for the work they do at house too.


My mother had a job as a nurse while my grandmother and my aunt (my dad's elder brother's wife) were homemakers. But this feeling of dependency was never a problem in our household as starting from my grandfather, we had a tradition that the men in the house used to give all their salaries to their wives (to mother before wedding but to wives post wedding) and they managed the house.


In our home it was typical that if a man needs something he used to ask for money from his wife. :-D So it was never an issue who earns the money. It was household money and they were money managers.


P. S. In France, in case of income tax filing, the money earned by all members (husband and wife and dependent kids) is allocated to family and it is allocated half and half to both husband and wife even if the woman is not working outside the home.


(We should stop saying that a woman is not working when she is a homemaker, she does work, just is not getting paid)


Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

650

Users

6

Likes

40

Frequent Posters

cooldreams thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I agree with your perspective and well said. I also love how CVs have been building Mukhi's character and Eijaz is doing complete justice to it. It's extremely rare to see a ML character on TV that exudes so much positivity 👏 and respect for FL. He's truly living up to his promise on wedding day.
C0raline thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: cooldreams

I agree with your perspective and well said. I also love how CVs have been building Mukhi's character and Eijaz is doing complete justice to it. It's extremely rare to see a ML character on TV that exudes so much positivity 👏 and respect for FL. He's truly living up to his promise on wedding day.



And the promise that they showed us from promos.

I will be honest and confess that I am not an Eijaz Khan fan and my reason to see this show were purely those promos. :-D

Not that I did NOT like him or some such things but I did not see much of his earlier work in serials. I saw him in Bhasker Bharati. Some episodes. And I do not remember much else.

Seen him in a few film roles and cameos. I liked him in Tanu weds Manu.

I also had my reservations about Aru's character and Niyati. Aru, I fell in love almost immediately and Niyati grew on me slowly.

I can now safely say I like Eijaz Khan as an actor. His twitter feed is also fun to read. (I rarely go in Jabara fan mode so that is maximum I can say)
A-A-S thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Well said, Coraline!
I liked Mukhi's attitude towards Aru wanting to work in this week's episodes so far. ⭐️

I can understand how ladies in real-life would be pissed off if their husband told them they didn't need to work because "what's mine is yours" and left it at that (or then told them to ask for money or whatever they needed, as you pointed out), but I think you have hit the nail on the head about Mukhi's choice of words and his reasoning and attitude. 😊

I really liked when he said (paraphrasing here) "what's mine is yours, you're my wife" to Aru because it was the first time that he called her his wife instead of the usual "patni mat banne ki koshish kar". The part after that when said that she didn't need to work while she was in the village as she would be gone soon and could work when she was back in the city was good as well, because it made it clear for us that he still expects that she'll be leaving soon, not that he has a problem with her working at all.

And the "woh main jaanta hoon" was good because it shows us how much he has come to respect her abilities, goals, capabilities etc, as you rightly said. ⭐️

What Mukhi said to Rami and Arjan about how they should let Aru work in the factory because Aru wants to work and that's its not a matter of needing more money in the household but "khud ki kamai paise ki baat alag hain" was awesome! A great level of understanding shown here - a very good thing for an Indian show to promote such understanding!!! 👏

And I liked the bit when they were trying to dissuade him from letting Aru the Mukhiyani work in the factory with the other workers and Mukhi spoke about how he helped the farmers with harvesting crops, so why should it be a problem if the Mukhiyani works with the factory workers! So awesome to promote that work is work and no one is better than someone else just because of a title!

