A clarification scene cud hv been dere after d oil bath scene

peace.. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Ok so we all hv been talking abt how abruptly d mani track ended..just some thoughts for my side here..
personally i dint really dislike d comic approach dat cvs took, dey did make some entertaining scenes.. d jail scene or d oil scene..which wudnt hv been so hilarious or even dere if ishra had a heart to heart already bfore..but once raman apologised, cvs cud had added an ishra heart to heart talk scene wherein Raman cud hv clarified his doubts abt d I love u to Mani n d Manisha thing..
Raman suddenly getting so comfortable with Mani looked so odd without Raman's doubts being completely cleared! pata nahin cvs ko kya jaldi padi thi..
Edited by peace.. - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

3.3k

Users

5

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

OfTheHeart thumbnail
Bluffmaster IF Thumbnail Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Star Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: peace..

Ok so we all hv been talking abt how abruptly d mani track ended..just some thoughts for my side here..

personally i dint really dislike d comic approach dat cvs took, dey did make some entertaining scenes.. d jail scene or d oil scene..which wudnt hv been so hilarious or even dere if ishra had a heart to heart already bfore..but once raman apologised, cvs cud had added an ishra heart to heart talk scene wherein Raman cud hv clarified his doubts abt d I love u to Mani n d Manisha thing..
Raman suddenly getting so comfortable with Mani looked so odd without Raman's doubts being completely cleared! pata nahin cvs ko kya jaldi padi thi..



@Bold The thing is that sometimes a couple, any couple doesn't need a clarification or justification, it was clear to Raman that all Ishita did was for him,and once he was clear about that MU, he became friendly with Mani, after all he had nothing against that man, after all, and that cleared everything, sometimes nothing matters, not even a verbal sorry, its just that she knew that he was sorry, yes in real life too, when we are really in love we forgive, not because we are weak or we love them blindly, but its because that we realize this already that, that person is really sorry, and we know them well to know that its their unique way to feel that they are apologetic!

Infact I thought that it was an absolutely natural approach towards the subject, 'Apology'! And its was quite novel in drama and beautiful in execution!

P.S. Its just my POV.😊
Edited by OfTheHeart - 10 years ago
peace.. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: OfTheHeart



@Bold The thing is that sometimes a couple, any couple doesn't need a clarification or justification, it was clear to Raman that all Ishita did was for him,and once he was clear about that MU, he became friendly with Mani, after all he had nothing against that man, after all, and that cleared everything, sometimes nothing matters, not even a verbal sorry, its just that she knew that he was sorry, yes in real life too, when we are really in love we forgive, not because we are weak or we love them blindly, but its because that we realize this already that, that person is really sorry, and we know them well to know that its their unique way to feel that they are apologetic!

Infact I thought that it was an absolutely natural approach towards the subject, 'Apology'! And its was quite novel in drama and beautiful in execution!

P.S. Its just my POV.😊


i really like ur post, and i partially agree too. 😊 But still, Raman has had a tough past, it wud just hv been logical if he clarified everything.. esp her i love you to Mani. And Ishita too shud hv made n effort to know what went that wrong that Raman got soo deeply hurt. Overall i just felt the whole sequence was incomplete, n dere was no harm talking things out properly. 😊
Edited by peace.. - 10 years ago
OfTheHeart thumbnail
Bluffmaster IF Thumbnail Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Star Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: peace..


i really like ur post, and i partially agree too. 😊 But still, Raman has had a tough past, it wud just hv been logical if he clarified everything.. esp her i love you to Mani. And Ishita too shud hv made n effort to know what went that wrong that Raman got soo deeply hurt. Overall i just felt the whole sequence was incomplete, n dere was no harm talking things out properly. 😊



Sometimes incompleteness completes everything... after all nothing is complete right?

You know I have learnt something from Ekta's shows, she never ever leaves anything incomplete, in future you'd be surprised about how she is going to fill the gaps... Trust me, or atleast trust her...😆
peace.. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: OfTheHeart



Sometimes incompleteness completes everything... after all nothing is complete right?

