IF X-Factor Voting Closed :) - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

98

Views

7.2k

Users

21

Likes

303

Frequent Posters

_Anonymous_ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#11
If giving ratings from 7 to 10 is considered "harsh".. imagine if I start throwing out 3's and 2's 😆
I tried to be as honest as possible, please don't get offended.. I'm not Lata Mangeshkar that I have the right to judge when I can't even hold a note myself.. Honestly its easy to judge and pretend you know the encyclopedia of music.. but its hard as hell to participate and even attempt to do what you guys did. Great Job to all of you and it was really a lot of fun to listen to you all so please don't take the comments to heart.

1) 9 – Great Job! You have a VERY sweet voice; it's like a pro playback awaaz. I did take a point off for the echo and the additional music, I felt you put a lot of work and thought into it to make it perfect so I appreciate that but I think at the same time it did put the other singers at a disadvantage for not having the same program. I feel like music can hide the rawness of a voice as well as faults but still I loved it.

2) 9 – I loved it! I love the original song so much and you totally remixed it up with the music and how you echoed (is that the right term? :s), VERY creative! BUT just as I said for #1, the music and the alterations can hide the faults you may have made, therefore I prefer raw voices without music more, it makes it easier to judge the voice and not the presentation and allow us to rate with more fairness. I wish you had sung more though, I enjoyed it :D

3) 5 – I appreciate how expressive you were and really attempted to bring across the "feel" of the song but at the same time I felt this wasn't the right song choice for your voice. I felt each word was a strain on your voice and there was a lot of deep breathing/gasps , I'm not even sure what to call it lol, that didn't work well with the song. Plus I thought some of the lyrics were missing or unclear. I think you have the potential to definitely get better and it was a good attempt.

4) 6 – It was a great attempt for sure, I thought you sang really well but I don't think it suited your voice and seemed a bit rushed through.

5) 7 – You have a very innocent and baby-ish voice LOL I thought it was a little 5 year old girl singing for a second, don't take it as an offense! Its cute LOL. You sang really well in some places, other times it felt as if you weren't singing but just saying the words and then there were parts where you lost sur. You definitely have the potential to playback for little girls for SURE :D The audio wasn't clear plus as I said for #1 and #2, I definitely prefer raw voices without music so a point was taken off for that as well. It was a great attempt.

6) 9 – LOVED IT! Especially the fact that you didn't have music and that you said Bahar a few times (YAY! LOL) made me love it even more. I could hear your voice clearly and enjoy it just as much. You sang really well and I felt it was a smart song choice as it suited you well but I felt it was an easy song to sing in general, good job!

7) 10 – Clear, clean and raw voice without music. Perfect. Sweet voice as welI, loved it! And I personally don't like the original song but I love how you sang it with such patience and "tehrao". Fantastic!

8) 5 – I like your voice but I think you took way too many unnecessary harkats (uff is that the right term?) that threw off your sur. Your words were slurred together, incomprehensible at times, seemed strained and near the end it didn't sound as singing but yelling. Sunidhi's songs are extremely tough to attempt in general so I definitely appreciate the risk you took and I think you really have the potential to grow as you do have a nice voice.

9) 11 – I'm going to try to cheat and try to give you an 11, hopefully I can get away with it! All I can say is, please teach me! The best singer out of everyone and I really hope you win! Perfect.

10) 6 – That's a tough song to sing for sure, I felt you could have sung much better and it seemed as if you were singing from your throat so it didn't come across that well. I felt like you could have tried a different song better suited for your voice, that would have worked more in your favor. It was a really nice attempt and a change from the rest of the songs.

11) 9 – The music overpowered your voice to the point where I couldn't hear a few words in the beginning but whatever I could hear I loved! Some parts especially were just fantastic! Great job, loved it!

12) 6 – You said unki instead of uski :P It was a really nice attempt, pretty rushed through but you definitely have some potential in you. Plus I think you should have sung more than a minute at least as some singers had to be judged upon 2-5 minutes of singing. You have a nice voice and you could work well with it if you brought more calmness in it when singing.

13) 6 – Great Attempt, there were definitely parts where you went offkey and lost sur. I loved the sonu picture you used btw <3 LOL. I didn't think the echo worked well with the song and I rather you had sung without any music. I appreciate the work you put into presenting it and your soft voice did help with the feel of the song but there is definitely room for improvement.

14) 7 – awww another cute innocent baby-ish voice. You could definitely playback for a 5 yr old girl, just like #5.. LOL you guys should pair up and sing sweet kiddy songs together :D. I wish you had sung more as most of the other singers sang 2-5 minutes. It was a sweet song and it fit your voice well.

