To DESERVE or NOT TO DESERVE - Sameer & Naina - Page 2

The reason behind people no longer visiting this forum is ur posts. I stopped visiting the live update thread.

Originally posted by: Samaina12

The reason behind people no longer visiting this forum is ur posts. I stopped visiting the live update thread.

The kind of negativity u are spreading sir is beyond tolerance now.

As @journalism_worm rightly pointed out, ur posts are too biased.

Nice post Dr.Don. agree to you. . Well analysed points.😊 not redeeemin Nainas character convincingly has been a major fault for now. Let's see if there are any chances of it further post the Swati friendship debacle.

Originally posted by: Bombaysunshine

Nice post Dr.Don. agree to you. . Well analysed points.😊 not redeeemin Nainas character convincingly has been a major fault for now. Let's see if there are any chances of it further post the Swati friendship debacle.

And lets no't make any thread a battleground. Everyone is entitled to an opinion to be conveyed respectfully and without being personal. IF you dont like a post pls ignore it. Making a point about a storyline and character is not negativity.. If people have counterargument pls feel free to share and spread so called positivity. Lets have a healthy discussion rather than fights here..peace.

Originally posted by: Dr.Don

Hey Bombay,

Thanks for sharing your views.

You are right in saying that no thread should be a battleground. We all should respect the view of others as long as the person is putting forward his points in s respectful manner. That's the way debate happens.

The aim of post is clear to anyone who reads it in total. Phase 1, 2 & 3 were superbly done establishing a huge connect with the viewers.

However, as a show watcher I have all the right to mention that the conclusion to tracks have been very loose that robs the show of its hard established hight standards. I am also very irritated with how the writers have been lately not giving proper closing track to my fav character - N which appears to make her completely opposite to what was established as the original Naina.

Originally posted by: Samaina_1990

Doc! Agree with you completely...I'm feeling completely disconnected from the character of Naina as well as the show. I don't even watch it regularly. Sometimes, I force myself to do so when my friends here suggest or due to my loyalty for the show I fell in love with.

The phase 4 that you've pointed out is the root cause of all problems here. Naina had her flaws, but we never expected her to be this selfish. She only had her own self, her dignity, her family in mind, and not once did she think about Sameer. After a point, it felt to me Naina never even thought about him, nor missed him, nor wished to spend her life with him anymore. Yes, she's resigned to her fate, but Sameer deserves a mention in her thoughts, her tears, her diary (she hardly writes!)

She conveniently forgot the way she ditched him when chachaji approved of them and when Sharad turned out to be one MCP! This is what troubles me and makes me feel like switching the TV off everytime I see her face on screen.

At least, CVs could have shown Naina realizing her folly, her selfishness and trying to make up for the pains she caused Sameer, for standing upto her family (even chachaji) for once. If she made Sameer go through all that post the bet, is she not in for a crime of the same gravity as he'd done.

And what was that suicide track. Thoughtless, pointless and Munna asking for forgiveness when he was the only one being sane. Had she gone upto her dad and told him she loves Sameer and will marry him...that...would have been a test of her loyalty.

I don't have hopes for the show now. Trying to relive the characters I admired through the stories on this forum. Rest, Samaina of our show have lost their sparkle! All thanks to the terrible execution since Delhi track, which worsened to the hilt with the breakup phase here.

Sur

Hi Sur,

I completely understand what you are asserting and expressing.

You are one of the biggest fans of the show and wrote the the amazing Mt. Abu series. That was only possible because of the fact that you love the show and connected with it.

Hence you and anyone else can freely express their feeling on how the story is progressing.

However, be careful now when you express your displeasure on the character and story progression. There are some users who ar resorting to personal remarks to justify their views.

On a bright side, I still read the campfire episode of your Mt. Abu story when I want to feel the old S & N romance.

Originally posted by: Dr.Don

Hi Sur,

I completely understand what you are asserting and expressing.

You are one of the biggest fans of the show and wrote the the amazing Mt. Abu series. That was only possible because of the fact that you love the show and connected with it.

Hence you and anyone else can freely express their feeling on how the story is progressing.

However, be careful now when you express your displeasure on the character and story progression. There are some users who ar resorting to personal remarks to justify their views.

On a bright side, I still read the campfire episode of your Mt. Abu story when I want to feel the old S & N romance.

Originally posted by: ruchi3179

I really feel scared to write here.If we dont agree than we become negative.