Review : Ishita too turned out to be another Shagun in YHM

DesiShowFanatic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Telly Tadka has always come up with some of the best Write-up when it comes to YHM and they have done it again...This is something every YHM fan will agree with even it it pains them to do so.

Check it out!!!!

LINK : REVIEW Ishita-Shagun and abandoning babies


Wondering what the review is about?

That how is it even possible to compare Ishita (Divyanka Tripahi) with Shagun (Anita Hassanandani)?

In what context this comparison made?

Before judging the article or making assumptions based on the title, we do urge our readers to go through the write-up.

Well one look at tonight's episode of Star Plus Yeh Hai Mohabbatein produced by Balaji Telefilms and you will understand that this accusation is not made lightly.

Initially while trying to pen down the title of the review "Ishita too turned out to be another Selfish' Shagun in Yeh Hai Mohabbatein", sounded perfect but then it dawned that that Shagun abandoned her 6 month old baby for her own selfish- self centered reasons whereas Ishita did not or technically did not.

Even though Ishita did not leave behind her new born child for any selfish reasons; when it all boils down she too did exactly what Shagun did several years back - ABANDON her baby; and that is not something viewers expected from Ishita who has always been shown as the epitome of motherhood even when she wasn't one by nature but nurture.

Sure this is the YHM's Writers ways of churning up something new, bringing in more drama, more spice, more angst and probably even more romance between Ishita and Raman (Karan Patel) since they are now separated and almost back to how it all started; but one cannot ignore the fact that history is repeating and once again a baby for no fault of hers was left behind by her mother.

Seeing Pihu (Ruhanika Dhawan) in the precap where she seems to have grown up in the love, care and protection of her Grand-Parents and possibly her Papa brings back memories of how during the early days of the show Ruhi (Ruhanika Dhawan) too grew up in the love and care of the same people with the exception of the Iyers who came in later.

Ruhi was deprived of her parents love at a very young age. He mother left her for a better life and her father though caring and loving, couldn't bring himself about to express that love or even to look at his daughter coz she reminded him of the betrayal and pain given to him by the woman he loved. In Pihu's case we are yet to see how Raman attitude towards the young child all the while sicerely hoping that he does not repeat what he did with Ruhi towards Pihu the latter reminds Raman of the fact that Ishita is no longer with them. On the other hand what we can mention is about Ishita who most definitely robbed her daughter of a mother's love.

Raman said a lot of hurtful things, words that one should never say, one that should not be said to a wife, to a mother, words that would not only break the heart but also crush the soul...in short he crossed a line that should never be crossed. Raman's actions and words can never be justified; however they came from the feeling of loss- of his angel, his daughter Ruhi. But in his blind rage, fury and pain what Raman does not see that it wasn't only he who lost his daughter; Ishita whose world revolves around Ruhi, whose very world is Ruhi too experienced the same loss. But sadly even a glimpse of the realization that they both have lost their child, that there was no point doing the blame game never came from Raman's side and his acid dripped words push Ishita to take a step that she shouldn't have taken no matter what!!!

Having said that nobody does anything unless they want to. Yes, it's true that Raman's words hurt Ishita, it killed something inside her but the moment she became a mother, the moment she held her baby in her arms she was bound to that little child and her every decision should have been keeping her baby in mind. And this is where Ishita failed.

Nobody is perfect, every woman irrespective of her age has a mother or to be specific mother-like qualities embedded with her because that's the way god has created her. Haven't we witnessed a zillion scenes where Ruhi a 6-7 years old girl play the perfect mother to Raman? It's just the way girls/women are. Ishita may not have given birth to Ruhi, or her own child who was born through surrogacy but even then she has always been a mother. She always kept trying to be a better mom and do the best by her children- Ruhi and Adi, she wasn't a pro' but she tried and kept trying because that is what being a mother is all about- it is a constantly learning process where every day you learn something or the other. However when it came to her own child, she did not try; she just left without looking back. And today after 7 years though Ishita feels guilty to some extent because she left her daughter behind the tears she sheds comes from thinking about Raman's words and him tagging her as a bad Mother'. Even today she is still not ready to do right by her child which is to let go everything, break every chain she feels is stopping her and be with her because truly the only thing stopping her is HERSELF.