And the part when Mukhi told Aru that she was the first lady of their house who was going to work out of the home was awesome (I know I'm using this word a lot!) - another acknowledgement that he does in fact consider her a part of the family/household rather than a visitor (as he used to say before the accident)! Making great strides here since the accident, Mukhi ji! 👏

This reminded me of the first promo for YMMKD in which Aru asks Mukhi what kind of wife he wants, a working girl or a housewife, and he replies by asking what the difference was, as they both work but its only the place of work that is different! That was an awesome promo and I'm glad they've kept up this attitude of Mukhi's in the show itself. Very well done to the story and dialogue writers!!! 👏

Coraline, thanks for sharing the story about your family. 😊
Debashri123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Well, kudos to another wonderful post. This is precisely what I like about this forum...we analyze the character in its entirety even if it requires re-visiting the past episodes...its a wholesome way of looking at the character. Coraline...sending you Hi-Fives from here! for absolutely getting the point bang on!!...and the other members as well...for adding interesting dimensions to her views👏
See, what I particularly believe in is that it is very simple to be a human and much more complex to be a husband or a son or a village head...a man or a woman etc. Mukhiji displays the character of an uncomplicated Human being (that does not mean, he is not layered). He does not bring in any judgment as regards Aru being his wife or a woman or an urban girl...nothing, he just lets her be...and standing by her as her unseen pillar of support...protecting her from evil...and letting her fly to pursue her dreams...almost as an unsung hero!!
These are the kind of unsung men and women that have actually made all the difference in the society...still they remain un-celebrated. Today, we all hail Mary Kom or so many such women...for being women of substance...but the real hero in all of this are their rock-solid and silent support system...whether it is the husband, parents, children et. al.
Instead of being overtly preachy, I find the show conveying this poignant message so neatly...weaving it with the main story line and making the leads as totally hail-worthy...!!
And about Eijaz Khan...I can just say that he was born to play this part!! The casting has been a total winner in this show...Brilliant would be an understatement!!!👏

Edited by Debashri123 - 8 years ago
kuttapu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Wonderful post Coraline
I agree with all your Povs. Mukhiji has full trust in her capabilities and that was never an issue.
You are absolutely right abt the role of a homemaker in a family and there is a new trend of looking down on someone if they want to stay at home and take care of their family. I think it should be a personal choice, if you are in a situation ( financially) to make that choice.
malkasub thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
👏 Another brilliant discussion on this forum!

I have a personal experience here. My parents are both professional - doctors. Equally qualified and equally talented. Never has my father considered that my mom was not around to do her duties at home. He had an equal part in raising us. He is retired now, but mom still works. When I visited them last time, I noticed that when the maid brings his tea and tiffin in the evenings, he finishes it and takes the tray to the kitchen so as not to trouble the maid. He is in his eighties and I have never heard him speak about female emancipation ever. He just lives his life that way.


What I'm trying to say here is about the effect he silently had on the next generation. My brothers both support their working wives completely and participate in raising their children more than their wives actually. (In India) The question of who is bigger does not arise. My brothers never had a mom around to fuss over them and they don't expect their partners to do so either.


I take my hat off to whoever created Mukhiji. The brilliant part of the creation is to make him a villager, so forward in his thinking that he has left all his city-bred, highly educated, feminist supporting guys way behind.


Eijaz Khan has taken Mukhi to a totally new level. His belief in Aru's capabilities reaches a new high. Btw, I tried to look at his earlier shows. Nope, none of them work for me. He is Mukhi inside out. Thats it! ❤️ Like Debashri says 'Brilliant would be an understatement' Hope he gets many awards for this one!


Niyati and Aru - both blend to make this lovable, beautiful, smart, funny and extremely intelligent girl who just goes for it. Notice with how much haq she scolds him for sending such a big tiffin 😆😆

Just love her ❤️.


One more thing about what Aru said yesterday, when he asked her why she needs to work since she is here for a few days only, she just took off - she said 'Aap manaa karr rahe hain???? and she went on about Aru thinks about everyone and noone thinks about Aru"


Not for her the 'self'respect dialogues, or how can u not let a woman work or getting upset or being hurt that she is not being allowed or wondering if this is how life is at Amboli and so on and so forth. NO WAY, she just took off, got her point across and got her way! Just love her for that!


Other shows would have dragged that one point about her working for a few weeks. So proud of this show too!


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".