Apr 18th: Galtiyon ki Sabakh

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Ross11

@Ross11

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#31

Hi Nivi,

Thanks for review and caps and for these threads warna hamari kaun sunta.

The episode was OK, and I knew it was coming, they have given us back to back awesome epis so it was quite natural considering soap opera.

Agreed Sam and Naina's behaviour on owning faults is different and I think , to understand this parallelism we have to go back to another parallelism of the day both had confessed their mistakes and reactions of others. Naina had Chachaji, a pillar of strength while Vishakha for Sam was wishy washy.

Maybe Naina has chachaji's full support in her mind and it's giving her courage, Sam can't handle it solely. Emotional support is must and I hope Vishakha's actions (not words) after today's hug will give him that emotional support.

Vishakha yeh blue saari roz pehna karo.Mamta ko jagaane wali saari.😆

Daadi ki ek baat to manna padegi, bandi planning zabardast karti hai, itna dimag politics me lagaati toh aaj ex-PM kehlati.kitchen politics ke chakkar me apna career barbad kar baithi.😆

Jokes apart, She had planned well in advance when Mundit had given her filmy gyan, she took filmy revenge. The reason Sam is not caught is his sheer luck and now when he realised his mistakes and becoming responsible Daadi ki yeh khwahish adhoori hi rahegi.

@Kavitha...Rishina Kandhari (Shanti teacher) is PH ki fav, they will cast her in another show. Just like Abha Parmar(Taiji).

Quote

mms1980

@mms1980

Inactive

Posted: 7 years ago

#32

Keshav first tried to get cigarettes from sameer's bag but failed now he searched munna pandit bags without their permission.. is that allowed? No one asked specially vishakha.. why keshav opened their bag.. later it seems she came to know that munna pandit didn't do anything.. then why not to show her taking stand for these slaps they got and this humiliation... not good ..

Also, I feel they should have shown Rohan seeing sameer , munna , pandit innocent masti and feeding each other... that was really required that's just my point of view...

Rakesh .. I don't have words.. just because he was not selected.. he made such a big drama that to a female teacher humiliating like this? Who does this?? I feel too much imp is given to a librarian of school compare to other teachers.., no offense to real librarians just talking about this character...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

umam

@umam

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

#33

NIvi..thanks for the post and the parallel caps tell the story so well..

I liked the epi for the way in which both Naina and Munna stood out 👏⭐️ actually the points that mundit gave to S for taking the blame were convincing..

Vishakha mamatha jaag uthna somehow looked like without a base. Did it take Mundit to land there in dilli, and the cassett incident to take place for her to realize that she is all that her son has in Dilli .. Before the cig incident and this one, she never got an inkling of how lost Sameer is Though I am glad for Sameer to get his mom back, the realization on V's part looked rushed to me..

Those brave words that she will stand by S.. keeping my fingers crossed .. atleast S is assured that his mother is there with him..

Naina - what is she going to reveal.. maybe she will inform that Shanthi teacher took a kasam from her to not to reveal the name of the student, in the student's interest... she will cleverly manage to clear the teacher's name..

Quote

Aisha

@Samaina_16

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: canapoem

Very aptly said Aaisha.

The truth is Vishaka is a very weak person. And her MIL and husband are total bullies.

From what I have understood is, most of the major decisions in the house is taken by Dadi and rest is by Bobby.
Vishaka has no authority or right in the Somani household.

Her only job is to romance Bobby, molly cuddle Rohan and look after Deepika.
As much as I remember, even day to day menu is decided by Dadi. Vishaka is expected to be just a robot.
I feel she has even lost her thinking capabilities by being like that for years together.

She might make promises to Sameer but the next time something wrong happens, she will not raise her objection and she will silently let Dadi or Bobby to take the decision.

And CVs have not even shown us how and why she married Bobby. Who is Sameer's father, we have no clue.

As of now, I don't have any hopes on Vishaka.