Whatever Ishita's reasons were big or small when it comes to her baby it should have been inconsequential but it wasn't. She placed everything else above her child and therefore did wrong by the little one, an innocent baby who deserved nothing but the love and care of her mother along with the rest of her family. Raman's words were rude and not something a woman wishes to hear from the man she loves, from the father of her child and that is what pushed her to the edge but ultimately it was Ishita's action of keeping away from Ruhi that truly deprived the little one to grow without a mother for 7 years.

How is that justified or more so how can a mother justify this ?

Still said and done this is a fictional show and everything that happens, almost always takes the viewers on an entertainment filled ride; and therefore one thing is certain that the journey of Ishita uniting with her family, Pihu getting her mother and IshRa getting back each other will be something to look out for provided that the makers use the same charm and magical touch they used when creating YHM in the first place...during what we love to call The Golden Days of Yeh Hai Mohabbatein'.

Author: Vijitha Rajan

Telly Tadka

Edited by DD_Maaneet4ever - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

11.5k

Users

18

Likes

94

Frequent Posters

3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
lovely article agree with each word but yhm golden days pass away will never back
DesiShowFanatic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: 3fra

lovely article agree with each word but yhm golden days pass away will never back



Umeed par duniya kayam hai...Never give up hope buddy 😊
momb24 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
They should blame the makers for their bizarre leap which wasn't needed.
stylish_VJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
I am glad that somebody voiced out the same thing...I get history repeating...but shouldn't you learn something from your past experiences...Ishita leaving behind her new born baby was a shocker for me...No matter what Raman said or did, she should have stayed with her baby...what did that little innocent life, just a few hours old do to deserve this ?- 7 Years with out her mother...without a happy family 😭
stylish_VJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: DD_Maaneet4ever



Umeed par duniya kayam hai...Never give up hope buddy 😊




The only messed up reason I am still watching YHM
Mdwst thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Nice article
I was shocked when she plunged to death.
I wanted her to disappear with the baby and start a new life for her and the baby away from the family and Raman.. Be it bhallas or iyers and then may be .. Maybe unite later.
Having said that" you are not a good mother" that one line pushed her over the edge that led her to do unthinkable ...imo..I'm not supporting her.
Edited by Mdwst - 9 years ago
DivanIshraru thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
finally a correct article
even i said this in a thread
Raman's words although wrong was said in anger.
she should have been angry with raman bt why leave d baby??????
everywhere people are blaming raman.
raman deserves punishment bt not pihu.
vanisree thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Agree with eavh word. Very nice analysis.
ramishi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Mdwst

Nice article
I was shocked when she plunged to death.
I wanted her to disappear with the baby and start a new life for her and the baby away from the family and Raman.. Be it bhallas or iyers and then may be .. Maybe unite later.
Having said that" you are not a good mother" that one line pushed her over the edge that led her to do unthinkable ...imo..I'm not supporting her.

Sorry but if she would have disappeared with the baby only then same people would have said that she deprived the child of fathers and familys love. So the only solution left is... she should have tolerated everything and stayed in the bhalla house with raman for the sake baby only. no offence just my pov

Don't bash me but Xena was also there and to be frank it seems more of her baby than ishitas ( ishita also told Xena is mother as well). So she can also give motherly love to that new born...and i guess that is why she must be staying in bhalla house ( though yet to be confirmed).
But yes she should have thought about others before taking that drastic step like she used to do during the initial stages of the show...that time also she tolerated much more but didn't left bhalla house because of ruhi.
Edited by ramishi - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: -SG- · 12 months ago

Yeh Hai Mohabbatein fame Pankaj Bhatia accuses makers of a TV show of not clearing dues; Aly Goni, Divyanka Tripathi extend support In an...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan · 9 months ago

Anita Hassanandani Says She Was Always Offered Negative Roles During Her 5 Year Hiatus Due to Yeh Hai Mohabbatein's Massive Success! In a new...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan · 4 years ago

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: TheStranger · 2 years ago

Divyanka Tripathi Estimated net worth is around 37 crore Property: apartment in Mumbai, house in Bhopal Cars: Mercedes Benz E- class sedan 75...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Aditi_X · 5 years ago

My retelling of the iconic show Yeh Hai Mohabbatein. Four separate souls -- Raman, Ishita, Ruhi, and Adi -- in four separate cities But somehow...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".