Are fans being a bit too harsh ? Or is the criticism fair ? (Edited)

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Lavanya

@KumbhkarnKiNani

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Meherya123
You all got so used to pseudo women empowerment in other tv shows hence the outrage. This show is completely realistic for a 90s setting. Don't expect 2018 ish things from this show. Watch it as it is being portrayed.

Fair enough. Look,there's absolutely no need for confrontation or any kind of friction. You having a separate opinion is perfectly alright and I totally respect your POV :-)

The first point about us being used to watching pseudo women empowerment could have been avoided. I'm sure you do not possess the prophetic skills (nobody possesses..😆 ) to know which shows all of us have watched previously.

Also,what we're asking for isn't pseudo women empowerment. All we're asking for is that the core characteristics of the characters shouldn't be dented. As I said,I totally respect your opinion and hence please allow me the liberty to ask you a simple question- We want a toned-down portrayal of Naina..as in we wish to see a Naina who's confident of her relationship and dosen't get jealous at the drop of a hat. How is a confident amd secure (with regards to her feelings) Naina specifically a 2018~ish girl ? Were girls in the 90's not confident ?

Again,I would like to reiterate that I perfectly get the fact that you have a different opinion and hence I respect your POV. I hope we can exchange our thoughts in a polite manner.Afterall criticising dosen't imply that I hate the show.The criticism eventually stems from my love for the show as I do not wish to see its quality being compromised with but unfortunately that is exactly what's been happening since a long time (just my POV..no offence to anyone who thinks otherwise).

Edited by gt2918 - 7 years ago

Quote

tannulove07

@tannulove07

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#12

I think show lost the old charm.. in collage track they just trying to show mature sameer and naina but I think they killed old sameer & naina.

Means jab sameer naina se pyar bhi nahi karta tha tab bhi unke peech ek chemistry thi , spark tha jo dikhta tha par abhi waisa nahi dikhta .

Naina ko bahot jada bold dikha rahe hai aur sameer toh aisa lag raha hai ki use naina main kuch interest hi nahi raha jabardasti wala pyar...

Kuch kuch scane hai waha makers unki chemistry dikhna chahte hai but fail ho rahe hai... collage life pe inta focus kar rahe hai ki sameer naina ki love story bhul gaye hai..

Laga tha ki makers abhi jada concentrate love story pe karenge but sab khichadi ho rahi hai. abhi utna interesting bhi nahi lagta jitna school track main tha.

Aur kitna kuch dikha bhi sameer naina ka dikha bhi nahi rahe hai...

Bahot jada expect kiya tha after patch kuch alag dikhayenge ..

Naina ka pyar show ke starting se dikh raha hai but sameer ka hemesha on-off dikh raha hai.

Naina ne kitna kuch kiya sammer ka pyar pane ki liye but jab sameer ko realize hua tabhi se wedding track chod diya toh itna efforts nahi dikha kidhar bhi..

Bahot jada Expectations hai sameer ki characters se ki woh naina ko feel kare ki wo just uska hai aur kisi ka bhi nahi ho sakta abhi usko apan pyar show karna chahiye.

Show main dikhana chahiye jitna pyar naina sammer se karti hai utna hi pyaar sameer naina se karta hai ( aur baar baar naina ko aisa show kar rahe ki uski koi level hi nahi hai )

Abi tak sirf sameer ka gussa dikhaya hai abhi uska pyaar bhi dikho yaar. Bahot ho gaya

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Pooja

@Samaina12

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#13

So many newbie ids just to bash the show shows how popular the show is getting and how people are trying hard to spread negativity in the name of criticism

Quote

Linee

@PM1774

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#14

Sam is showing sign s of being matured as he was too careless earlier...naina has become less serious in studies and only concentrate on sameer.it happens phases of growing up...so the show is showing the same thing too...I am finding it really apt.sam like a naina too much and is quite possessive too but jealous is not his nature so he is shown differently.in school also naina was really childish...but she was good at studies...but her mental make up was childish only...she will take time to grow up.i really am liking the show now also...it' showing how the relationship is growing ...sometimes some physical aspect of relationship is also shown...do not find anything worth complaining.

Quote

haritha45

@haritha45

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: gugul
Yesterday i was watching some previous episodes... Rakhi tying wala... My god... Those episodes were so nice.. each and every expressions were worth watching and each expression had some message to convey... The activities in classroom.. everything... Nowadays even dialogues are delivered without showing the person who is delivering them... Like the dialogue Hema told pandit after the cassette stealing episode... Even Sameer gave a chocolate to Naina saying a gift for someone you love... That was also not shown...
These are my thoughts...

Earlier episodes were filled with so much of feel and excitement and yes Rakhi episode was biggest turning point of the show.Thanks for reminding me that sequence I'll watch that episode .Samina n Rakesh scenes were power pack

Thanks again I'll watch that episode now 😊

Quote

Lavanya

@KumbhkarnKiNani

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Meherya123
So many newbie ids just to bash the show shows how popular the show is getting and how people are trying hard to spread negativity in the name of criticism

Okay fine. I surrender.

I guess you're true. A relatively new member like me does not have the intellectual calibre to counter 'old' and 'experienced' members like you. I'll not spread negativity anymore.

I thought we could have a good discussion on our conflicting opinions but I forgot that new members like me do not have the brains to speak sense.

Thank you for enlightening me and also for taking out time to give your valuable opinion.

Regards

Quote

Lavanya

@KumbhkarnKiNani

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: PM1774
Sam is showing sign s of being matured as he was too careless earlier...naina has become less serious in studies and only concentrate on sameer.it happens phases of growing up...so the show is showing the same thing too...I am finding it really apt.sam like a naina too much and is quite possessive too but jealous is not his nature so he is shown differently.in school also naina was really childish...but she was good at studies...but her mental make up was childish only...she will take time to grow up.i really am liking the show now also...it' showing how the relationship is growing ...sometimes some physical aspect of relationship is also shown...do not find anything worth complaining.

Thank you for sharing your POV :)

I disagree with it but that's alright. The show is ultimately a commercial product and is bound to be perceived differently by different people.

Edited by gt2918 - 7 years ago

Quote

Linee

@PM1774

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: RinnyManu12

Well said everyone are passing that show is real story and going by realistic approach but many household women how are not aware about Shashi mam and Summit sir story for them it is just a serial which earlier filled with feels and now freshness is missing
College track ka apna ek freshness hota hai but what we are getting only naina jealous since day 1 of college

in the beginnng of the show launch party itself sashi mam said it' not exactly her love story while she has taken few parts from her own love story she also have added some other friends love story and other people life also.sumeet sir was not having any step brother etc but in show sam has.its not exactly what sashi mam is.the story is loosely based on her life but not exactly the same.coming to criticism on aunties watching serials...yes indian aunties are the biggest community in tv viewership and play extremely vital role in trp gain.do remember that the writes or people in this forum is not the entire viewer of this show.the actual viewers are not here commenting in IF.in my office branch there are 40 people and almost 9 people watch this they range from she group 33 till 55.and everyone likes this show till date.they like both sam and naina and are not biased towards

Naina and except for 1 all 8 are woman only.so logic is why so much of criticism.show is good...let' enjoy.

Edited by PM1774 - 7 years ago