@bold: 😆 Sorry, couldn't help but laugh. What a waste of an actor like Vaishnavi. Delhi track could have been easily utilized to answer all our doubts about Vishakha and to bridge the gap between Sam and Vish. One moment she is shown to understand and the very next moment she becomes the silent sanskari bahu again.

I agree, she has no voice in her own house. But now she is well aware of dadi's intentions. If she is smart enough, she w

ould have figured out by now that sameer was right in blaming dadi for his haircut . Sameer is her son. She knows he is all alone here. She knows dadi is plotting against him. Kb tk chup rahengi? Kabhi kabhi jaagne vaali mamta smjh nhi aati😆 . P ar jaisa aapne kaha shayad sochne ki kabiliyat bhi khtm ho gyi h somani sadan me🥱

Vaise instead of rushing through 'sameer ke paas bhi maa hai' vala phase, writers could have shown their slow and natural bonding.

And How many people would have to suffer just to keep Dadi's pride intact? Will they ever show everyone coming to know about all of Dadi's deeds?

😆khud pe hi gussa aa raha hai. Why don't I stop thinking all this?😆

Edited by AaishaM - 7 years ago

Quote

anjalii123

@anjalii123

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: mms1980
Keshav first tried to get cigarettes from sameer's bag but failed now he searched munna pandit bags without their permission.. is that allowed? No one asked specially vishakha.. why keshav opened their bag.. later it seems she came to know that munna pandit didn't do anything.. then why not to show her taking stand for these slaps they got and this humiliation... not good ..

Also, I feel they should have shown Rohan seeing sameer , munna , pandit innocent masti and feeding each other... that was really required that's just my point of view...

Rakesh .. I don't have words.. just because he was not selected.. he made such a big drama that to a female teacher humiliating like this? Who does this?? I feel too much imp is given to a librarian of school compare to other teachers.., no offense to real librarians just talking about this character...

I completely agree with u... Aft Vishaka knowin the truth why cudnt she take a stand for Mundit n question Dadi..n ya Keshav openin Mundits bags is unacceptable..dono wat cvs r tryin to say.. yeh unn dino yaa inn dino, checkin someone's bags witout their permission is definitely unacceptable..
N Rakesh, the cvs have jus made his character unbearable.. I have never seen a librarian have more importance than the school teachers except in PVKM ..Jus becoz he has a loud mouth, every1 gives into his nonsense.. cvs r kinda loosin the plot, no offense to anyone

Quote

sky-if

@sky-if

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: KashafZaroon30

Okay now my PVKM rant- Ek toh padhte nahi...jab dekho tab isko farewell, usko farewell, yeh prep woh prep...Upar se Naina convinced the whole class and Princi for the farewell and also the letter is by a student...Inke Princi ko koi bhi topi pehna ke jaa sakta hai...Rakesh kya cheez hai😆...Podium pe saying aap ne galti ki hai...Hold on beta... you are discipline monitor not the management/trustee of the school...Probably I might be the only one who found her dialogues pretty direct to be said in a function in front of all...that whole scene didn't went down well with me......

@Veda- PVKM rant ke bina mera khaana hazam nahi hota...😆

@bold 😆 I still don't get what the Shanthi teacher fiasco is meant for but totally agree - today it felt like the CVs got so carried away by Naina being the FL that they forgot she is still in school!

PS: Love your commentary about PVKM!😃

Quote

rose1000

@rose1000

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: KashafZaroon30
Like seriously CVs...I'm still trying to figure out what was the need to throw Shaanti away...Anyway they were in 12th...12th khatam, PVKM ke saare characters khatam...Pointless drama...Anyway it's not that this track is for Rakesh to feel guilty...he anyway is going to continue with his tactics irrespective of whatever happens...No Karma for Rakesh and his son any sooner...😕

Zulu I can only think of one reason...Shanti gets kicked out of school. Then she gets a job at a college. The kiddos end up in the same college. So Shanti again becomes their teacher. Rishina continues in the show...

Munna-Pandit are love ...I'm loving M n P more at times than Samaina😆...Infact my sister isn't a regular watcher...but whenever she watches the show she watches only M n P scenes...she is like baaki sab is good but M n P are jaan...

