chaaru26 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
I am disappointed with the yesterday's question and answer session. Vishaka's questions could be justified to an extent because she has to know about Naina and whether she will be the right match for her son, but Naina's response to them did not suit her personality.
The answer to the first question that she loves Sameer and it was not an attraction was good and I expected that the questions that would follow and Naina's answers to them will show Vishaka how much Naina loves Sameer. But unfortunately that didn't happen..

Sameer praised Naina in every way he could before Vishaka met her. He expressed how much he loves her and what she means to him, so the meet should have validated Sameer's praises and love but Naina's answers seemed contradicting. Her answers in no way showed the depth of her love for him. I felt that Naina's answers were more theoretical which did not show the level of love and emotional attachment she has for Sameer. The fbs after her response were contradicting and it could lead to two possible outcomes..

1. She could feel that Naina and Sameer both have their own positives and negatives, that both balance out each other., that one will support the other when they face a difficulty. If Sameer lacks a quality then Naina will fill it in Sameer's life and when Naina lacks something Sameer will fill it. This would be a positive outcome where Vishaka would understand that the other has what one lacks and together they will make their relationship work, that together they would be a perfect match. if she sees it in a holistic way then it could be a plus for Samaina, where both Naina and Sameer together make a perfect match...

2. But there can be another outcome where Vishska might assume that Naina and Sameer are completely different from one another and that they would never be able to work together. She might feel that their thoughts contradict each other. If Sameer thinks in a way then Naina will think in a completely opposite manner. She might see Naina as dominate and Sameer as submissive. She might see them in the long run where they might face compatibility issues.

Whatever Vishaka feels I want her to express it openly with Sameer. If she feels that Naina is not a perfect match for Sameer but still accept her for Sameer's happiness then I want Vishsaka to be clear with it to Sameer. I dont want her to pretend in front of him that Naina is best for him and later on she is confused or worried about Sameer or the relationship. She needs to be frank with whatever she thinks of Naina whether it is positive or negative. If she really finds Naina perfect for Sameer and wholeheartely accepts her then I want her to state why Naina is best for Sameer. I just want VIshaka to communicate with Sameer properly, without hiding any fact or possibility of doubt. Only then Sameer will understand what went wrong or right with the meet and handle the situation with more care.


This is just my POV, yours could be completely different...

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2k

Users

6

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

Ross11 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
Very nice post.
I too felt the same that in Naina's answers something was lacking and said it perfectly what was lacking.
Hope your last para comes true.
soniadutta thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
I totally agree with ur post
Hope we get the clear pic from vishakha side.
sweta2005 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: chaaru26

I am disappointed with the yesterday's question and answer session. Vishaka's questions could be justified to an extent because she has to know about Naina and whether she will be the right match for her son, but Naina's response to them did not suit her personality.

The answer to the first question that she loves Sameer and it was not an attraction was good and I expected that the questions that would follow and Naina's answers to them will show Vishaka how much Naina loves Sameer. But unfortunately that didn't happen..

Sameer praised Naina in every way he could before Vishaka met her. He expressed how much he loves her and what she means to him, so the meet should have validated Sameer's praises and love but Naina's answers seemed contradicting. Her answers in no way showed the depth of her love for him. I felt that Naina's answers were more theoretical which did not show the level of love and emotional attachment she has for Sameer. The fbs after her response were contradicting and it could lead to two possible outcomes..

1. She could feel that Naina and Sameer both have their own positives and negatives, that both balance out each other., that one will support the other when they face a difficulty. If Sameer lacks a quality then Naina will fill it in Sameer's life and when Naina lacks something Sameer will fill it. This would be a positive outcome where Vishaka would understand that the other has what one lacks and together they will make their relationship work, that together they would be a perfect match. if she sees it in a holistic way then it could be a plus for Samaina, where both Naina and Sameer together make a perfect match...

2. But there can be another outcome where Vishska might assume that Naina and Sameer are completely different from one another and that they would never be able to work together. She might feel that their thoughts contradict each other. If Sameer thinks in a way then Naina will think in a completely opposite manner. She might see Naina as dominate and Sameer as submissive. She might see them in the long run where they might face compatibility issues.

