When will bhalla start respecting ishita - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

6.9k

Users

27

Likes

121

Frequent Posters

Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#41
@ aimf .
Thanks .

I agree with you . Mrs Bhala's behavior is all about control and insecurities . It's not kitchen politics or hate towards Inshita . she raised Ruhi. And has done great job now someone else's is sharing that bond . This will take some time and trust to love outsider . If they show " Ma wala pyar " towards Ishita then it will be forced and very unrealistic . Love is develop over periods of time . It doesn't flourish over night because she is her daughter in law. Ishita needs to be sensitive about this issue .

There was one episode when mrs Bhalla was upset over Inshita buying vegetables . It wasn't about what Ishita brought . This was sas's control was an issue .In extended families Sas like bahus to ask them . If Ishita had ask her " mummiji what do we need for dinner tonight " would have been perfect .

So we need to be sensitive about these issues which are very real. I loved Mrs Bhalla at the breakfast table after drinking fiasco. I thought they treated her accepting way . It was funny and adorable . I don't think they are leaning towards kitchen politics . I think this relationship has handle well by the writers.
Edited by Heema22 - 11 years ago
-Inferno- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#42
I am going to play Devil's advocate here.
First off, I feel Mrs. Bhalla nor the family is mentally prepared to have a daughter-in-law. I say this since even though Ishu and Raman got married, it was only because they were convinced by Mr.Bhalla that they would not find a better mother for Ruhi. So, in their minds they have a mother for Ruhi, but not a daughter-in-law. And hence, they expect Ishu to only pay attention to Ruhi and not mingle in anyone else's business.
I completely empathize with Ishu though because for her, this is her new family. But, we have to take into account that Bhallas have dealt with Shagun and that was a bad experience in itself.
Personally, I feel Shagun did not only mess up Raman but the whole family in general.

Secondly, I do agree that it's time Mrs. Bhalla lays off her madrasi jabs because sometimes it's too much. But again, it's in her nature to do so. She isn't bad at heart, and I've notice that. She isn't the type to purposely plot against Ishu. No, I have seen Toshiji help Ishita out when she is busy with Ruhi many times. It's just when she gets hyper, she gets defensive. Similar to Raman, he also gets defensive.
I think they all have a complex where they feel that everyone is attacking them and so they retort back with taunts and jabs.
Ishita also when talking about Simmi had no such proof, if she had taken a pic or something then Mrs. Bhalla would have found it more believable.

As a whole though, it will take time and I am glad that they haven't shown an improvement yet. It's too early for everyone to be all nice nice and goody goody to each other especially under the circumstances that IshRa got married. Is Ishita under appreciated? OFCOURSE! But for Bhalla's to acknowledge that, it will take time. AND IT SHOULD take time to make it seem much more natural. The quarrels have died down significantly from before. But, if you are going to remove almost all of it, then there will be no Mrs. Bhalla's character.
Edited by -Inferno- - 11 years ago
SimSimmer thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#43
I don't like the way Toshi ji treats Ishita😲 The way she acts is totally Un- Toshi 😆 I really hope she starts to accept her soon
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Heema22


<font size="3">Sas and Bahu equation is very complicated. Specially this relationship has lots of dynamics. Every Bahu goes though adjustment. .Inshita is new Bahu and she needs some time . It's only 20 days old marriage. There is no love in this marriage, Mrs Bhalla never liked Ishita who insulted her son on live tv . Extremely difficult for mother to respect this kind of women . I give mrs Bhalla lots of credit that she accepted this cross culture marriage for her granddaughter .</font>
<font size="3">I am not found of either mother on the show but respect is earned its Two way street . Ishita knew about Mrs Bhalla eccentricities, she is an educated women she knew what she was getting into .she knew that mrs Bhalla cannot tolerate any criticism from Ishita specially about Simmi her daughters. (Mother's weak point ). Inshita know mr Bhalla is very understanding and sympathetic man .she should have approach him and not Mrs Bhalla . . So she sets herself up for this conflict . We need to know how to avoid conflicts in poor relationships .( education teaches us this )</font>
<font size="3">I personally think , knowing all the problems between two family Ishias is tolerated well by Bhallas .</font>

that's an interesting point and different perspective but then I am saying that they could acknowledge her atleast but ya watching last night she did not have proof against simmi so reaction of mrs bhalla was perfect
eternalasha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: aimf

@ Heema

You make very valid points, and I like how you have worded them. I also like that this show is not really focusing on kitchen politics in a typical sas-bahu way. Instead, at least till now, we have some layers and nuances in various relationships that you point out, such as the control issue, and and also the fine-tuned egos of the personalities involved.

@asha

I liked your observations also.