You know I have learnt something from Ekta's shows, she never ever leaves anything incomplete, in future you'd be surprised about how she is going to fill the gaps... Trust me, or atleast trust her...😆


hmm.. really hope so 😊 only thing she shud complete d gap in a good way, cos wid ekta u never know 😆
devilishbiatch thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
I ws thinkin f d same... keeping his acting talent in mind...they cud hv written a beautiful scene for raman...evn b4 he apologized,he shud hv been given a few scenes for introspection...
he had been going through this emotional turmoil for so long now...he deserved a proper closure @least... all his thoughts regarding ishi's infidelity,her comparison wid shagun etc...he needed to think abt it and give a little makover to his thought process...
I think an apology shud hv come after that... wid everything dat he had seen or heard recently..aur kuch nahi toh yahi bol deta..yaar mujhe toh I love u bola nahi aaj tak..use kyun bol diya.. :-P

but no...I guess d script f dese scenes got burnt in that fire...so they casually just skipped it..

bt even ishi behaved like a jerk...maana safai unko dee jaati hai jo khud saaf ho...lekin agar khud saaf ho,toh safai maang toh sakte ho na!!!!
it wsnt as if d whole issue ws abt d madrasi gold ka bracelet...his drunk behaviour on d road,his crying into the pillow, his jaanwar wala behavior...

y was it all forgotten so easily? had she asked, prob he wud semi confessed abt d jealousy et al...or ws she afraid f such a direct confession??

if I trust ekta maai, I hope she gets dat guy back wid whom raman had a man to man talk in the bar.. hopefully someday he wil meet ishra and tel ishi abt wat all raman sed..

haye!! expectations!!

the bottomline for me is that sumthin ws amiss...sumthin that cud & shud hv been so much betr!!
peace.. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: devilishbiatch

I ws thinkin f d same... keeping his acting talent in mind...they cud hv written a beautiful scene for raman...evn b4 he apologized,he shud hv been given a few scenes for introspection...
he had been going through this emotional turmoil for so long now...he deserved a proper closure @least... all his thoughts regarding ishi's infidelity,her comparison wid shagun etc...he needed to think abt it and give a little makover to his thought process...
I think an apology shud hv come after that... wid everything dat he had seen or heard recently..aur kuch nahi toh yahi bol deta..yaar mujhe toh I love u bola nahi aaj tak..use kyun bol diya.. :-P

but no...I guess d script f dese scenes got burnt in that fire...so they casually just skipped it..

bt even ishi behaved like a jerk...maana safai unko dee jaati hai jo khud saaf ho...lekin agar khud saaf ho,toh safai maang toh sakte ho na!!!!
it wsnt as if d whole issue ws abt d madrasi gold ka bracelet...his drunk behaviour on d road,his crying into the pillow, his jaanwar wala behavior...

y was it all forgotten so easily? had she asked, prob he wud semi confessed abt d jealousy et al...or ws she afraid f such a direct confession??

if I trust ekta maai, I hope she gets dat guy back wid whom raman had a man to man talk in the bar.. hopefully someday he wil meet ishra and tel ishi abt wat all raman sed..

haye!! expectations!!

the bottomline for me is that sumthin ws amiss...sumthin that cud & shud hv been so much betr!!


grt post. 😊a lot of important points made there. yes a lot of issues needed to be sorted. wish they had made atleast a one scene resolving n clarifying all issues..
Edited by peace.. - 10 years ago
shravani_2311 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
lets hop fr d best...hw thy fill dis gaps...
avni_19 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: OfTheHeart



@Bold The thing is that sometimes a couple, any couple doesn't need a clarification or justification, it was clear to Raman that all Ishita did was for him,and once he was clear about that MU, he became friendly with Mani, after all he had nothing against that man, after all, and that cleared everything, sometimes nothing matters, not even a verbal sorry, its just that she knew that he was sorry, yes in real life too, when we are really in love we forgive, not because we are weak or we love them blindly, but its because that we realize this already that, that person is really sorry, and we know them well to know that its their unique way to feel that they are apologetic!

Infact I thought that it was an absolutely natural approach towards the subject, 'Apology'! And its was quite novel in drama and beautiful in execution!

P.S. Its just my POV.😊



I AGRREDDD WITH YOU 100%!👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".