tanya's prob....

anushe khan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

In the precap they showed that bottle in tanya's hand and I think she was about to drink..from it...what do you think....will trish save her and would come to know what tanya was doing.....or trish would just think that she is taking medicine before eating anything.....coz they showed food and then trish.....and tanya......Do yout hink trish would stop her doing that...I think she would ask tanya why she is taking medicine without eating anything and then tanya would stop it and then rethink it and wouldnt abort the baby.....I dont think tanya has courage to do so......coz she is very kind...but somehow I think that she will have a miscarriage the time she would be feeling attached to this baby ....................coz.......when kul was praying I thought that can happen...Im agianst abortion but this child would be suffering all his life......I think tanya shouldnt abort the baby herself...that would show that she has weak character......though that will bring to much pain if she keeps the baby......I loved the way that trish is so kind to her sister......what would be raj's reaction if he comes to know that tanya was going to abort the baby.....I think he would be definitely mad at tanya.....

Somehow I think kahniya is coming back soon...he will hear from someone that tanya is pregnant and the pregnancy is before even before she got married...and he would create probs for tanya and that would be a cause....of her miscarriage........I really hate to see those things...coz the baby is innocent....if kul would have taken tanya right away to the doc that wouldnt have happened.....poor tanya..now sujata and her dad would get even more angry when they would come to know that she is pregnant for two months.........Also nupur and co might play a part to make it worst ........I really want them to show tanya being happy...she cries almost in every episode........

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

Totally agree! Even though the smartest thing to do would be abortion but still that would ruin Tanya's character. I am still praying she would have a miscarriage by accident.

smayat thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
i know..they need to show that for once Tanya is happy for herself..i really think they shouldnt kill the baby..
gp00 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
She cries a lot? She cries every stinkin' day. Not that she has no reason to.

My core belief is that Tanya is Jell-O, mold her any way you want, tell her what to do and save the poor girl from having to think for herself. I will not deny she has been through a lot, probably more than I could imagine. But, all I see, when I think of Tanya is: head down or mouth agape, and really confused looks should anything come up. She's confused (aka traumatized, right) and I get confused looking at her, seriously.
Obviously, I never expected her to be Trishna Jr., but something, anything would be nice (like the holding of Trishna's hand but showing humility), having a strong opinion, or even an opinion.

With the baby, I'm torn. I'm not torn between what is right and wrong because in this situation, it's hard to see absolutes, black or white, good or evil. And it has nothing to do with her character. A woman who has an abortion still has character, there is no black mark. Whose business is it anyway?

Look, given she's "married" and Yuv wants the innocent. Her mother says do not have this baby as it will ruin your life or put the baby at risk too (Kanaiya returning). Tanya was never able to reach inside herself and carefully think about what she feels and what she should do. Kanaiya causing a miscarriage is "guilt-free" (forgive the coarse word, but I think you understand the meaning). But Tanya will have to make the decision. And while I'm leaning towards abortion, I can understand why she, as a married woman, and Yuv would want to keep the child which really is an innocent. Noone can doubt that. But what do you tell the child about its father? What if Kanaiya reveals everything? The baby is the final link with Kanaiya, although he is a psychopath and would go after Tanya and Yuv anyway.
Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

I agree with most of what you said. She needs to have a strong opinion. I used to cry a lot , that's because I am too emotional but that didn't mean I didn't have an opinion. Her character is just too nice. She is not confused. Maybe you are not undertsnading it, that's why you are confused. She is just too nice for her own good. She doesn't know how to say no. She always thinks about others that's why she ends up crying even more. She is also not like jello. She likes making her own decision though they might not work towards her best interest. Others get involved on their own and she is too weak plus nice to fight it. So no she is not confused. It's not that she can't strong, we have seen her be strong and mean but she only does it when others are concerned.

Abortion is the right step here. Yes the baby is innocent and I am 100% against abortion but I really don't want Tanya to carry a part of Kanaiyah. She might even love the child so much she will forget it's the result of a rape but it would be hard for me to forget she is tied to Kanaiyah through that child.

I do see it ruining Tanya's character. Not because the decision of aborting the child would be wrong but because it's not Tanya. As we always say she is an angel. The girl is the nicest person on that show. She is always putting others before herself, it's not right to be that selfless but that's who she is and it makes me love her even more. If she aborted the child because of her own benefit her character won't be the same. So I am praying she will have a miscarriage and not abort herself.

minuu thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

Totally agree! Even though the smartest thing to do would be abortion but still that would ruin Tanya's character. I am still praying she would have a miscarriage by accident.


I agree with you Fatima, I really feel bad for tanya!
SahirsBeard thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
yha, I wish so too.....
Its not fair! How come shes the only one who suffers!!!?
(well, I guess everyone else does too.... but she suffered the most...) 😒
-dhruvi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: veera25

yha, I wish so too.....
Its not fair! How come shes the only one who suffers!!!?
(well, I guess everyone else does too.... but she suffered the most...) 😒

she does, i want to see her happy
[in love happy mostly 😳]
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Even if she goes for abortion that won't spoil her character...she has suffered a lot now and the baby will always remind her of that horrible day in her life....if she doesn't want to give birth then she should go ahead with the abortion...infact i am totally disappointed with yuv.....he should support her decision rather than forcing his decision on her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".