I think that adjustment takes time, especially since 2 hostile families have got together, and two people who absolutely detested each other got married. Let us not forget all that happened between the neighbours, specifically between Ishita and Raman before the wedding, even leading right up to it. Further, there are continued misunderstandings even as people are trying to adjust to one another. Ishita herself has been quite high and mighty and only now is she slowly learning to relate to the various bhallas. I also think it is a cultural issue. South Indians do not tend to be very vocal about their thoughts or feelings in general and can be rather private, giving off the vibe to non-southerners that they are aloof and snobbish. North Indians, on the other hand might be more expressive and demonstrative both of positive and negative feelings. It will take some time to plumb through the depths of baggage of cultural morass that each person carries and to take steps to understand the other.




you makes some great points aimf and Heema
  • they already had acrimonious baggage and hurts due to each other prior to the marriage; just because they are married all of sudden, they won't forget because the subconscious remembers.
  • cultural morass - yes we inherit a lot of it from our parents and the community we live - a fish doesn't realize it is swimming in water until it is pulled out of it and gets perspective
  • the Toshiji-Ishita equation is only a typical saas-bahu relationship on the surface
  • when people have positional views or a need to be right, they back themselves into a corner and their ego makes them respond with akad and fights out of the blue


I guess its not a simple situation and will take time to unravel itself

@inferno - vary valid point re: "Mrs. Bhalla nor the family is mentally prepared to have a daughter-in-law...So, in their minds they have a mother for Ruhi, but not a daughter-in-law."

Edited by eternalasha - 11 years ago
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: --mancityfan--

that's an interesting point and different perspective but then I am saying that they could acknowledge her atleast but ya watching last night she did not have proof against simmi so reaction of mrs bhalla was perfect


Hi mancityfan 🤗Sorry I do not know your name but you as a thread maker I really appreciate your response . I know our opinion on topic are very different but you were polite to acknowledge it . I appreciate this .thanks .

I am frustrated with this forum . I think as a thread maker ( anyone ) , person should respect others opinion and respond to posts on that thread . Most posts with different opinions are ignored by thread maker . This is very rude in my opinion . .every one doesn't not agree with every thing you say .. It's okay to disagree with the thoughts or opinions expressed by other people. . . Learn to recognize others posts ( when they are expressing different POV) when you read it, even if it means overcoming your pride and opening your mind beyond what is comfortable This is not directed to you as thread maker . I think you have done well . I just wanted to express my frustrations that all. .
. Everyone wants to see Brainless romance and leads falling in love. But this show is about mature love not about teenage romance . It will be very boring if mrs Bhalla starts loving Ishita at this time . It's not her personality . Lady does not talk behind anyones back she is upfront and loud . They both need time to adjust .

Edited by Heema22 - 11 years ago
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Heema22



<font size="3">Hi mancityfan 🤗Sorry I do not know your name but you as a thread maker I really appreciate your response . I know our opinion on topic are very different but you were polite to acknowledge it . I appreciate this .thanks .</font>

<font size="3"> I am frustrated with this forum . I think as a thread maker ( anyone ) , person should respect others opinion and respond to posts on that thread . Most posts with different opinions are ignored by thread maker . This is very rude in my opinion . . Learn to recognize posts when you read it, even if it means overcoming your pride and opening your mind beyond what is comfortable. Every one doesn't not agree with every thing you say .. It's okay to disagree with the thoughts or opinions expressed by other people. . . Learn to recognize others posts ( when they are expressing different POV) when you read it, even if it


means overcoming your pride and opening your mind beyond what is comfortable</font><font size="3">This is not directed to you as thread maker . I think you have done well . I just wanted to express my frustrations that all. .</font>
<font size="3">. Everyone wants to see Brainless romance and leads falling in love. But this show is about mature love not about teenage romance . It will be very boring if mrs Bhalla starts loving Ishita at this time . It's not her personality . Lady does not talk behind anyones back she is upfront and loud . They both need time to adjust .</font>




Hello thanks for replying

Well I like ishita and divyanka more but I don't make post. Supporting her always and I post as I see it or episode as I see it per episode thats why my posts fluctuate wildly so I praise as well as criticise and as far as ignoring post go well I know that well as my critical post don't get that many replies and as far me go I reply to everyone whether I agree or not so that that and all views are welcome and anyway thanks for replying
pilot100 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#48
I dont think the bhallas are misbehaving with ishita in any way, ishita is still as strong and independent as she was before marriage, she does what she wants and also speaks what she wants, the bhallas dont dominate her in any way and morever ishita is the one who has chosen this life, they never begged or cried before her to marry raman, on the marriage day if she wanted she could have backed out,but still she chose to marry raman! Ishita herself says that this marriage is only for ruhi, then why does she poke her nose in others affairs! For the bhallas ishita is only a liability whom they are tolerating only for ruhi! I feel ishita is the root cause for all the problems that the bhallas faced, and somewhere i do agree with mrs bhalla that she always tries to find fault in raman and loves to pounce on him!
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
I think Toshiji and Ishita need to bond...one of these days when its just Toshiji and Ishita at home, Ishu needs to make some "cold drinks" for the both of them and let it all out 😆 Toshiji never has to find out that Ishu was just pretending to be drunk 😉
ipkkndmoments thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#50
Totally agree!! It's sad when you see someone trying really hard to fit in but they continue to feel like an outsider😒...Ishita needs to be respected, and not treated as a third wheel 👎🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".