Edited by _Anonymous_ - 14 years ago
tulipbaby53 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
I say: Give the scores as you feel. It doesn't matter what people rate you b/c it's not like if you get a 1/10 on IF X Factor you have failed at life or something 😆 Unless if IF is your life, then I suggest you get a good therapist. 😃 😆
Edited by tulipbaby53 - 14 years ago
MyInspirationz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#13


THIS IS A "MEMBERS ONLY" POST
The Author of this post have chosen to restrict the content of this Post to members only.


pinkisluv91 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Okay so I really don't know how to lie or be a sweet judge, so I'm judging all of you like I don't know you guys:) I hope I don't offend anyone:) Sorry if I do:)

1) 9 points- You're pretty amazing⭐️ I'll ask the same question CPR asked, have you used any "tools"? I kind of hear an echo to your song😆 but wow, you're great👍🏼 Good job😎

2) 8 points- The music you've added was quite distracting, I think I couldn't hear your voice properly in the beginning and in some parts of the song😳 that's why I subtracted 2 points from your score:) Other than that you were great, you have a nice voice😃

3) 5 points- Okay you have a great voice and you could do really well with practice, but in the beginning you were talking😆 and you've got some of the lyrics wrong(idk if we're concentrating on lyrics though) and you need to ease up on the H's, you add H sounds in every word that doesn't require em. overall you were average😃

4) 6 points- You have a nice voice as well, with practice you could be great:) Your sur's kind of shaky:) You can improve on it:)

5) 7 points- You've got a nice voice, the music was a bit too much😆 like I was like, when will I hear singing😆 You kind of rushed through parts of the song:) You could work on your sur too:) Good job though

6) 8 points- I liked how you sang without music, so we could hear your voice clearly:) You were good 👍🏼

7) 1 point- good song choice - sung by the legends lata and kishore⭐️they are so amazing, who can ever reach their great heights. but one point for trying😛

8) 6 points- You have that classical voice, which I like:) I think you could work on the sur:) You have potential 👍🏼

9) 10 points- This is seriously amazing singing 😍 The classical voice, the bhajan just lovely👍🏼 My fave out of all the songs AMAZING job 😎👏

10) 7 points- Broadway, it's a good change after all the bollywood songs😆 I really don't know how to judge this one😆 Good job👍🏼

11) 9 points- Okay you have a great voice👍🏼 and I loveed the song⭐️ You were so amazing esp in some parts:) Fantastic 👍🏼

12) 6 points- You're a cute singer😆 but you need to put emotions and feeling into your song:) I felt like you sped through the song😆 Good attempt 👍🏼

13) 7 points- Have you added an echo to your song?😆 You're pretty awesome:) You've got a nice innocent voice😃

14) 8 points- You have such a pretty voice ⭐️, I wanted to hear more of your singing though:) It was kind of short😆 Awesome job 👍🏼

I'm proud of everyone for having the guts to participate:)) I was as honest as I could be without being mean:) I'm sorry if I hurt anyone 😳
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
Hey Monica so you are No 7. Loved it. 👏

I wonder which one is Pimp Sis ??????? 👏
MyInspirationz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#16
Bhai.. your song was good too.. I had already told you ... 😊
xobile thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
1. 8/10
2. 6/10
3. 3/10
4. 3/10
5. 5/10 - the thing that majorly pulled you down was the hight notes, otherwise the expressions and midoctave singing were quite good.
6. 6/10 - pronunciation could have been better, otherwise very good
7. 7/10
8. 4/10 - the techniques used were good in parts but not suited to this genre
9. 10/10
10. 4/10 - nice voice, but in broadway songs you need to work extra hard to bring out the melody otherwise they can sound like a soliloquy
11. 9/10 - great song choice and singing, the poor recording quality let you down slightly
12. 3/10
13. 5/10 - nice simple singing. good voice.
14. 5/10 - one of the best voices here, but you kept changing scale and went off a few times
Edited by xobile - 14 years ago
ani_gr thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
Ok.. here is my scoring:
# 1 - 8.50 - very good singing😃
# 2 - 8 - there were disturbances, but it great.. 😃
# 3 - 5 - still work more.. can do it..
# 4 - 6 - Practice.. there is room for improvement..😃
# 5 - 7 - nice voice.😃
# 6 - 8 great..😃
# 7 - 9.5 - wonderful, fantastic, innocent voice... keep up the great singing..😃 👍🏼
# 8 - 7.5 - u definitely hv a great voice and classical touch.. just lil bit more practise needed..😃
# 9 - 8 - lot more practice needed
# 10 - 7 - liked it😃
# 11 - 9 - fantastic voice quality😃
# 12 - 7 - cute singing..loved it.. 😃
# 13 - 7 - great singing.. 😃
# 14 - 8 - great voice.. nice singing.. 😃
good luck to every one...😃
RagMasta thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53

I say: Give the scores as you feel. It doesn't matter what people rate you b/c it's not like if you get a 1/10 on IF X Factor you have failed at life or something 😆 Unless if IF is your life, then I suggest you get a good therapist. 😃 😆



This song is dedicated to all of the participants😳😆..i would be such a bad judge..give all tens😆

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzE1mX4Px0I[/YOUTUBE]

ThatOneGuy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: raju786



This song is dedicated to all of the participants😳😆..i would be such a bad judge..give all tens😆

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzE1mX4Px0I[/YOUTUBE]


Dude this is scary...my sister was JUST listening to this on loudspeakers and I told her to STFU 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".