Can't wait to see the FINALS !

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

TheUltimate

@TheUltimate

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

It is more hilarious than confusing when a person cannot come up with a solid reason why Geet won.

To tell that Geet won because he was humble is equivalent to saying that everybody else lost because they were not humble.

To tell that Geet won because people despise Sonu/SLB is reaffirming that Geet did not win because of his singing abilities.

To tell that Geet won because of his good singing will require a lot of data to back up.

To tell that Geet won because he got the highest number of votes is the most logical.

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: suresh555
Goodness always wins. Geet was humble and polite despite being treated rudely.

Some people voted for Geet because they liked his singing

Some people voted for Geet to spite Sonu & SLB for the dirty politics against Geet for a show which was more about judges ego rather than the talent anyway

Everything is fair in love and war

Some people need to read properly to understand the message 😆

The votes from the first "some people" plus the votes from second "some people" is equal to all the votes that may have gotten Geet to win

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shivani

@shivani003

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Seema's only 17. This really is just the beginning for her. U never know maybe SLB might give her a break like he did to Shreya. I also wish to see Nirmitee in future. Kaaash they would come to New Zealand...

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: shivani003
Seema's only 17. This really is just the beginning for her. U never know maybe SLB might give her a break like he did to Shreya. I also wish to see Nirmitee in future. Kaaash they would come to New Zealand...

I think Nirmitee is already singing for SLB in his movie My friend Pinto. I also feel that SLB will give Seema a break in his next big movie. SLB has always been a fan of Lata's voice, in fact I had read somewhere that he had wanted Lata to sing for him in Guzarish and also the Maar dala song from Devdas.

Quote

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: suresh555

I think Nirmitee is already singing for SLB in his movie My friend Pinto. I also feel that SLB will give Seema a break in his next big movie. SLB has always been a fan of Lata's voice, in fact I had read somewhere that he had wanted Lata to sing for him in Guzarish and also the Maar dala song from Devdas.

Well currently Shreya rules the lady playback singing. But these days they need a lot of voice types or "modern" songs.

Seema has proven in one popular song type but has to brush up in other areas. She will do well.

Quote

TheUltimate

@TheUltimate

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Some people need to shut their hole if they do not know what are they talking about without any data to validate their outrageously pathetic claims. 😆

NO - there is no data that proves that people voted for Geet because they hated SLB or Sonu or they loved Geet's singing. All speculations.

There are two facts - Geet won and Geet won because he got the most number of votes. Period.

Just like saying that some people may have voted for Geet because they liked his demeanor.

Some peoplemay have voted for Geet because they did not want Seema to win.

Some people may have voted for Geet because they did not want Sajda Sisters to win.

Some people may have voted for Geet because they found his name cute.

Some people may have voted for Geet because he is from their region.

Some people may have voted for Geet because they were suffering from ultra reverse psycho garden variety post-partum depression.

See how speculation works?

Heck, I remember a poster was 100% confident that Kartar is going to win it all because the show was rigged. 😆

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Summer3
Well currently Shreya rules the lady playback singing. But these days they need a lot of voice types or "modern" songs.
Seema has proven in one popular song type but has to brush up in other areas. She will do well.

I'am sure with more experience, that will come. Remember how Shreya used to sing certain type songs and after more experience, she experimented with songs like Yeh Ishq hai and Zoobi doobi and did a great job.

I'd love to see Seema sing for the Yash Chopra's film that he is directing with SRK-Katrina-Anushka. Yash loves Lata type romantic numbers and with Seema singing for A R Rahman would be amazing

Quote

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Yes Seema's raw talent should not be wasted. She needs some good guidance and persons like Shreya and Sonu ji will be able to help a lot.

Wish her all the best.

Quote

Shivani

@shivani003

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: suresh555

I think Nirmitee is already singing for SLB in his movie My friend Pinto. I also feel that SLB will give Seema a break in his next big movie. SLB has always been a fan of Lata's voice, in fact I had read somewhere that he had wanted Lata to sing for him in Guzarish and also the Maar dala song from Devdas.

Really? Thats great! Didnt know that... Cant wait 😃

Yea I figured he loves Lata and hence why he loves Seema. But I dont really like her voice in non-Lata songs. It sounds a bit boyish when she sings Sunidhi type of songs. I just hope that her voice matures nicely so its bearable to hear her in other genres too.