Mundit scenes are truly unique to this show. Leads romance to har show mein hota hai. But this kind of friends are so rarely shown in sabun. 😊

I don't get one thing...Vishakha ki mamta...When exactly is her radar on...when is she keeping a watch on Dadi...Infact she should look after Sameer when she knows Dadi is troubling him...Yeh sab pehle kiya hota toh itna raita na phelta..Ladka bighad ke sudhar bhi gaya aur aunty ko kuchh khabar nahi...One thing is good that she trusts and understands M n P...that was nice...Today again the blue-saree worked its charm...Blue-saree is a very symbolic saree...Very important saree...Dadi ki wajah se hua dhamaal, lekin Vish ki blue saree ne kiya kamaal...

Better not to go looking for too much logic. Sar dard hone lagega. Phir saridon lena padega...Geez..I don't know if they still sell Saridon in India...😆

But Naina seriously felt very guilty...Her scene with Shaanti maam and the VO for it was beautiful...Good to see her guilty...Sam I feel was more confused, feared and plus guilty...he was not able to understand what exactly is happening plus he has fears in his mind...

I thought both Randeep and Sam seem a bit detached from the scene and the emotions...or may be the CVs wrote it badly...or perhaps the direction was bad...

Okay now my PVKM rant- Ek toh padhte nahi...jab dekho tab isko farewell, usko farewell, yeh prep woh prep...Upar se Naina convinced the whole class and Princi for the farewell and also the letter is by a student...Inke Princi ko koi bhi topi pehna ke jaa sakta hai...Rakesh kya cheez hai😆...Podium pe saying aap ne galti ki hai...Hold on beta... you are discipline monitor not the management/trustee of the school...Probably I might be the only one who found her dialogues pretty direct to be said in a function in front of all...that whole scene didn't went down well with me......

PVKM mein sab kuch chalta hai....😆

Precap: I completely second your thoughts...Sameer O bai tu padhle...Padhai karle mann apne aap divert ho jayega...But he working with Radio specially All India Radio to be precise would be good to see..if they show it properly...I love radio in general and AIR scenes with songs would be good...
Believe me the day Sam takes a book and Rohan speaks a substantial dialogue I will declare Eid on this forum..Rohan's character is genuinely good one...simple and sweet ...he is seen to be happy and at times sad for Sam..he even did his bit yesterday...but why aren't CVs utilizing him..it's been 2 months...okay he is a silent and shy character but so much shy ...

I guess even Rohit is wondering why he is not getting dialogues...😆

@Veda- PVKM rant ke bina mera khaana hazam nahi hota...😆

Quote

dixie123

@dixie123

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: angelic567
Hi nivi
After giving us two back to back amazing episodes, cvs again disappointed us with this epi.

The only things i liked are that keshav got slapped, vishakha sameer hug and shanti mam naina conversation.

Daadi and her drama was unbearable... Kitu's acting made it worse... Daadi is a master manipulater and she played her cards well... She slapped mundit and took her revenge on them.

Shanti mam was no less than a mother... Naina said it right, there is one such teacher in everyone's life and its shanti mam for her... Shanti mam wanted to protect naina at any cost... As i said yesterday, she totally earned the respect from her students with her hardwork... Though i don't understand why she said she'll get another job easily... Will this incident not remain as a black mark in her career?... May be she said that to console naina.

I feel vishakha knows the truth but remained silent as she felt its better for mundit to leave... Loved her assuring mundit to be with Sameer always.

Even i felt naina was more remorseful for ber actions than sameer.. She was ready to own up to her actions... She tried even after shanti mam making her promise.

Kids acted more sensible than principal and teachers... They said right, we can't judge anyone based on one incident... Rakesh as usual hopeless... This man only knows to spew venom... I guess shanti mam will refuse to name the student and will walk away with dignity.