Whatever Vishaka feels I want her to express it openly with Sameer. If she feels that Naina is not a perfect match for Sameer but still accept her for Sameer's happiness then I want Vishsaka to be clear with it to Sameer. I dont want her to pretend in front of him that Naina is best for him and later on she is confused or worried about Sameer or the relationship. She needs to be frank with whatever she thinks of Naina whether it is positive or negative. If she really finds Naina perfect for Sameer and wholeheartely accepts her then I want her to state why Naina is best for Sameer. I just want VIshaka to communicate with Sameer properly, without hiding any fact or possibility of doubt. Only then Sameer will understand what went wrong or right with the meet and handle the situation with more care.


This is just my POV, yours could be completely different...


i understand what you are saying ,about Naina not saying much to Vishaka about how much she loves Sameer as compared to Sameer saying bot are different Sameer was saying this to his mom
but Naina met first time Vishaka , that's Sameer's mom,so she cant be so open to her
anu1979 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
Totally agreed. There was a complete lack of depth and her intense love for S instead she came across as an obsessive go-getter !!
mehraan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
Good post!!!
Infact i wud say sme of her answers were likere boasting...jus like the day wen she was scared to meet V n SAM reprimanded that u were confident she wouldnt find a bahu like u ...Naina replies aise hi.bola tha 😆
Till the gussa answer...i found Naina genuine in her replies...but wat followed mei Than leti Hu...i hate harna, failure n Jab kuch galat kiya nahi to darna kya...yes yes i wnt to kno y is she not telling her Family abt it...straightaway...y mkng bahanas n lies always...n y did she break up n even if she did ..y she was marrying Sharad jab kuch galat nahi tha...y the hell DAR KYU LAGA US WAQT??jab kuch galat nahi tha...y chickened out😆 ...if its 4 her father suicide attempt well n gud but later wat followed we all know...😆 Not even one attempt ...n she went shead to marry...Wen u kno ur luv isnt rong...y didnt she muster courage to stop it!!!
Dar tab khatam hua wen Chachaji cme 4ward otherwise Sab galat hai...😆 pyar bi😆

All contradictory answers to wat she hasnt stood firm on...!n mind u no gal wud even say Shakikhor talks or dialogues i dnt like to loose etc etc infront of saas watever the era is or how broadminded the inlaws are...n here we r dealing wit Naina😆

So my nger is on the CVS for spoiling it wit third class dialogues n potraying Naina in tat picture which she isnt in totality...If the talks had the emotional punch about life n love...i guess it wud had sinked much better...but then nothing of tat reflected the deptness or emotions in love...

Havng said my 2 cents...

I really wnt the last para of urs to cme true...i want to kno xactly wat V thinks abt the whole situation...no ambigiuous or round the bush convos...Y has V selected her n on wat basis...!!Mayb some of my confusion wit yests epsdes...the pointers wud be clear...!
Edited by mehraan - 6 years ago
chaaru26 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Ross11

Very nice post.

I too felt the same that in Naina's answers something was lacking and said it perfectly what was lacking.
Hope your last para comes true.



I felt Naina's answers were lacking an emotional connect with Vishaka.
I really want Vishaka to speak properly with Sameer and state why she likes or dislikes Naina.
chaaru26 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: soniadutta

I totally agree with ur post

Hope we get the clear pic from vishakha side.


We need to get a clear pic today itself i cant handle suspense any longer. I hope she doesn't hide anything from Sameer about her talk with Naina
chaaru26 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sweta2005


i understand what you are saying ,about Naina not saying much to Vishaka about how much she loves Sameer as compared to Sameer saying bot are different Sameer was saying this to his mom
but Naina met first time Vishaka , that's Sameer's mom,so she cant be so open to her


I agree she is meeting Sameer's mother for the first time so she will not be able to open up about her love to the extent sameer did. But few of her answers like she was behind Sameer or she would have tried till he accepts her dont go with the story... they seemed quite off and might have created a bad impression on Vishaka...
chaaru26 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: anu1979

Totally agreed. There was a complete lack of depth and her intense love for S instead she came across as an obsessive go-getter !!


Yes her answered seemed she was obsessed with him. But Naina was not like that she really loved him with all her heart

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".