What was the need of all this drama in the first place?... Mundit were anyway leaving and shanti mam character could have ended in a dignified manner... Did mundit and shanti mam deserve to be insulted and thrown away like this?... Or as someone mentioned, was it to show that samaina love story has so many people's sacrifices attached to it?... I'm very much disappointed with the way things have turned out... Don't have any more hopes from rohan... I am just waiting for delhi track to end.

Sameer may be wants to stay away from the toxic environment in somani house... Thats why he wants to do a lart time job... Its anyway better than mawaali track.

Hi Simi..

Vishaka remaining silent for me is not done. Her son's best friends are insulted like this and she is still was consoling Mummyji. She will rise only when another catastrophy happens until then she just remains mum.

Quote

-Vibha007-

@-Vibha007-

Voyager

Posted: 7 years ago

#39

Am I the minority who liked what the CVS were trying to show. We sometimes do realize the intensity of our mistakes when our dear ones are affected. Specially Sameer's case. He wasn't that remorseful of his action after Munna slapped him. He is now. He will do everything to correct it now. Sameer probably was thinking what actions to be taken next...so not as emotional as Naina.

Life is the best teacher. The bet fiasco.taught him something and this will too.

I just hope Arjun and Naina had realized the same during the paper chori incident. Galti kare Aur bhokte koi Aur. Hope there is something for Rakesh from all this.

Vishaka- hope we get a scene where vishaka is thinking about a the incidents that happened from day one in Delhi and realize what's her role in how Sameer behaves. He sudden Mamta sprouts will be more meaningful then.

Itne din se hum chahte the ki Sam koi part time job kare..ab bichara constructive kar Raha hai tho Karne do na.

Waise bhi padhaye nahi aati..shayad RJ hi ban Jaye... Dekhna RJ popularity ka credit bhi Lega older Sameer😆.

Quote

dixie123

@dixie123

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: PreetiSJ
Going home from my exam and I know I'll fall asleep as soon as I get on my bed lol so i won't be watching the episode but catching up with your post :)

Seems to have been a terrible episode overall :(
Yeah honestly the shanti teacher track seems a bit random- unless they're just planning on showing samaina truth being revealed to rakesh, but I highly doubt that's going to happen right now. Let's see why they've put this track

Dadi aur keshav ko koi aur kaam nhi hai kya. Had hai yaar
MunDit are true friends. Took the blame without a complaint so that Sameer wouldn't suffer. Yeah Naina will definitely share and hopefully after his recent realization, even sameer will decide to be truthful to Naina. If he owns up to his mistake himself then Naina will not be as hurt. I guess maybe we can assume that she knows? Idk I guess they're just trying to show her in a really positive light now. Which is good but yeah definitely confusing whether or not she knows that MunDit are not the real culprits. Maybe she had suspicions on dadi since she did see Keshav hiding that cigarette packet and warned dadi. She just doesn't have proof yet to speak up.
I'm really happy with sameer vishakhas slowly forming bond. It's much needed to keep Sameer happy. And mother-child bond is a beautiful one that's irreplaceable, so I'm really happy that they're developing it.
Shanti mam is so sweet. Taking all the blame because she knows if Naina is caught it'll be a bigger problem. And naina being equally sweet is going to try to fix the problem of course.
Yeah I agree that Sameers reaction doesn't seem to have been as well played out as Nainas. :/
PVKM bahut khaas hai, yahaan pr kuchh normal nhi hota Lol. And besides if they can have farewell for an expelled teacher, why not cancel classes too haha
Rakesh pisses me off so much honestly.
Maybe part time job? Idk honestly. But as long as he's staying positive I guess it's fine.
Hope tomorrow's episode is better

Hi Preeti ! All the best for your exams.

True, Vishaka didn't have any proof to support MunDit but when will she learn that staying mum is equally wrong. It is like as long as her son is in front of her eyes, she thinks it is enough and she makes efforts in their daily routine life and that is enough for her as of now. I am still not able to understand how oblivious she has been of Sameer and his activities (when he was with the mawali gang)

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 8

Apr 18th: Galtiyon ki Sabakh - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics